6 ms·
Imagine a future where you do a swab test every morning while brushing your teeth. If you had any of thousands of infectious diseases, you're required to stay
by londons_explore 7y ago
Imagine a future where you do a swab test every morning while brushing your teeth. If you had any of thousands of infectious diseases, you're required to stay home. The test would take only 5 minutes, and you get fined if you don't do it, and receive sick pay if you test positive.
I imagine that within a few years of rolling this out, common colds might be a thing of the past, and overall worker productivity higher rather than lower.
- keiferski 7y agoImagine a future where you do a swab every morning while brushing your teeth and your testosterone and adrenaline levels are evaluated for likelihood of engaging in Anti-Social or Anti-Authority Activity. Individuals with high levels are locked into their apartments and subject to online training courses. Repeated violations result in a visit from the authorities. Yeah, no thanks. Not every solution to a serious problem needs to be some surveillance state dystopian nightmare.
- Taek 7y agoOpen source toothbrush that's not connected to the cloud.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoBut it needs to be based on good science. As someone in thread said, the false positive rate needs to be staggeringly low. And the false positive for Testosterone -> AntiSocial behaviour is huge - marathon runners to entrepreneurs and weight lifters. So the idea is good - test people for something bad they will do - but the ability to test reliably for all the bad things is real low. I think we shall just stick to past crime not FutureCrime for now. And honestly, using "bad authoritarian governments do bad things with good tools so we should not use those tools" does not make a good argument. it just means we need to double down on democracy.
- keiferski 7y agoI don't think it is a good idea or good tool at all. I don't need or want some external authority to tell me if I'm allowed to leave my house. I used the example of "Anti Social" behavior as a joke and I thought that was obvious...but apparently not. The idea is entirely antithetical to a free society. As someone indicated in another comment, the proper way to do this is through personalized incentives and social encouragement, not through authoritarian state action.
- pishpash 7y agoSure, but what do you have against a personal in-home test? The information should be available at least to the individual.
- keiferski 7y agoNothing, as long as it functions more like a pregnancy test and not something that is sending personal data to a corporation/government somewhere. However, that wasn't the primary idea in the OP, which was specifically about tracking and restricting people based on their test results.
- scotty79 7y ago> I don't need or want some external authority to tell me if I'm allowed to leave my house. In a world full of Covid19 mutations, some even more lethal than the current one you actually might need external authority to tell you if you can leave the house because you yourself will lack technology to asses the risks involved and your decision making even if you have the information might be very dangerous to other peoples freedoms. You still might not want that because people's wants are not necessarily reasonable.
- keiferski 7y agoAs I said in the original comment: > Not every solution to a serious problem needs to be some surveillance state dystopian nightmare. The authoritarian response of shutting everything down, locking people in their homes and instituting all-but-in-name-martial law seems like a massive lack of creativity to me. Plagues are not a new phenomenon. We can come up with better solutions - as Taiwan and Singapore seem to be doing. Throwing away the rights and benefits of a free society should be the last solution.
- titzer 7y ago> Not every solution to a serious problem needs to be some surveillance state dystopian nightmare. I agree. The internet doesn't need to be a surveillance state dystopian nightmare, but the free market brought us that.
- Dylan16807 7y agoI'm not sure why you invented your own scenario to call bad. Checking if someone has the flu isn't dystopian. Full sick pay isn't dystopian. You don't even need the fine if that offends you so much.
- mxcrossb 7y agoYou’d have to have a staggeringly low false positive rate to be able to do this, because you’d basically have no prior, and you’re testing for multiple things.
- londons_explore 7y agoIf a false positive results in someone staying home and getting paid, one can easily work out the economic cost of that. Then it becomes a simple economics problem - how much should the government spend on improving the test to regain a bit of productivity. A false negative (someone going about their day despite being infectious) is just the status quo, and has served us well for centuries.
- sokoloff 7y agoI would expect a gaming system to emerge (to force positive test results when people wanted time off without suffering any consequences). Done well, that might be the most valuable purely wasteful invention ever created.
- lolc 7y agoWhere I live, it's common for people to just call in and stay home for the day when they are sick. They don't need to game a device or convince a doctor. There is some trust. Maybe this could be tried elswhere?
- sokoloff 7y agoWhen the money comes from the employer, there is incentive to root out and eliminate significant fraud. When the money comes from the sky/government, there is much less. We have a nice wooden fence that was (properly) built around/over the roots of a city-owner tree. The city later removed the tree and the fence now looked dumb where it had been trimmed around the roots. A neighbor stopped by and advised me that I should call the city and have them pay to replace that section of fence. Said it shouldn’t be my responsibility to pay for it. I asked her if she thought it was her responsibility to pay for it. “Of course not; that’s ridiculous!” “Well, that’s why I’m not asking the city to pay for it...”
- discodave 7y agoSounds like Gattica :)
- kijin 7y agoHere's a less dystopian variation of your idea. Everyone has access to those swabs, either for free, included with their health insurance plan, or at a marginal cost. It's not mandatory to use it every day, but there are incentives such as automatic sick pay and discounts on health insurance. On the other hand, there will be serious legal consequences if you test positive, decide to go to work anyway, and end up infecting other people. If it was your employer who told you to come in, your employer bears those consequences instead. Money speaks louder than common sense. One of the reasons law exists is to tweak the incentive structure so that they align better with common sense.
- scotty79 7y agoI think a lot of people would opt in to this testing just to get a chance of paid free day.
- lenkite 7y agoImagine a future in which employers can also gain history to such health data and ensure jobs are given to the people of superior health. Such means will be necessary for economic health and progress of human civilisation. Marriage prospects, political and administration posts, etc can all leverage advantage from such a better policy.