3 ms·
>GitHub has monopolized open source development. Github has done nothing of the sort - they're popular, but being popular is not the same as having a monopoly.
by krapp 7y ago
>GitHub has monopolized open source development.
Github has done nothing of the sort - they're popular, but being popular is not the same as having a monopoly.
> The likelihood of your software being discovered, used or contributed to goes to zero as soon as you host it anywhere but GitHub.
Untrue. It's less likely, because again Github is more popular, but not zero, because popularity isn't monopoly. Active projects do exist elsewhere, people still use projects hosted on Sourceforge FFS.
Unless Github can forcibly prevent competitors from arising by leveraging their control over resources or a legal advantage granted them by the government, they don't have a monopoly.
- Supermancho 7y ago> forcibly prevent competitors from arising by leveraging their control over resources or a legal advantage User visibility is a resource. While overwhelming popularity is not the same as a Monopoly (since they are from 2 different perspectives, they can't be equated), the effect is often the same.
- krapp 7y agoIt isn't a resource that Github controls, it's a resource that the user timeshares to Github. It isn't like steel or oil or fiberoptic cable, where it's infeasible for a new entrant without Github's resources to compete for user attention without insurmountable effort. OP could have spent their blog post informing users that the project would be hosted elsewhere, rather than going on a rant comparing Github to the Nazis, and that precious user visibility wouldn't have kept their userbase from moving elsewhere. Oh wait, they did, at the end of their post. So... why are we even here then?
- rhinoceraptor 7y agoThis is similar to the Twitter/Facebook problem. Yes, they're not true monopolies, no one is forcing you to use Facebook. You can use whatever geeky federated project is in vogue, and talk to the three other people who also use it. But if you want to talk to your grandparents, you need to use Facebook.
- krapp 7y ago>But if you want to talk to your grandparents, you need to use Facebook. Or skype, or email, or text or call them or maybe just visit once it a while. Facebook doesn't have nearly the degree of monopoly on general human communication or mass communication that HN argues it does, neither does Twitter. If Trump weren't addicted to posting there, no one would care about Twitter.