7 ms·
> "We don't make pure electric cars because for the time being, we think they're too heavy, and they don't make a cool sound. And as long as we can be CO2 neutr
by speedgoose 7y ago
> "We don't make pure electric cars because for the time being, we think they're too heavy, and they don't make a cool sound. And as long as we can be CO2 neutral and frugal and clean comparatively, we will push the combustion engine."
I read that as "we don't give a fuck about emissions because we like vroom vroom and we plant a few trees to not feel bad about it".
I agree about the weight problem of large lithium batteries, and light hydrogen fuel cells may not deliver enough pick power, so I don't have a good solution for hyper cars. I just think that ICE engines shouldn't be in cars ASAP.
- Justin_K 7y agoThey make high performance cars, what do you expect? With your logic, any improvement to IC engines is evil...
- speedgoose 7y agoIt's ok to improve ICE engines. I'm sure some people continue to improve horse drawn carriages. Thankfully we don't have our cities full of horse poop anymore.
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoJesus. Not everybody lives or wants to live in a city. Get over it.
- speedgoose 7y agoYou never drive to a city ?
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoNot as often as driving over a horse poop when out and about in the countryside. And I’m not complaining about it. But when I’m there, I never really feel comfrtable walking around. It’s full of people on bicycles who don’t give a damn about pedestrians.
- Justin_K 7y agoWhy do you keep on saying "internal combustion engine" engines? Are you trolling?
- speedgoose 7y agoYou are a bit pedantic.
- manigandham 7y agoThis car has 3 electric motors and one of the smallest combustions engines ever in a hypercar while also running on carbon-neutral/clean fuel. Plenty of other hypercars also have electric assist and advanced engine management that gets them higher fuel efficiency and lower emissions than your average family SUV. Your concern is entirely misplaced. Also you should focus on industrial uses like container ships and coal power plants that create 1000x more pollution if you're really that serious about it. The world is moving as fast as it can, but oil is used for more than just transportation and it's not changing overnight.
- WanderPanda 7y agoWhy all this focus on weight? Regenerative breaking makes weight 80% more irrelevant, or did I miss something?
- speedgoose 7y agoIt's still good to be light on low speed corners. At high speed the aerodynamic down force is much greater. I think they just want to have a super fast car for a few people, and to do so you need to pollute with an ICE engine.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ska 7y agoThis is a performance car company. Weight is 100% relevant, it will help with acceleration and deceleration performance, cornering especially at speeds low enough that down force isn't determining your grip, and general responsiveness.
- dragontamer 7y agoRoad wear is IIRC to the 4th power of weight. That is to say, a 4500 lb Tesla Model S has 5x the road-wear of a 3000lb Toyota Camry. If all Tesla Model S drivers were willing to pay 500% the road-taxes to make up for their 5x damages that their cars do to our roads, I think I'll be cool with them using their road-destroying heavy batteries. And the F150 drivers too, while we're at it.
- djrogers 7y agoA Model 3 starts at 3,550lbs, vs 3,241 for a Camry. A model S is not in the same class as a Camry, so comparing them is not useful. A better comparison- a Mercedes S Class, starts at 4,500lbs to the 4,800lbs of a Tesla Model S. In both cases there’s a mere 300lb difference (less than 10%), which is way under the 1500lbs/ 50% difference your argument is based on.
- zaroth 7y agoYou are generally correct that a 4,500lb car will do 5x the road wear per mile than a 3,000lb vehicle. (Although some studies find damage increases closer to a power of 3 not 4). However it’s extremely important to ask... 5 times what number? The cost per mile in terms of road damage is mainly a function of axle weight and designed load and volume of the road surface. The damage per mile per ESAL (Equivalent Single Axle Load) can vary from $0.03/ESAL-mile to $5.90/ESAL-mile when you exceed the design load of the road. Low volume roads will have a higher ESAL because of natural wear exceeding use-based wear. Since passenger cars will never exceed the design load of a road, this is not a factor in our analysis (but it’s a very big deal for heavy trucks, particularly on rural roads). Since low volume road wear is predominantly due to natural causes and not road-use we should probably exclude those as well. Just to put this in perspective, the cost per mile per ESAL of $0.09 (a relatively high volume road that operates within vehicle weight design spec), gives us road damage for a light passenger car (3,000 pounds) or 0.0002 ESAL which equates to $1.80 per 100,000 miles. Increasing to an ESAL of 0.001 results in a wear cost of $9.00 per 100,000 miles. Basically all road wear comes from heavy trucks with an ESAL > 1. This is compounded when those trucks exceed the design load of the road, which can add another up to 500x multiplier on the damage per mile driven. The damage/road wear cost for passenger vehicles is a barely even a rounding error by comparison. Based on this simple analysis, I do not believe it is at all justified to claim that Teslas (or EVs in general) have “road-destroying heavy batteries.” [1] - https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/design-parameters/equivalent-single-axle-load/ https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/design... [2] - https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/reports/tswstudy/TSWwp3.pdf https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/reports/tswstudy/TSWwp3.pdf
- rbanffy 7y ago> "we don't give a fuck about emissions because we like vroom vroom" Some people like to compensate with cars what they lack in other attributes.
- speedgoose 7y agoI think a main reason why people in Europe don't buy the huge American pickup trucks to commute is because of that. They know everyone will joke about their penis size all the time, forever.
- gorbachev 7y agoThe roads in European cities are generally speaking much smaller than in the US. You'd have real difficulty navigating the roads in a pickup truck in Europe.
- speedgoose 7y agoYes, and these trucks use way too much gaz for European standards.
- kube-system 7y agoAnd European wallets. That side of the pond prefers spending less on cars to begin with, and is also usually taxed on CO2 on top of the high gas prices. I doubt the average Asda has a dozen late model 5L+ V8 vehicles out front with prices >$50,000 USD. But the average Walmart in the US does.
- Hamuko 7y agoThe main reason is that Europeans realize that you don't need one. If they actually need to haul a bunch of stuff, they'll buy a cargo van.
- rbanffy 7y agoLast time I rented one. Next time I'm moving houses, I'll rent another. Chances are it'll be electric.
- creddit 7y agoIf they are legitimately carbon neutral, why does it matter?
- DagAgren 7y agoIf. Biofuels are not environmentally friendly, at all.
- manigandham 7y agoThere are far bigger things to worry about than a limited run hypercar from a boutique manufacturer that uses the smallest gas engine, advanced engine management, and 3 electric motors to improve fuel efficiency and exhaust vastly beyond your typical family car.
- winrid 7y agoWell yeah. They're fun.
- andrepd 7y agoI'll be sure to keep that in mind if I'm one of the tens to hundreds of thousands of annual excess deaths due to pollution.
- winrid 7y agoOh, do you live next to a factory making parts for electric cars?
- manigandham 7y agoYou might want to reference what actually causes the most pollution. Massive container ships, coal power plants, and manufacturing facilities make consumer ICE vehicles insignificant in pollution potential.
- vinceguidry 7y agoThe engine burns alt-fuels. They took a lot of time and care to tune the engine so it can run carbon neutral. It's pretty sad to see this effort fall on deaf ears. Someone here doesn't care, but it's not Koenigsegg.
- lukeschlather 7y agoAlcohol-based fuels are, generally speaking, worse than gasoline or even diesel when you do a full life-cycle analysis. They are not carbon neutral. They could be, plausibly, but that technology has not been commercially demonstrated yet.
- alkonaut 7y agoIf you produce ethanol from locally sourced biomass using renewable power, you’ll get as close as you can. The figure 60% CO2 emission reduction (compared to gasoline) is often floated. Completely carbon neutral is difficult for any product of course. E85 is 15-24% gasoline too, which is neither renewable or carbon neutral. I still don’t think its a very good idea (cars are thirsty, infrastructure expensive, worse than both biogas and EV’s for climate etc).
- avalys 7y agoMore like “we don’t care about emissions because we only make 20 cars per year.” It makes no sense to get all up in arms about carbon emissions from sports cars. As a fraction of the market, even if you include more mainstream manufacturers like Porsche, they’re totally inconsequential. But of course, if you are really just using carbon emissions as a way to preach and brag about your morally superior lifestyle and/or political positions, expensive sports cars are a great target.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- speedgoose 7y agoI'm sorry that you assume that I feel morally superior. I don't. You can enjoy your ICE sport car, it's okay.
- praptak 7y agoIt's a philosophical question. Is the rarity actually a good excuse? I'd say no. We should not burn carbon without serious need, as rarity or not. This particular case is more complicated though - they are developing technology which may be a net saver in CO2 emissions in which case it sorta pays for itself.
- Hamuko 7y ago>We should not burn carbon without serious need, as rarity or not. This would require a ban on holiday air travel.
- avalys 7y agoWho determines what a serious need is? No ones needs a sports car. Or a 40” TV. Or to go golfing. Or Broadway shows. Movie theaters - for that matter, no one needs movies at all! Recreational international travel - totally unecesssary. Why does anyone need more than one house? A house larger than 2,000 square feet? Why does anyone need more than 2 kids?
- Hamuko 7y ago
- dragontamer 7y agoGiven the cost of Lithium Ion batteries, especially the human costs of mining Cobalt, I would argue that hybrids are the better technology today. You reduce the Lithium-Ion battery size, and then increase the range of cars. Li-Ion is also extremely heavy, reducing range, increasing wear-and-tear on the road. In overall costs, hybrids make sense today. We need another magnitude of improvements before Li-Ion batteries can completely replace ICE. But we are absolutely at the point where Li-Ion can augment cars in hybrid form. Maybe in a few years, a Cobalt-free battery would be mass produced (or other chemistry that doesn't need to be sourced from war-torn nations). And in the meantime, increasing ICE efficiency by 30% (on TOP of the Hybrid savings) is only a good thing.
- speedgoose 7y agoI think the human cost of gaz is underestimated. Between the wars, the pollution, the destruction of nature, it's not great. True some cobalt mines are a shame, some are even using children. I don't think any car manufacturer wants to be associated with that, so they try to use providers from "ok" mines. The range isn't really a problem for new electric cars and the weight will hopefully go down. Personally I think that the hybrids I can afford drive like shit compared to the fully electric cars I can afford.
- alkonaut 7y agoICE doesn’t necessarily mean fossil fuel. In Sweden where these cars come from you’ll find E85 (85% renewable ethanol) at every gas station. Not sure what the situation is like in other countries, but for someone who can afford a car like this, it should be possible to run it carbon neutral or nearly so. CO2 isn’t the only emission from an ICE vehicle however.
- speedgoose 7y agoWhy taking away lands from the nature or the food production to produce ethanol so people can enjoy ICE engine sounds ? Just use the fake engine sounds on the speakers (yes it's a thing).
- alkonaut 7y agoWe have 10k trees per person, and growing. We subsidize farmers to keep the forests from taking over the landscape here. Making ethanol from wheat or similar is bad, but from forest products in forest-covered countries seems ok. I don’t think a number of hypercars makes any difference to the climate issue. For the rest of us the solution is probably BEVs