3 ms·
I want to make it absolutely clear that I am not minimizing the coronavirus here, but the statistics would be lost in the noise. If known statistics are an orde
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I want to make it absolutely clear that I am not minimizing the coronavirus here, but the statistics would be lost in the noise. If known statistics are an order of magnitude too low, and there have actually been 800 deaths in the US instead of 80, that's still only about 3% of the total flu deaths this season. And flu seasons vary in intensity by a lot more than 3%.
- pvaldes 7y agoThe real problem is the concentration of number of cases in a big peak in a narrow space of time, so many people that should not die will die anyway by exhaustion of resources. Physicians will need to decide who to let die and who is treated and lives. This is what they are trying to improve when asking people not to go out for a couple of weeks
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoYes, again, I'm not minimizing anything or saying coronavirus isn't a problem. I'm only explaining why statistics wouldn't currently detect a bunch of unknown cases.
- taeric 7y agoThis is my line of thinking, too. And I second your point of not trying to minimize it, but there appears compelling evidence this is already hit. Trying to determine what I could watch to get more or less confidence in this view.
- tunesmith 7y agohttps://twitter.com/trvrb/status/1238310251679461377 https://twitter.com/trvrb/status/1238310251679461377 perhaps?
- taeric 7y agoI'm not good at reading Twitter threads. Will dedicate some time to it this evening. Note also that I'm questioning if we will see an exponential rise in deaths. In large, I don't think that will be seen outside of places with poor lung health, if my hypothesis is right.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAs I mentioned downthread, Iran is the country to watch for me. It's pretty clear that their infection is uncontrolled, and Rouhani claims that new infections have peaked. Now that we know the Bay Area is going on lockdown, I intend to drop coronavirus off my newsfeed for a few days and tune back in to see if he was right.
- taeric 7y agoThat really is just the country to watch for bad baseline health country getting it. My hypothesis is a higher baseline lung health will result in a milder wave of infections. Essentially, it is not young that are getting milder cases, it is people with less damaged lungs. And no matter how you slice it, the places that have had the most deaths, have by far the worst air quality.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIran has pretty good baseline health. It's not amazing, but it's much closer to the US than the US is to Japan or Singapore. (And Italy is very healthy, one of the healthiest countries in the world in most rankings.)
- taeric 7y agoDepends on the health. And the city you are looking at. The air in the area of Italy hit hard has really bad levels as far back as Jan. I didn't look father, but that satellite showed Italy bring terrible. Was that just a new thing? So, my hypothesis is on base lung damage. And is spurred by kids not getting hit. I find it hard to think kids aren't getting sick.
- tathougies 7y agoIf coronavirus has already hit America then that is a huge vote of confidence for the American medical system, which, in this hypothetical, has managed to deal with a major pneumonia pandemic without so much as calling in extra nursing shifts. That would suggest that America's medical system is ahead of Italy, which is suffering heavily due to running out of hospital space.
- taeric 7y agoNot necessarily. My contention is that in places with many severe cases, there are also tons of mild cases. In particular, I see no reason to think the young population is not getting it. Toddlers and pre teens. Especially in areas with higher family residence. So, my hypothesis centers around trying to give an explanation for why that population isn't impacted by severe cases. Going off how bad it hit me, if that is what hit me, best I have is lung health. And I don't have unhealthy lungs, all told. I do, however, have a distant history of asthma, and I find it plausible it did damage my lungs long ago. To flip it some. They say even if you survive, you may have lasting lung scarring. What if that preceded the covid?
- tathougies 7y ago> To flip it some. They say even if you survive, you may have lasting lung scarring. What if that preceded the covid? That doesn't make sense. Covid follows the same exponential curve in all countries. If the US has a bunch of latent infections, but no huge surge in pneumonia, then that would imply there is something special about Americans that keep them from developing the worst symptoms, or something special about American old people that, despite contact with the young silent carriers, they do not develop the disease. There is no reason to believe either of those are true. They say we are a week or so behind Italy. Italy is experiencing hospital overruns. If the week-behind estimate (based on actual numbers) is overly conservative, then we would have expected to see hospital overruns in the United States from old people with pneumonia. However, we don't have that. Thus, if the week-behind estimate is overly conservative, we are certainly not at the same point as Italy or ahead of Italy, so we can say that we are anywhere from 1 week to 1 day behind Italy which is still a pretty good bound.
- usrusr 7y agoNo way to have the statistics get lost in the noise for a prolonged time and then suddenly switch to strong exponential growth that totally buries a developed medical system. If the ratio of sub-noticeable to noticeable cases was so much bigger, by the time you'd reach Lombardy-grade hospital influx the growth rate would already be shrinking from saturation. A virus that shows the infection rate documented by serious cases in hard-hit regions is unable to spread slowly in an unaware and unimmunized population.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoExponential growth is very good at getting lost in the noise for a prolonged time until suddenly it's not. Toy numbers: If you have 20K cases today with a 6 day doubling time, the first case was 84 days ago but 99% of the cases are new this month. (And in some sense this must have happened - everyone agrees there are a significant number of undetected cases, the only question is how many.)
- tathougies 7y agoThank you for a cohesive answer. Yes, but if this is true and the number dead is not enough to even catch our attention when compared to flu dead, it would seem these economic and societal measures being undertaken are way out of proportion. In reality, if America were suffering a major pneumonia outbreak like Italy, we would be out of ventilators and deciding who dies. That is clearly not the case here, so we can rest assured that we are certainly behind Italy.
- taeric 7y agoBut my question is if we will see the same levels as Italy. Just glancing at their air quality, I couldn't go there without extra inhalers. Is that making them more susceptible to lung illness? Is a question I haven't asked. Do they usually see more pneumonia than places like the states, anyways? Could be a proxy to test my hypothesis.