3 ms·
This complaint is going to be an interesting test, because if it ends up with legs it could go two ways: 1) it fails, and the GDPR has some precedent to constr
by shadowgovt 7y ago
This complaint is going to be an interesting test, because if it ends up with legs it could go two ways:
1) it fails, and the GDPR has some precedent to constrain its application in the future
2) it succeeds, and Google actually pulls out of the European markets completely. Internal responsible data-sharing and data-aggregation is extremely core to Google's entire business model (it is the "special sauce" that drives the entire application suite, from search to speech), and if the GDPR is incompatible with that business model, Google is incompatible with Europe.
- mongol 7y agoGoogle will not pull out of Europe. As long as it can make a profit in Europe it will stay. There is a demand for many of the services it offers and it is well positioned to sell them, regardless of GDPR.
- shadowgovt 7y agoPossibly. Depends on what the cost-benefit tradeoff is. Google tends to be a long-term-thinking-oriented company, and requiring them to silo internal data (under the rules of a third-party oversight, not their own rules) strikes at their ability to do R&D. They know that in the long-term, the survival of a technical company is hinged on what they deliver in the future, not what they're delivering now.
- disgruntledphd2 7y agoOk, so there are two parts of the work rich enough to support advertising companies. They are the US and Europe. It's super implausible that Google will pull out of Europe (the EU at least), because they are forced to implement the laws. It's as likely as them pulling out of the US because they are forced to refuse to deal with countries under US sanctions.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> They are the US and Europe ... and China. And the refusal of the ability to deal with countries under US sanctions doesn't strike at the core of Google's R&D techniques and resources.
- disgruntledphd2 7y agoSortof. Urban China, yes. Rural China no (but probably yes in 10-15 years). Nonetheless, I don't see Google (or Facebook for that matter) pulling out of Europe if they are forced to comply with (the entirely reasonable restrictions of) GDPR.
- shadowgovt 7y agoMe neither. If the restrictions prove unreasonable in practice, it's a question that I'm sure those companies will revisit.
- paulryanrogers 7y ago> Google tends to be a long-term-thinking-oriented company, ... Is that still true? The number of products they've launched and abandoned, sometimes in the same market (like messaging), seems to indicate they're more an in-the-moment company to me.
- shadowgovt 7y agoA lot of launch-abandonment churn is to be expected from an R&D-heavy institution.
- ilikehurdles 7y ago3) The Irish GDPR enforcement office will ignore it.
- KarlKemp 7y agoThe idea of Google pulling out of Europe is a fantasy, the libertarian equivalent of hoping for famine in the Sowjet Republic ca 1975. As long as Google doesn't have to pay their lawyers more than what they are earning in the EU, Google will happily continue doing business in the EU. And if I had to guess, lawyers make up 0% of their costs in Europe and anywhere else, when rounding to the next integer. I see suggestions of various companies leaving the EU far more often these days than suggestions to leave China. It seems people on HN consider GDPR a more serious danger to justice than, say, "reeducation" camps for unliked minorities. Go figure..
- shadowgovt 7y agoGood point. As long as the costs to do business in Europe can be quantified and managed, even if those costs were legal penalties, I agree. I was imagining the scenario where Europe went as far as "cease and desist mixing and aggregating all user data or we'll start throwing people in prison."