11 ms·
> Is everyone in a high-risk group supposed to withdraw themselves from society for six months until they can emerge once the (so far entirely imaginary) secon
by jrochkind1 7y ago
> Is everyone in a high-risk group supposed to withdraw themselves from society for six months until they can emerge once the (so far entirely imaginary) second wave has been averted?
OK... but... isn't that what everyone is being advised to do right now? So maybe not a great example of something unrealistic to ask? Since in fact the UK would be asking it of fewer people than... many are saying it needs to be asked of -- although the US government isn't actually telling us to... yet? But that's the alternative those who who think the UK's plan is madness are suggesting, right? Asking everyone to withdraw from society for months?
I can see the desire: Wait, could we just ask high-risk people to withdraw themselves from society for months, instead of asking everyone to do that? Cause that'd be a lot less disruptive to our social and mental health maybe it'd be just as good? (There are real costs to mental health and social functioning of asking everyone to avoid all contact with everyone else; it might be the best option anyway, but it's definitely not without it's own health risks and consequences).
But I'm no expert. It kind of sounds like the experts are saying "not really, that isn't a good idea, everyone has got to do it". Sometimes what we are called upon to do is not easy or pleasant.
One of the frustrating and anxiety-producing things here is that we aren't getting very consistent messaging from the governmental authorities and experts. It seems like really a failure of the kind of consistent and pervasive public health educational messaging that would actually maximize compliance. Instead it's "everyone picks what forwarded chain letter on facebook makes sense to them" and we all know how well that works...
- walshemj 7y agoWorks for me if you can find a suitably remote cabin and a stock of food etc :-)
- saagarjha 7y agoBut what about my Hacker News habit? Surely there is Wi-Fi…
- dmos62 7y agoI'd end up simulating my own HN on paper.
- grogenaut 7y agoMonte Carlo simulation or hidden Markov models?
- danbolt 7y agoMy heuristic is to take a oversimplified idea and express it in an authoritative tone on social/economic/administrative topics. Sign the username with pg and you’re good.
- avip 7y agoMaybe you can run the fakehn on-premise. At times of mass hysteria it's indistinguishable from the original.
- vinni2 7y agoThe Norwegian government is prohibiting anyone from staying in cabins [0] because they fear it would overwhelm the small hospitals in rural areas and becomes harder to manage medical resources. [0] https://www.thelocal.com/20200315/norwegians-told-to-leave-countryside-cabins-and-return-home https://www.thelocal.com/20200315/norwegians-told-to-leave-c...
- masklinn 7y ago> OK... but... isn't that what everyone is being advised to do right now? No. What everyone is advised to do right now is not to withdraw from society, it's to perform basic hygiene and social distancing in order to slow down the spread. Social distancing doesn't mean living like a recluse eating spam cooked on a gas burner, it's not getting into large crowds and trying to stay some distance from other people (outside spitting / coughing range). WaPo has an article with a "social distancing" simulator: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/corona-simulator/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/corona-si... "Self quarantining" is closer to what you're talking about, but it's for people who are at risk or likely to have been infected, not the general public. Of course the latter you start the more it's already spread and the harsher measures have to be. And the more you'll have to ramp them up as you realise your initial measures were not sufficient, or your citizens have decided "freedom or death" is a good choice and decide to just ignore it. FWIW Taiwan's already reopened its schools and life has gone back to something not entirely dissimilar to normal (people do have to wear masks and get their temperature checked to step into public buildings or businesses but they can move around just fine).
- derefr 7y ago> it's not getting into large crowds and trying to stay some distance from other people (outside spitting / coughing range) ...which presumes you don't live in a place with high-enough urban density that going outside your home immediately puts you into a large crowd. Like, what are you supposed to do if you live in Manila? Mumbai? Dhaka? Pretty much the only way to "practice social distancing" in those sorts of places is to never go outside.
- alkonaut 7y agoSocial distancing is just minimizing contact, not avoiding all contact (self-isolation/quarantining). E.g. try to go out for groceries once a week and pick a time to avoid the crowds. > what are you supposed to do if you live in Manila? Mumbai? Dhaka? Rejoice that you are with 99% certainty way under 70 years old.
- massysett 7y ago
- confeit 7y agoIf I noticed anything in the past months it is that it hardly matters if you are an expert. There never was punishment for being wrong for hypotheticals. People just don't know. The WHO when declaring emergency said: "We don't know the damage this virus can do". Even this week professors in statistics compare the Italy crisis to heart attacks and their models all fall apart within a week.
- treis 7y ago>although the US government isn't actually telling us to... yet? But that's the alternative those who who think the UK's plan is madness are suggesting, right? Asking everyone to withdraw from society for months? It doesn't take that much to contain something like this. In no particular order: (1) Temperature checks outside all major gathering places. Shops, subways, offices, etc. If you're running a fever you don't get in. (2) Hand sanitizer at the entrance/exit of all major gathering places. Clean your hands before you go in and clean them when you come out. Don't clean them you don't get in. (3) Wear masks everywhere in major gathering places. No mask, no entry. (4) Widespread testing and contact tracing for those who have tested positive. I agree that the West in general is handling this as dumb as possible. Shutting everything down is pointless if you don't use the respite to enact public health measures.
- Taek 7y agoIt's estimated that as many as 20% of the infected are asymptomatic, including no fever. A lot of your suggestions would fail to contain the virus. I do believe that widespread testing and tracing would be effective. Given that we don't yet have access to the scale of testing that is required to maintain public health, I think an immediate quarantine is the only way to save lives.
- treis 7y ago>t's estimated that as many as 20% of the infected are asymptomatic, including no fever. A lot of your suggestions would fail to contain the virus. We don't need to stop 100% of the transmissions. Right now, on average, an infected person will pass it on to 2-3 people. The goal is to get that to below 1 and eventually it will fizzle out. I'm not quite sure what's so controversial about my post. It's what countries in Asia have done and they've all contained the spread.
- lonelappde 7y agoIf every place does temperature checks, how many will do it with a poor protocol that spreads virus?
- nightfly 7y ago
- joe_the_user 7y agoOK... but... isn't that what everyone is being advised to do right now? Yes but that's expected to, uh, not work. It's only expected to slow the progression. One of the frustrating and anxiety-producing things here is that we aren't getting very consistent messaging from the governmental authorities and experts. The only sane course of action the extreme lockdown we are now seeing in many countries. But politicians, being gutless cowards, are coming up with other ideas until their hand forced ... I hope. The alternative of actually believe this stuff and sticking to it would horrific. I mean, everyone should be definitely be isolating and doing everyone that they can to slow the infection. But we are going to need much stronger measures than individual action. This is a real war, not like drug or terrorism wars, OK.