8 ms·
Price isn't just the cost of buying something, it's the reward for producing it. If we see too many price gouging laws, then you can expect shortages as compani
by whatshisface 7y ago
Price isn't just the cost of buying something, it's the reward for producing it. If we see too many price gouging laws, then you can expect shortages as companies find themselves unable to justify extreme measures that would otherwise increase production (at great expense). Secondly, I would expect that localities with price gouging laws will discover that their goods are being re-routed to other places without those laws, exacerbating shortages further.
- nwah1 7y agoYep. A much better way to alleviate shortages would be to suspend sales taxes.
- bernawil 7y agoMost stuff is bought by scalpers and sold on the black market anyway
- logicchains 7y agoIt's not a black market if it's a market for legal goods, it's just a market.
- chillacy 7y agoJust not one where sales tax is paid I presume. It’s at least not part of the “formal economy” that will show up on a public profit and loss sheet.
- logicchains 7y agoFun fact: one term for the informal economy is "System D": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_D
- AsyncAwait 7y agoYep, here's that comment. Business benefit over direct customer benefit seems to be the manta these days.
- whatshisface 7y agoI'm not sure how the parent thinks it will help with shortages, but sales tax adds to the price that the consumer pays. On sales tax holidays you see prices go down.
- emayljames 7y agoAs I commented below, I don't think someone saying "oh look, I saved 10 cents" is going to stop price gouging. As much use as a chocolate fire guard.
- AsyncAwait 7y agoThe problem, from what I saw, is hoarders having stock piled 17,000 hand sanitizers and the like, not official stores selling them for too high a price.
- maxerickson 7y agoIn a country of 300 million people, a few semi trucks worth of hoarding isn't doing much of anything to availability of any particular product. It's the just-in-time nature of distribution. Demand doubles from "normal" and all of the sudden nothing is sitting on the shelf.
- AsyncAwait 7y agoWhich would be the case even without a sales tax? However, while no sales tax on hand sanitizers is hardly going to be of a measurable impact for an individual, when you're hoarding to squeeze people in crisis, no sales tax makes for a nice 'bulk discount'.
- blockmarker 7y ago
- emayljames 7y agoI don't think someone saying "oh look, I saved 10 cents" is going to stop price gouging. As much use as a chocolate fire guard.
- Dangeranger 7y agoWhen people charge 10-20X more for something that could have been purchased in a local store before the “arbitrage” businesses purchased all the inventory, that is clearly price gouging.
- ikeboy 7y agoIt depends on the details. The recent NYT article about buying in stores and selling online mentioned that more than 50% of the sale price could be eaten up in shipping and other fees.
- Erikun 7y agoIt also mentioned them making tens of thousands of dollars in profit in a short time.
- ikeboy 7y agoAnd tens of thousands in losses for products that were stuck. As I mentioned in my comment on the original article, the required margin goes up to account for risk. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22576051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22576051
- Dangeranger 7y agoThat’s because his business is inefficient. If he had left the products in place there wouldn’t be a scarcity in his local region that he then could profit from. He helped create the scarcity, and then profited from it.
- ikeboy 7y agoHe's not necessarily selling to the same region as it was bought from, as the original article mentions.
- rickyc091 7y ago"A nearby liquidation firm was selling 2,000 “pandemic packs,” leftovers from a defunct company. Each came with 50 face masks, four small bottles of hand sanitizer and a thermometer. The price was $5 a pack. Mr. Colvin haggled it to $3.50 and bought them all." "He quickly sold all 2,000 of the 50-packs of masks on eBay, pricing them from $40 to $50 each, and sometimes higher. He declined to disclose his profit on the record but said it was substantial." $100,000 gross revenue ($50 each), let's say shipping, fees, and price variance were 25%. That's still $75,000 for a $7,000 investment. 10x returns.
- geofft 7y agoIsn't price-gouging usually (and definitely in this context) about someone who bought an item at a standard wholesale price and is reselling it at a markup? That's not about the reward for producing it, that's about the reward for being in the right place at the right time. You can still try to argue that it's economically reasonable to reward people for being in the right place at the right time (to incentivize people to ship goods around etc.), but that's a very different argument from whether companies are able to fund increases of production.
- whatshisface 7y agoWell, from the perspective of the buyer it doesn't matter if you're buying it for 20x the price from CVS or from Joe Schmoe Markup Inc. It matters to CVS, but that's their problem.
- gpm 7y agoNo, it matters to the buyer, and everyone else, because that one transaction doesn't exist in a vacuum. If the buyer is giving the factory an extra 19x the price, the factory is incentivized to produce more, the buyer is substantially more likely to be able to buy more then next time they want to. Averaged over society the buyer is much more likely to be able to buy whatever they need the next time they need to buy anything. If it's Joe Schmoe Markup Inc getting the extra 19x the price, there is no benefit to society or the buyer. Joe Schmoe is just an asshole profiting off of making other people worse off. That should be criminal.
- tracker1 7y agoIf you're buying from retail and re-selling at over 4x the purchase cost, that's gouging... not even wholesale pricing, but retail.
- geofft 7y agoFor the most part, CVS isn't producing it, they're reselling it. I agree it doesn't matter which reseller is gouging, but it does matter to me whether I'm paying a markup to someone who was clever enough to hoard important goods (and thereby incentivizing hoarding) or whether I'm paying for increased cost of production (and thereby incentivizing production). Markets are a way of managing information. That's why things like "the stock market went up" or "the stock market went down" matter: it communicates what people believe about whether things are underpriced or overpriced. In turn, those beliefs are only worth paying attention to if participants have some reasonable information about the things they're buying and selling. While my individual purchase of a $50 bottle of hand sanitizer is a small drop in a bucket of information, it is conveying information, and everyone else paying for it absolutely does influence the market. When we communicate that we're willing to pay $50 for a bottle of hand sanitizer even if the cost of production has not gone up, it tells resellers that they should start hoarding. A clever reseller will stop selling their reserves entirely and wait for discovered prices to max out. That does matter quite a bit to me as a buyer!
- will_walker 7y agoThis isn’t the companies being punished - it’s the opportunists. These vultures are driving to every small pharmacy and clearing out all the masks and sanitizer. Now that Amazon & EBay have cracked down on reseller gouging, some are sitting on stockpiles through the midst of a pandemic. * https://www.nytimes.com./2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-purell-wipes-amazon-sellers.html?action=click&module=Spotlight&pgtype=Homepage https://www.nytimes.com./2020/03/14/technology/coronavirus-p...
- whatshisface 7y agoWhy don't the pharmacies raise their own prices 20x before the scalpers can get to them? The answer is probably, "they don't want to get slapped by gouging laws." So in essence this is a prohibition scenario where lawful providers don't want to touch the situation and unlawful people fill the gap.
- Erikun 7y agoIsn't it more likely that regular sellers want to protect their brand, something that the arbitrage seller doesn't care about? After all, the California price-gouging law only takes effect once an emergency has been declared and regular stores, presumably, weren't increasing their price by 20x before that.
- ikeboy 7y agoAmazon and eBay banned all sales, regardless of price. Anyone relying on those platforms to sell products is stuck.
- siruncledrew 7y agoYes, for some reason people complaining about the supply-demand economics of price gouging laws seem to think Clorox, Charmin, Kleenex, etc are the ones jacking up the prices of supplies... Manufacturers producing enough quantities to sell is not the issue. The assholes that swoop in and buy out all the stock in a store temporarily to quickly turn around and sell the items for much more are doing the gouging. It's like going to the gas station right after a refill with a big-rig tanker during a time of high demand, filling up all the gas from the station, and then sitting next to the now-empty gas station all day and charging people 500% more for gas. That is why stores are now implementing quantity limits for certain supplies, so people don't just hoard them for profit and to deny everyone else access to buying the supplies.
- jka 7y agoHere is a link to the relevant section of the California penal code: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=396.&lawCode=PEN https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio... "While the pricing of consumer goods and services is generally best left to the marketplace under ordinary conditions, when a declared state of emergency or local emergency results in abnormal disruptions of the market, the public interest requires that excessive and unjustified increases in the prices of essential consumer goods and services be prohibited." Emphasis mine. This definition still allows producers to pass on increased costs, as long as they are not excessive and unjustified.
- ComputerGuru 7y agoAnd only in a state of emergency. If you’re in Egypt, that can be thirty years or more. In California, probably not.
- nfjfo9nnd 7y ago“While the pricing of consumer goods and services is generally best left to the marketplace under ordinary conditions...” They forget to mention that the marketplace is highly optimized at the foundation to make this bullshit. There’s no open marketplace. The government protects concepts like inflation which is the deflation of buying power of the masses to prop up the power of aristocrats. I have zero qualms with government stepping in to actually create some pricing competition. Financial “value” is not a property of an objection reality. It’s a human ideology. No one in economics disputes this. And somehow we’re convinced old gits dumber than us, outnumbered us have sold us on truth of markets. They pray on confusing and controlling our innate behavior to model our future. “Oh guess my model will be these cube walls forever.” And I’m talking specifically about the bulk producers of basic human needs, food, material supplies, medicine. How shallow and self aggrandizing America as a culture is is on display right now. A weak ass people who coddle old gits because they can’t source local TP, and toothpaste? The people are so incapable of absorbing a true calamity in this nation is frightening.
- generalpass 7y agoExcessive and unjustified seem quite subjective. Not subjective is exporting to Japan.
- jseliger 7y agoYes. These laws are bad. Mike Munger of Duke University explains more here: https://www.econtalk.org/munger-on-price-gouging/ https://www.econtalk.org/munger-on-price-gouging/
- amiga_500 7y agoMight company bosses just keep doing their job because they are decent people?