7 ms·
Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statement on misinformation
- hadrien01 7y agoTechcrunch redirects me to guce.advertising.com, is there an alternative link? Edit: Oh apparently it's just this paragraph (found it on about.fb.com): > “We are working closely together on COVID-19 response efforts. We’re helping millions of people stay connected while also jointly combating fraud and misinformation about the virus, elevating authoritative content on our platforms, and sharing critical updates in coordination with government healthcare agencies around the world. We invite other companies to join us as we work to keep our communities healthy and safe.”
- aembleton 7y agoI had to whitelist guce.advertising.com. Couldn't find any way around it.
- close04 7y agoThe way I approached this was to avoid anything that has to do with techcrunch. I am more than happy to read the comments on such postings but no way in hell am I clicking on that intentional dumpster fire of trackers, advertisement, convoluted consent forms, etc. I can't help but treat that site as malicious. The fact that such links/sites still end up top of the front page on a site like HN is a bit surprising for me.
- stiray 7y agoI am having workaround for moths. I am not using techcrunch any more. If there are some relevant news, they will be soon on some other site, that is not anti-users oriented. Vote with you "wallet" or soon all the sites will be like this.
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> elevating authoritative content on our platforms That's quite orwellian of them. Oh that explains recent lack of facebook hitpieces by the "authoritative sources". I swear everytime the "authoritative sources" attacked facebook, reddit, google, twitter, youtube, etc, they "elevated authoritative content by authoritative sources" and gave them preferential treatment and magically the hitpieces stop. Also, rather than offering joint statements and colluding together, I'd rather these social media platforms compete to provide the best information. There is just too much collusion by big tech. We need competition.
- meritt 7y agoThis is a great move but I hope everyone is ready to hear a lot of "those west coast liberals are suppressing our freedom of speech!" for the foreseeable future.
- ta999999171 7y agoWhy is it a great move?
- krapp 7y agoWhat else is new? Anything short of allowing misinformation, hate and propaganda to run rampant on all channels is an inevitable slippery slope towards an Orwellian fascist dystopia, no nuance can possibly exist. Either we let the trolls, cranks and Nazis take over or it's the camps for us all. It's become the CMB of the internet at this point.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMore about how west coast liberals need a carefully crafted stream of information. People don't like it because it seems infantile.
- jakeogh 7y agodata: https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6 https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.h...
- tasogare 7y agoWhat will they do concretely? They already missed a window of 2 months ago where they could have had an impact by censuring WHO, European governments and news agency that were spreading fake news in the like of "it's just a flu", "2% mortality".
- avip 7y agoIt's in the statement. Elevate official and authoritative information over fake news and lies.
- paganel 7y ago"Official and authoritative information" in Germany is that only 17 people have died out of the 7500+ officially infected with the virus, with "official information" like that it's not hard for "unofficial information" to be closer to the truth on the ground.
- close04 7y agoAre you using intuition to say that the numbers can't be right or some knowledge of real numbers? So how many did die of Coronavirus in reality? If someone is already suffering from life threatening complications would this still count as a Covid death?
- paganel 7y ago> If someone is already suffering from life threatening complications would this still count as a Covid death? The Western official media was strongly denouncing the Chinese authorities when they were doing similar things a month or so ago in Hubei. Following that same logic I guess cancer is not the number one killer in the world, it's either the respiratory failure caused by that cancer or the related infections. But this is just Western hubris in play, as in "our numbers can never be wrong, reality be damned", and I say that as a guy from the Western "side".
- 7y ago
- Onanymous 7y agoHi there, the "Ministry of Truth"!
- notlukesky 7y agoCensorship is the path that leads to tyranny. Better to have all sides without being muzzled. Today’s truth can be tomorrow’s fake news and vice versa. Either they are publishers or platforms. They can always put disclaimers by every “news.”
- maccard 7y agoThe issue is that these companies are now providing a platform for the "village idiot", and it's up to people to differentiate truth from falsehoods, which is surprisingly difficult to do on a topic you don't know anyything about.
- raxxorrax 7y agoNews media has direct business relationships with these platforms. This isn't about some village idiot. If you are fascinated by village idiots, you are their audience.
- FeepingCreature 7y agoI'd much rather it be up to the people than up to one person, especially one who is unaccountable.
- stephenr 7y ago(Paraphrasing Colin Lane here) In some cases, it's the village idiot, in a village full of village idiots.
- itronitron 7y agoEven worse their letting village idiots target individual users based on their 'profiles'
- bjourne 7y agoAre you old enough to remember the lead up to the 2003 Iraq war? The village idiots are maybe not who you think they are.
- izacus 7y ago
- paganel 7y agoLast I checked Twitter had suspended an account who was providing relevant information out of China when the virus was still mostly affecting only them, I think that was around February 20th or so. Yeah, that account was also publishing videos that some might have thought as too bleak (i.e. videos of very desperate people), but that was the actual situation on the ground in Hubei province. Had we listened to videos like those earlier we wouldn't have been in this situation.
- rvz 7y agoThe "internet companies" are trying to tackle something that is beyond their control and from the looks of it is close to impossible to contain misinformation and disinformation. So it results them to have a deep integration into our lives and the way the internet works in general. (Google and Facebook can never be taken down, even when they still have content seen as 'offensive', 'misleading' or just completely false by some). "Don't believe everything you see or hear on the internet" - The Internet
- techntoke 7y agoI believe educating people how to validate information and use the Internet would have much better results than censorship. I will say though there is a certain decline in older people where they become highly gullible and susceptible to fake news, robocalls, scams, etc.
- raxxorrax 7y agoBut their attempts to promote authoritative sources like news media that also happens to be in a direct business relationship with them is swallowed up like a blessing. Completely delusional. Maybe not true for reddit, I think they do it for random reasons. This is the actual consequences of stripping down education on every front.
- easytiger 7y agoReddit r/coronavirusuk pretty much taken over by left wing extremists turning it into a political football match with barely a rational thing there. Currently full of anti government propaganda, much of it unrelated to the virus.
- Quequau 7y agoI've been moderating a handful of communities over on Reddit for about ten years now, among them several are focused on hearing health. Something I see as a matter of routine is the roughly 21 day arc of folks learning that some aliment exists to speaking intentionally as if they are an educated medical professional, while essentially medical rumour and legend mongering. I don't think this is limited to those with issues of hearing health and I suspect that, while it's more common in circles where doctors often give unspecific bad news with no real resolution (something that many folks don't want to hear), it's not limited to them either. Right now on Reddit there are scores of subreddits focused on COVID-19 and the Coronavirus, with really terrible moderation. If the admins were actually serious about dealing with missinfo they'd be shutting more than a few down.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoReddit has been a very good source of information in this crisis. Of course there will be misinformation. That's not as big of a problem in Reddit because of moderation and voting, compared to Facebook and the likes.
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> Reddit has been a very good source of information in this crisis. Got to be joking right? Reddit is pretty much the battleground of misinformation. It's run by think tanks, ngos, intel, media, etc. Most of the threads and most comments are pretty much anti-china propaganda along with some pro-china nonsense. That's it. Every gilded and boosted thread and comment are of a particular propaganda bent. > That's not as big of a problem in Reddit because of moderation and voting, compared to Facebook and the likes. The problem with reddit is precisely the moderation. It's why you have garbage echo chambers like r/politics, r/the_donald, r/worldnews, r/news, r/china, r/atheism, [do I need to continue]. Even the coronavirus related subs are heavily politically driven. Because of the rise of moderation, reddit has turned into hives of extreme echo chambers. Whereas in the past, most major subs allowed all viewpoints, now each sub moderates toward a particular worldview and you get the worst echo chambers. You get the worst echo chambers due to moderation and censorship. Moderation and censorship doesn't prevent echo chambers and extremism. It promotes it. It's why nazi germany, soviet union, north korea, saudi arabia, silicon valley, etc love moderation and censorship.
- aestetix 7y agoNot sure why I should be trusting Big Tech companies to tell me what is "misinformation." Did I miss the event where they proved themselves worthy of being such gatekeepers?
- sebow 7y agoKind of ironic, because Facebook at least has allowed and even facilitated "fake news"(regarding anything)for at least 8 years blatantly.This has been done purposefully, let's be clear. If you get your news/health tips from twitter,facebook or similar platforms, you deserve your fate to be eventually misinformed.Facebook would not risk their profits and existence even if this would become humanity's last plague. Having access to social media platforms means that you more or less have access to the internet, which is way more filtered than social platforms for qualitative information about anything regarding health.
- grandpoobah 7y agoAnybody else noticed how bad Google search is at search nowadays? YouTube search too. Both of these search engines used to be incredible at turning up results when provided with even the most obscure search terms, but now all of the top results are from main stream media news sites. In their quest to control the spread of misinformation they have neutered their core product. I miss the good old days :(
- WhyNotHugo 7y agoI moved to DuckDuckGo years ago. I did it mostly out of interest on their stance on privacy, but stayed and never moved out because of how much better their search results are.
- ramblerman 7y agoddg works pretty well, but for obscure things it's even worse.
- raxxorrax 7y agoIt is ridiculously commercialized. If you search for a topic and there is a commercially available product that happens to have the same name, good luck finding relevant info. Or what is new and even worse, if there is a news article about a certain topic, Google will heavily drive the traffic their way, regardless of the quality of the article. There are few topics left where search results aren't just shit.
- capableweb 7y agoI'm not sure "their quest to control the spread of misinformation" is the reason behind this, as the search quality got lower and lower before the whole panic around misinformation started. My guess would be that Google is tailoring their search engine to ~80% of the queries and optimizing for those, so when you're searching for the 20%, it's really bad. But when within 80%, it works great. I remember back in the day when you had to know how to search in order to find things. Some people were better than others and different search engines had different tricks. Nowadays it seems like trying to optimize your search query makes it worse, and most engines just deal with generalized queries.
- buzzkillington 7y agoPeople want daddy government to save them. Daddy government is why the virus first spread so far in China. Lies and more lies about how the situation was under control is how it got out to the rest of the world.
- ForHackernews 7y agoPublic health is almost the canonical example of something where you need concerted response organised by a government. So yes, we expect government action.
- addHocker 7y agoThe institutions mostly promoted inaction (WHO). And the government does nothing, but censor and provide a mixed message (Lobbyism saying you dont need to social isolate that hard).. Sorry, you are on your own with this one, when you dont want to rely on the poisoned wells of official news sources.
- heyoo 7y agoPeople wants a united society to save them. Government = society.
- jlawson 7y agoThis notion is dangerously pro-totalitarian. Government=the people who have the power to kill other people and get away with it. No more, no less.
- jhanschoo 7y agoAs long as people need to coordinate in a society, a government will form; it is exactly the institution that handles exactly the matters that need to be solved by societal coordination.
- dang 7y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments to Hacker News? We're trying for different than that here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- cannedslime 7y agoSo what counts as misinformation? There is a lot of uninformed statements about SARS-CoV-2 everywhere, including goverments like mine that says that you are "safe" if you just stay 1-2m away from infected persons. If you ask me, constantly calling this SARS strain Corona, Covid-19 etc. can count as misinformation as well.
- a_c 7y agoI don't think the proliferation of fake news is due to the lack of gatekeeping. I think the issue is the ease of authoring fake content. Publishing a piece of news/article used to mean hosting a website, registering a domain, writing html, running a web server. All require studying, the very action to battle disinformation. Now all we have to do is make an account (or even not) and start typing on keyboard. Opinion is like a-hole, everyone got one. But not every piece of opinion as useful as an a-hole. Lowering the bar of publishing is normalising the weighting of each opinion. Which I think is the root cause of today's internet
- techntoke 7y agoYou'd be surprised how many fake news artist and disinformation agents have pleasantly designed websites. The problem isn't so much that anyone can post something on Reddit, and people believe it as fact. It is that they read it on Reddit, then their browser history curates their recommended videos on YouTube to validate what they read using real people who make money off these ideas, then they send money to their Patreon to get the exclusive information which includes access to a nice looking website. Here are some examples: https://lightonconspiracies.com/ https://lightonconspiracies.com/ https://charlesortel.com/ https://charlesortel.com/ https://truepundit.com/category/featured/ https://truepundit.com/category/featured/ https://crowdsourcethetruth.org/ https://crowdsourcethetruth.org/ Those are just a few of hundreds, if not thousands.
- rufusroflpunch 7y agoSo glad the government and corporations are working together to ensure I may not have an unapproved thought.
- raxxorrax 7y agoAlso all these nice voluntary helpers that like boots too. I mean there are just so many reasons to do that because people are so bad.
- BickNowstrom 7y agoFrom this pandemic I learned that the current internet is far too controlled for information. I got most of my (by now confirmed) information from early leaks. Of course there are ridiculous hoaxes and bad advice floating around, but it pales in comparison to the erroneous information that authorities are putting out, and it is way easier to distinguish as BS. For instance, I have read from official sources: Vitamin C does not help. Garlic (powerful anti-inflammatory and antiviral) will not help. Black and green tea will not help. Chance of infection outside of China is negligible. Human-to-human transmission is unlikely. Coronaviruses don't survive on plastics and metal surfaces. Taking anti-inflammatory drugs is not dangerous. Face masks are not protective against the virus. Gargling and swallowing hot iodized salt water does nothing. The virus is not mutating and not creating more deadly strains. The virus can't be made by humans. The official statistics are real and not a gross undercount. Cities will not go in lockdown or quarantine. Longer than expected incubation periods are not impossible. Sauna's and hot showers don't help. Everything is under control and contained. The flu is more deadly. You should not avoid public transit or large gatherings. We have enough ventilators. We have enough protective equipment for medics. You should not be worried about COVID-19 if you got flu-like symptoms before the first confirmed case on 19 January. The CDC is and was not lying about the number of cases, and warnings circulating online reporting community spread are hoaxes. The virus can not pass the brain-blood barrier. The virus does not increase chance of triggering latent schizophrenia and psychosis. Some national from a different country did not die outside of China before the WHO called a world health emergency. This is not yet a pandemic. Fantasies about coronavirus are more contagious than the disease itself. Not eating in Chinatown restaurants is racist. When hand sanitizer ran out, it's not a good idea to make your own hand sanitizer. Countries in Europe won't follow Italy. The virus started in a wet market in Wuhan. You can't blame China for the pandemic, they did a great job and set an example for outbreak response. Papers discussing HIV inserts and gain-of-function infectiousness are retracted because they are completely false, not for fueling conspiracy theories. This virus is not a viable bioweapon, because the mortality rate is too low. The pope will not have coronavirus. Trump will not have coronavirus. Bolsonaro will not have coronavirus. The stock market is looking good right now. There is no reason for panic. This virus is not expected to calm down around June, only to pick up again in November. The government thinks that shaking hands is ok. Experts are right. Experts give correct projections. It is better to listen to public health officials and experts if you want to stay up to date and predict what will happen. There are no terrible long-term concerns of contracting COVID-19 for young people. I can provide sources upon request if you believe any of these statements. An educated citizenry is a vital requisite for our survival as a free people! Stop managing panic and come clean: You all lost control of a SARS-like virus and containment is impossible. Instead of quarantining subreddits, you may want to take a look at the immense sockpuppetry from China nr. 1 accounts and the trade war driven anti-China propaganda from U.S. intelligence. Even on HackerNews I get multiple downvotes on posts that are long on page 5. There is a gross information warfare going on, but hey, got to protect against my Facebook aunt trying to give (scientifically unproven) well-intentioned advice, in the absence of any certainty. Google prioritizes information such as "How to protect yourself against novel coronavirus? Cough in your elbows!". They are arrogantly acting like the public can't handle the truth.
- heyoo 7y agoI had high hopes from this title. Unfortunately, it only involves misinformation in regards to COVID-19. I would really hope they would unite in a joint effort against the spread of propaganda from fake accounts instead. As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, take a look at Bot Sentinel top 100 trollbots [1]. #1 @BrandonBeckham_ is (from my judgment) a fake twitter account [2]. He poses as a veteran Christian that loves everything Trump. All he posts is pro-Trump stuff & Donald J. Trump retweets him frequently. This is the stuff that needs moderation for misinformation. This is _dangerous_ - it affects people's minds and changes their minds. But somehow this stuff is just ignored by Big Tech. [1]: https://botsentinel.com/top-100 https://botsentinel.com/top-100 [2]: https://twitter.com/brandonbeckham_ https://twitter.com/brandonbeckham_
- rotidodol 7y agoapple doesnt care about coronavirus
- jquery 7y agoIronic, considering that “misinfo” was the name of the game when WHO was in charge of downplaying this, and anyone following mainstream media got caught completely flat footed when the dam broke, while I am well stocked up on supplies I purchased in late January. I know there’s a lot of disinfo and rumors out there. But I don’t want them shutting it all down. Put a warning over it if you must. But without some of these sources I would not have learned about the severity of the virus in time to prepare.
- austincheney 7y agoSpecific only to COVID-19. I don’t see social media companies making any dent on misinformation. Here are a variety of examples. * Troll farms that deliberately seek to manipulate gullible people for unrelated motivations. * Fanatics, which are the same as troll farms except their motives are aligned to what they claim. * Cults which are also just like troll farms except their motives are centered around the desires of a central person or idol. * Liars. People who deliberately mislead others for personal reasons nor affiliated with an organization. * Stupid people are like liars except their deceit is not deliberate and they have primarily fooled themselves and want to share their foolishness, such as people who put their heads in the sand and twist themselves into knots to ignore evidence when pushing opinions onto people. * Gullible people are those who spread any information they believe to be true where truth is only based on popularity, conformity, or social expediency. I want to see how social media eliminates that.
- HumblyTossed 7y agoSadly, this does not appear to apply to popular politicians who can't seem to grasp what their advisors are telling them.
- bluGill 7y agoThey will still accept money to show ads for vitamins and other useless "supplements" I'm sure fake news will remain okay if you pay them to spread it.