6 ms·
Indeed, public transportation is the worst option when it comes to sanitation.
by pengaru 7y ago
Indeed, public transportation is the worst option when it comes to sanitation.
- the_af 7y agoIn cases like this, however, it seems a car is the solution to the wrong problem: you should not be commuting at all. A car is also the "solution" to an individual problem -- "how do I get safely from A to B?" -- but this is a societal problem: "how do we as a society overcome this disease while causing as little damage as possible?". Solutions must be oriented towards the community, not the individual. Everyone using their cars, if they even have them, is not the solution.
- pengaru 7y agoI don't commute, but use my automobile to retrieve groceries and potable water every week or two. I don't see this as a poor solution to my particular needs, but I do look forward to it being electric and charged from solar panels on my roof.
- gumby 7y agoYou live in a place without a supply of potable water?
- pengaru 7y agoI haul water from a bulk water dispenser in town operated by the city water department, have a cistern cache on site which gets topped up that way. It's not that unusual in desert communities like mine.
- nradov 7y agoIt is disappointing how unaware many urbanites are of the realities of life in rural areas. After the travel restrictions are lifted we would do well to get out of our bubbles and see firsthand how others live. That could help reduce the current political and cultural divides.
- scarejunba 7y agoWhat's really disappointing is the degree to which we subsidize the incredible climate costs of non-urban people. When the carbon taxes are finally required, rural Americans will learn just how much they've been externalizing. Our food will be more expensive and it should be but all those other parts of rural living are just this horrendous climate abuse. EDIT: Oops, I mean the costs should be baked in. Obviously governments should provide food aid.
- macinjosh 7y agoSo let me get this straight: You want food to be more expensive when we already have families that struggle to put food on the table (see recent worries about closing schools affecting access to the food they provide)? Urban populations have their own fair share of climate related problems. Sounds to me like you just want people to starve in order to solve your precious climate ‘crisis’.
- the_af 7y agoIn your case it seems the use of a car is warranted. I don't see the problem.
- taborj 7y agoBut some people using their cars is a solution (for those people). After all, not everyone has the luxury of a job that can be worked from home.
- the_af 7y agoThe problem is that the solution doesn't scale. Some people stocking up on supplies, to the detriment of their neighbors, is also a "solution"... to those people. Not to their neighbors. A "solution" must scale, otherwise it's selfish. Even worse, if a lot of people think "cars are the answer!" they are compounding the problem. Fighting coronavirus requires a societal response, one that works for most people and where people don't take individual actions that seemingly benefit them (and only them).
- nradov 7y agoCars are fine for essential transportation as defined in this order. They aren't making the immediate situation any worse. Overall vehicle traffic is way down and will be even lower tomorrow.
- the_af 7y agoThey are fine only because not everyone uses them during an emergency. If everyone felt validated to start driving their cars, it would probably not be fine.
- nradov 7y agoOutside of a few small urban areas everyone already drives their cars every day. It's not causing any additional problems during this emergency.
- donemanaging 7y agoWhat if you need to see your family, or help out a friend? Or vice versa? Or go pick up medication? This comment strikes me as pretty insensitive. I live in SF and don't own a car. It's never been more tempting for me to get one. I live alone, far from family, and now seemingly can't see my friends or significant other. It's already getting incredibly lonely. A car would enable me to at least go straight to my gf's place without being in contact with anyone, or to the pharmacy for meds without taking public transit.
- the_af 7y ago> This comment strikes me as pretty insensitive Well, I didn't mean to. In fact, I'm advocating for the community at large. An individualistic "solution" ("if only I had a car, I would be able to [...]") is not the best solution for the problem at large. Everyone fending for themselves, driving their cars, is obviously not the answer, and in fact it might make things worse. That you, and many others, are feeling pretty lonely and isolated is part of the reality of this outbreak. It's obviously going to be very hard for a lot of people. Many people's livelihoods are at stake here, regardless of the seriousness of COVID-19. Unfortunately this is going to have some big consequences regardless of individually owned cars. update: it seems the city of SF has an advisory, and is mandating (among other things) against taking "unnecessary" trips in public transportation, car or motorbike: https://sf.gov/stay-home-except-essential-needs https://sf.gov/stay-home-except-essential-needs Some excerpts: "You cannot have dinner parties. You cannot invite friends over to your home to hang out. [..] You cannot take unnecessary trips on public transport or in your car or motorbike." "Can I leave home to visit friends or family members if there is no urgent need? No. For your safety as well as their safety, we need to help each other fight the spread of COVID-19 by staying at home."
- NotAnEconomist 7y ago> Well, I didn't mean to. In fact, I'm advocating for the community at large. This thinking led to all sorts of atrocities in the past 100 years, from fascism to communism -- and the murders to starvation that accompanied them.
- 7y ago
- bduerst 7y agoYou are correct in that there is less demand for travel, but there is still demand. Without a car it's incredibly difficult to fulfill even a trip to the pharmacy with only a compromised public transportation system.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- daphneokeefe 7y agoHow do we think health workers and sanitation workers and police/fire and other vital workers should get to work? Not everyone has 24-hour public transportation available.
- the_af 7y agoI think it goes without saying that emergency services are an exception. There's no need to take my argument to the absurd. I'm assuming the OP meant he was a regular worker (not an emergency or law enforcement worker). In any case, don't emergency services provide transportation for their employees? > Not everyone has 24-hour public transportation available. I don't think public transportation is the safest choice at this moment either. In fact, everyone should avoid it if at all possible (in some cases and parts of the world, it's not possible at the moment).
- nradov 7y agoEmergency services don't provide transportation to their workers. Most of them drive their own cars to work just like everyone else. Some law enforcement agencies do allow officers to drive squad cars home when they have extras available.
- the_af 7y agoSome do, some don't. But you took issue with the less important part of my answer, I assume because you agree with the rest: that what is fine for emergency workers is not necessarily fine for ordinary citizens.
- sequoia 7y agoI make a point of riding transit daily in my city (Toronto) because I think it's better for the community, planet, and myself. Since last week I have been driving 100% & not using transit. Now is not the time for reusable mugs & public transit. Right now we optimize for distancing & isolation, not resource conservation.
- the_af 7y agoTo be clear, I wasn't arguing from a "green" point of view. I'm arguing driving a car as an individual solution to the outbreak is not a particularly useful solution to the community at large; this must be a community effort. Mine wasn't an argument about pollution or the environment, but about individualist vs collective solutions.
- sequoia 7y agoBut when I don’t get sick, I also don’t spread it to you or your child or your grandpa. We all benefit. Everyone should increase distancing however they can, and driving and biking rather than taking transit is a part of that solution. Those who have no choice but public transit also benefit from me driving because now it’s less crowded and transmission is less likely. Everyone benefits.