8 ms·
Some activities lend themselves well to amateurization. It's hard to imagine a world where people need a professional license to write computer programs or publ
by matheusmoreira 7y ago
Some activities lend themselves well to amateurization. It's hard to imagine a world where people need a professional license to write computer programs or publish articles. Not all professions are this accessible though. Perhaps amateurization is correlated with benign consequences for being wrong. We don't see amateur engineers, doctors, lawyers...
- TheUndead96 7y agoThis is the exact point that I believe is understated. The gig economy is pure supply-and-demand. Customers are saying that they do not need a professional hotel or taxi service. The historic prestige of these services is predicated on the fact that before the internet there was no better way to connect customers and service providers. If there was a tier below Economy on planes, people would use it. This is because there will always be a portion of the population (maybe even a majority) who strictly only care about the service rendered and the outcome achieved.
- mellavora 7y agoWell, there are factors like health and safety risk in these industries. The gig economy works because these costs are ignored. How many Uber drivers have commercial insurance? If they don't have commercial insurance, does their insurance company cover the damages (including medical bills of passengers) in the case of an accident while the vehicle is in commercial use? Or, what is the Air BnB host's personal liability in the case that Air BnB requires hosts to refund bookings cancelled due to COVID? A hotel is a corporation, as an Air-BnB host do you have similar limitation on personal financial liability? The gig economy is supply-and-demand combined with dodging regulatory costs. Which is great until you run into the situation the regulation is designed to protect against.
- clairity 7y agoamateur engineers are abundant across garages in the US. everyone is an amateur doctor, especially parents and any caregiver. and you can certainly represent yourself in court without a lawyer. i'd even go so far as to argue law to be the least "technical" profession (in the sense of having specialized knowledge) of those options--you mainly need to know how to construct a good argument and deconstruct bad ones (most law education seems to be learning a canon of past cases and rationales so you'd be better prepared for that. and writing a lot.).
- giantDinosaur 7y agoLaw is just as technical as the others. Most law isn't really about constructing or deconstructing arguments, it's about filling out pages and pages of very boring but very necessary documentation. Lawyers are often just in the business of contracts and other such formulaic (but technical) stuff. Trial law, or similar, is also as much about following rules as anything else. Anyone can construct an argument, and a lot of people can construct better arguments than a lawyer, but almost nobody can do it in the way that's necessary for it to actually work.
- amelius 7y agoIsn't this all backwards then? If a person can't defend themselves then how can a person know if they did something wrong in the first place? To me it sounds like an entire profession created a monopoly on what they are doing to artificially keep out "amateurs".
- Nasrudith 7y agoI suspect it is backwards including the source of the doctrines. Precedent while it may have a function in consistency is just gussied up rationalizations essentially. Representatives in matters of disputes would always have a purpose but only a codified law with its complexities would create lawyers. They like doctors also occupy the "high stakes license" version. Combined with incompetence of council as a reason for appeal it is easy to see why the state and others would have a valid interest in quality standards. Small stakes courts are often still done lawyerless for instance.
- clairity 7y agoi worded that poorly (see, that's why i'm not a lawyer! =). i was intending to differentiate (breadth of) skills versus knowledge. lawyerly technical skills, as i see it, is the different ways of constructing, destructing, and rebutting arguments, along with presentational skills (verbal and written) and related strategies. so i see filling out forms and drawing up contracts as a form of argumentation--in that case, the preemption of common and likely future arguments. so then, lawyerly technical skills are relatively enumerable. on the other hand, law has a vast corpus of knowledge (e.g., precedent) that no one person can master in a lifetime. in contrast, the technical skills to imagine and create physical (and virtual) objects, or to understand and modify biological systems, are vast and relatively innumerable (as is what's known and unknown in those realms). that's not to say anything about the intelligence or creativity of practitioners of any of these professions, as they all benefit from those qualities.
- jaxn 7y agoIf Covid19 ends up being the worst case scenario, and my mom can't get a ventilator, I will absolutely attempt to do it myself. So maybe not benign consequences as much as perceived risk. The problem is, my perception of risk is not always accurate.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoWhen it comes to ventilators, you'll have to be really careful about infection risk and particulates. Making an air pump should be relatively easy, but making things medical grade is more complicated. I think that's the main difference between amateur and expert, between homemade and professional. Explains the price difference as well.
- nnq 7y ago> We don't see amateur engineers, doctors, lawyers... Not yet! > amateurization is correlated with benign consequences for being wrong Not that simple I think. it's correlated with either (1) as you say, not so bad consequences for being wrong, (2) being able to quickly check/measure both an individual's actual skill and the possible consequence of their decision before implementing thee, or (3) "rollback"/undo-ability - if something wrong happens, there's a relatively cheap way to undo the consequences and try again a different thing. You can't easily measure skills in medicine or law (you can't create simple and fast tests/exams yet for such areas). You can't really simulate either by running a mental experiment or by running some software the consequences of decisions in medicine or law. You can try but it will fail horribly most of the time. And there's no "undo" after someone dies or stays wrongly in jail for X years. I think that, paradoxically, as fields get more technical and precise, they will become more open to amateurization, because skills will be easily assessable and outcomes predicatable before deploying a scenario in the real world. Of course, this will happen concurrently with AI/ML-replacing humans in these areas, so the amateurization if it will ever have time to happen will probably be a footnote in history, dwarfed by the bigger story of mostly getting humans out-of-the-loop... But the humans that will remain in the loop will likely be more and more expert-generalists, eg. the "platinum level" version of "amateurs"!
- tsukurimashou 7y ago> We don't see amateur engineers, doctors, lawyers... What about self taught people, don't they count as "amateur" in some way?
- ivanche 7y agoI'm not aware of any country in which somebody self-taught (i.e. without graduating from university and being a member of chamber afterwards) can legally practice medicine or law.
- zeckalpha 7y agoLegalZoom and WebMD enable many people to “practice”, if only for themselves.
- lonelappde 7y agoAt the edge, in some US states you don't need law degree for joining the bar, but you do need a Bachelors and apprentice work experience.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoI believe that's only a couple of states though, and you still have to demonstrate legal experience. I believe it's mostly to allow experienced paralegals and law enforcement a path to lawyerhood, not to allow the broader masses of citizens into the profession.
- tsukurimashou 7y agoYeah sorry I'm in the IT field, which is probably an "easy" one, but it is hard in my mind and with internet to think it cannot (or shouldn't) be possible with any field
- radu_floricica 7y agoI think you got the professions backwards :) You just can't be an "amateur programmer" - it takes a lot of effort to get to the point where you're employable in the field. Probably something like a year of sustained work. Sure, you can learn light scripting in a week, but learning curve gets a lot steeper at some point. On the other hand, it's relatively easy to learn a slice of health care or law enough to be able to give advice. As for engineering... try combinations including the word "redneck" on youtube search and enjoy yourself.
- Firadeoclus 7y agoYou don't need to be "employable in the field" to be an amateur programmer. And plenty of people learn to program in their spare time to a level where they would be employable. Often while they're still in school.
- superhuzza 7y agoOf course you can be an amateur programmer, amateur means you're practicing something but not in a professional manner (i.e. unpaid). A huge number of the people who program things like their raspberry pi or open source projects are amateur programmers. Or all the students and dabblers. Same goes for engineering in general, if you spend any amount of time in a rural area you'll stumble on some amateur engineering genius.