4 ms·
Injection moulding isn't hard but it's not uncommon for even experienced teams to take a couple of goes to get it right. "Re-re-re-re-fabrication" is excessive
by nl 7y ago
Injection moulding isn't hard but it's not uncommon for even experienced teams to take a couple of goes to get it right. "Re-re-re-re-fabrication" is excessive though and sounds like it was an inexperienced team.
Source: worked at a place that made injection moulded hardware.
- ggm 7y agoits somebody else's kickstarter, not mine. Its the PIXLater, a diffuser and three or four parts which need to all fit the same size hole, to provide the right 35/128/70mm shaped holes for negatives, to be backlit by the diffuser, and sit on a tablet. The problems relate to the repeated click-unclick of the parts, which require strong corners and chamfers to insert, and friction hold. Every single iteration of design required re-design of the injection moulding. I think had the design been well worked out in advance it would have only been 2-3 cycles, but since the design had to overcome mechanical rigidity, re-insertion, keystoning the parts, over-dimension outcomes, under-dimension outcomes, it was fraught. Its finally reached production. A large amount of the 1960s dislike of plastics vests in the super-bad job injection moulding of the time did, with both bad plastic stock, and badly made moulds. Now, we think its fantastic but we're standing on the shoulders of giants who made it work. Lego's fab is pretty awesome, to maintain dimensional fit for click-fit on millions of parts like that. The Mint, is not exactly injection moulding, but similar: they have to replace coin dies frighteningly often because they just wear out. The CSIRO did work with the Australian mint doing ion beam vapour deposition to create hardened surfaces to try and preserve the die lifetimes. Stamping out CDs speaks to how accurately we can do this now. (injection moulding CDs is not a thing)
- Dylan16807 7y agoSo when you talk about getting anywhere near lego you're talking about a type of problem that's in a completely different ballpark. 3D printing can't even hope to reach those tolerances. If they were making a part that could simply be 3D printed, the type of manufacturing relevant to the article, I'm pretty sure they wouldn't have had all those problems.