12 ms·
Ask HN: Have you been infected by Covid-19? What is it like?
Might be useful to provide some information about existing conditions you may have so that we can get a picture of what symptoms to watch for beyond the "fever and difficulty to breathe" described by most sources.
- danek_szy 7y agoSymptoms as described by WHO: - https://i.cbc.ca/1.5496615.1584111464!/fileImage/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/original_780/covid-19-symptom-chart.jpg https://i.cbc.ca/1.5496615.1584111464!/fileImage/httpImage/i... - https://sm.mashable.com/mashable_sea/photo/default/coronavirus-symptoms-eng_j6gy.png https://sm.mashable.com/mashable_sea/photo/default/coronavir...
- jsjddbbwj 7y agoAre there any major differences between this and the annual, regular flu?
- tomatotomato37 7y agoIt's essentially a somewhat more intense flu with no herd immunity, which means instead of spreading itself nicely throughout the year it comes in at once in a massive exponential spike that blows out the medical system I'm kinda curious though if this quarantining is also gonna significantly help with any other diseases already out in the wild. Would be nice if we ended up also clearing out some of the regular flu stains too
- coldcode 7y agoFlu season is already at the tail end so it would be hard to tell. Colds and flu spread in similar ways as CV19 so isolation should help that too.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI read somewhere the rate of colds and flu has fallen in Hong Kong.
- e12e 7y agoI seem to recall that during the svine flu, kindergardens and schools emphasized better hygiene (wash hands, hand sanitizer, cough in elbow) - with a (at least anecdotal) dramatic reduction in sick leave. As kids didn't get sick at the same rate, did not infect parents who did not spread it in the work place at the usual rate.
- cm2012 7y agoDeath rate is between 5x-25x higher, hospitalization rate even higher than that. Regular flu has a .01 death rate, Covid is at .08 right now in Korea and like 4% in Italy.
- ComputerGuru 7y ago> Regular flu has a .01 death rate, Covid is at .08 right now in Korea and like 4% in Italy. Dude. You can’t mix units like that. The flu has a 0.095% death rate, S. Korea’s current Covid-19 death rate is 0.7%, and Italy’s rate is around 5%. You made both the flu and South Korea’s situation out to be ten times worse than they were.
- senordevnyc 7y agoActually think they just forgot the % sign, and added extra zeros to flu and Korea numbers. I think they meant to say 0.1% and 0.8%, which isn’t far off.
- playpause 7y agoIt’s worth noting Italy’s much higher death rate is because the hospitals are full, and this is likely to happen in other countries soon. The proportion of Covid-19 patients that require intubation is much higher than that of flu. Several other European countries and the US are on roughly the same infection rate trajectory as Italy, just a few weeks behind. Unless they significantly slow it down, it seems likely their health systems will be overwhelmed too, and their death rates could start looking more like Italy’s.
- cutemonster 7y agoIn addition to that, I read that there are more old people in Italy too -- another factor contributing to the higher numbers there.
- makomk 7y agoItaly is probably also just not testing people who don't have serious symptoms. They've been hovering around a 15% positive rate on tests, about half of which have to be hospitalized, which is a lot compared to other countries.
- axiomdata316 7y agoWhat's alarming and kind of ironic is that COVID 19 has a lack of symptoms compared to the common flu. Aches and pains sometimes for COVID 19 as opposed to aches and pains common for the common flu. Runny nose sometimes for COVID 19 but runny nose common for the Common Flu. Its almost to say if you feel really bad you probably don't have COVID 19 unless you really start having trouble breathing. It's helps me appreciate the need to stay home if I just start getting SOME of the symptoms for the flu like a fever. Don't wait for body aches or a runny nose.
- mantap 7y agoThe important thing is that achy muscles don't spread disease (quite the reverse) but coughing does. So people with a recent bad cough should stay at home.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoEven if it's only flu people should try and avoid spreading it around at the moment.
- chalst 7y agoThe February report from WHO did not list runny nose as a symptom. If you do have a runny nose, though, that increases the riskiness of hand-nose contact as an infection pathway. https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/who-china-joint-mission-on-covid-19-final-report.pdf https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/who-chi...
- perlgeek 7y agoThose two tables contradict each other. The first says runny nose is not a symptom of COVID-19, the other says "sometimes". This just shows how little we know (and/or how much misinformation there is about it), and that a differential diagnosis based on symptoms is basically impossible (at least for a non-expert).
- Barrin92 7y agoit's also quite possible that some people suffer both from covid-19 and the flu or a cold at the same time and the symptoms are being mixed up.
- danek_szy 7y agoThen maybe this [1] clears things out. Probably differences in understanding what "sometimes" means. This shows specific frequency/percentages. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-symptoms/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-sympto...
- okareaman 7y agoI'm a retired programmer who does ride sharing in Silicon Valley. I often pick up people at the San Jose airport. Sometimes they are coming in from China or Seattle. I live in a Chinese neighborhood. I gave a woman who couldn't breath a ride to the emergency room. When I got sick in February, I figured it was the flu, but now realize it was probably Covid-19 based on symptoms. I recovered nicely and have been quarantining myself just in case. It's like the flu with the added difference that it makes breathing more difficult. Also difficulty swallowing. It was more annoying than anything, not really that bad. I don't have any health problems, but if I did have breathing issues, I imagine it might be very problematic.
- ekianjo 7y agoThanks for sharing. Did you take any medication to ease the symptoms?
- okareaman 7y agoNo, I don't like taking over the counter meds. The main thing is just get rest and try not to aggravate the coughing, which was a somewhat painful. I quit smoking last year, thank goodness. Chicken Noodle soup was really good for my sore throat and trouble swallowing.
- cageface 7y agoFrom what I've read sore throat is relatively rare as a symptom of covid-19: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-symptoms/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-sympto... Notably, the COVID-19 infection rarely seems to cause a runny nose, sneezing, or sore throat (these symptoms have been observed in only about 5% of patients). That doesn't mean you didn't have it, of course, but does suggest it might have just been a cold.
- username90 7y agoDoesn't dry cough imply sore throat (ie you cough since your throat is sore and irritated)? So people having a cough wont also mention that their throat is sore since it is unnecessary information? Edit: The way I experience is is that there is a constant tickle in my throat. It sometimes get so strong that I can't hold back a cough but most of the time it just stays a tickle. I call that sore throat, when I got it initially it surprised me and I got a cough attack but after that I've been able to suppress it and not cough for days.
- benrrio 7y agoI have had a fever for a week and difficulty breathing. I have asked my doctor about getting tested for Covid19 and they have declined to test me because I don't meet the critical criteria: age > 60, around large groups of people, etc. I run in circles with someone that returned from Italy and has been confirmed to have Covid19. I'm assuming I have it. The fever isn't so bad for me but there have been a few times where I thought I would die from not being able to breath. There is only one thing I did that helped with the breathing but it fits in the old wife's tales category so I wont post it here since I don't want to be mocked for it. We used to the same thing 10 years ago to get my Mother-in-law off the ventilator when they told us she would never get off. Today is day 6 since the fever started and the fever is gone today, still feeling weak.
- adonese 7y agoI'm really grateful you're getting better. I had a very strong flu two years ago, it was the toughest flu (or any diseases) i ever had. I fall apart and lost conscious three times, the cough was very strong that i wouldn't be able to breathe for a few seconds. It was really terrifying experience, and from what i read it is quite simialr to covid-19 symptoms. For the throat issue, we use hibiscus (hot) with ginger. It really helps a lot to relief the pain and ease your breathing.
- smoyer 7y agoSome of the old-wives tales were descriptions of things that worked just like a lot of the herbal medicines. We didn't know why they worked so I agree it's hard to call them science. It's also possible it worked for you due to placebo effects, but you describe having a sample size of two! I hope we don't mock people for stating anecdotal evidence. I have seen mocking for statements that clearly contradict evidence (cough-cough flat-earth cough) or when people clearly have confused anecdotal evidence with fact. I'm curious now what you meant ... maybe it would work for others and if it falls into the category of "can't hurt", why not share it. NOTE: the coughing above is not a self-diagnosis on my part.
- klodolph 7y ago> We didn't know why they worked so I agree it's hard to call them science. Science doesn't always tell us why something works, but it may tell us "whether". The theory of whether something works is much easier to understand and test than the theory of why or how. It may not be rigorous science with good experimental design, that's all.
- kjakm 7y agoIt might be worth taking a look on Twitter. This doctor is 'live' tweeting his experience with the disease including lung scans [1]. Based on some other first hand experiences I've read on the Twitter/News people's experience varies wildly. Some people say it's not much worse than the flu. On the otherhand I saw a tweet from one doctor who had it claim it was worse than child birth so seems like the variation in experience can be massive. [1] https://twitter.com/yaletung https://twitter.com/yaletung
- mmcnl 7y agoCouldn't this be because doctors in hospitals only see patients who require hospitalization? That gives them a bias.
- kjakm 7y agoThe two doctors I was referring to were referring to their own experiences of having the disease (not of observing patients). Not sure I made that clear enough.
- samfriedman 7y ago>people's experience varies wildly Here's an article about two Chinese women with COVID-19, with very different outcomes. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/13/world/asia/coronavirus-death-life.html?algo=top_conversion&fellback=false&imp_id=488592137&imp_id=369373730 https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/13/world/asia/co...
- rntksi 7y agoWhat a heart wrenching article. When it's just numbers people can brush it off, but when it has a human face and story, I think that's when it really hits most people. More so when it affects closed ones too. I've been repeating this to my students: don't panic, but be cautious.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoDoctors' reports seem more trustworthy than patient social media because patient social media is likely to have a stronger selection bias. If you're in excruciating pain (or just part of an older demographic) you're less likely to be tweeting about it than if you have a mild cough, so expect harsher symptoms to be underrepresented.
- criddell 7y agoAfter reading a lot of reporting about this, it isn't clear to me if Covid-19 is the name of the virus or the disease or both. I realize that for laymen (like me) it doesn't really matter. But academically speaking, is there a difference?
- haunter 7y agoAs far as I know: COVID-19 (Coronavirus disease 2019) is the disease. SARS-CoV-2 (Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2) is the virus.
- bthrn 7y agoThe novel coronavirus is the virus, Covid19 is the disease it causes. Similar to HIV being the virus and AIDS being the disease it can cause.
- burakemir 7y agoCovid-19 ist the disease. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019 https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2... The virus itself is called SARS-CoV-2 and previously 2019-nCoV https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Severe_acute_respiratory_syndrome_coronavirus_2 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Severe_acute_respiratory_syn...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aufav36 7y agoHave 4 family members that have been tested positive for COVID-19 in Austria: - Male (56), no symptoms except weak voice - Female (55), no symptoms - Male (80), light fever (37,7C), weak voice - Female (81), no symptoms These cases are all connected, and we have talked with others that seem to have caught the same variant/mutation. None of them does really show symptoms, no hospitalizations, no real fever, and no hard breathing. Hope this is a light variant/mutation, and the situation stays the same for them.
- alexilliamson 7y agoIs there a significant amount of testing going on in Austria, compared to other countries? I'm suprised that you mention these people were tested without symptoms.
- aufav36 7y agoThe amount of testing seems to be ramping up, but we also hear reports that results now take up to three days to get back, where we got the results for our tests (which happened on Wednesday and Thursday) on the next day. As for symptoms: Male (56) fought quite hard to get one, as he had long direct contact with a positive-tested person. Male (80) got one because of "risk group" (age) and symptoms (light fever).
- y7 7y agoI read that here in the Netherlands the testing capacity is limited by a shortage of little plastic slabs that hold ~90 test samples at a time. One tactic to increase capacity is to not test the samples until the slab is full, which also delays test results.
- holri 7y ago14.03.2020, 15:00 Tests: 7.467 Confirmed: 655 recovered: 6 dead: 1 Austria has approx. 8 Mio inhabitants official source: https://www.sozialministerium.at/Informationen-zum-Coronavirus/Neuartiges-Coronavirus-(2019-nCov).html https://www.sozialministerium.at/Informationen-zum-Coronavir...
- noevil4 7y agoTake good care
- amai 7y agoHere is an interview with one of the first patients in Germany: https://www.br.de/radio/bayern1/coronavirus-in-bayern-100.html https://www.br.de/radio/bayern1/coronavirus-in-bayern-100.ht... The interview is in German but maybe Google Translate can help. His symptoms however have been very mild.
- anttisalmela 7y agoOne Finnish entrepreneur describes his so far mild infection: https://perjantaikokki.fi/2020/03/14/greetings-from-a-corona-positive-patient-from-quarantine/ https://perjantaikokki.fi/2020/03/14/greetings-from-a-corona...
- makomk 7y agoSky News ran an interview with a woman in London diagnosed with Covid-19: https://news.sky.com/story/coronavirus-london-woman-who-caught-coronavirus-in-italy-describes-covid-19-11956362 https://news.sky.com/story/coronavirus-london-woman-who-caug... It doesn't seem like something that can really be spotted based on the symptoms, which is probably why it's so hard to contain.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chewz 7y ago‘I was stupidly overconfident’: a South Korean coronavirus survivor’s tale https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/health-environment/article/3075170/i-was-stupidly-overconfident-south-korean-coronavirus https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/health-environment/article/30...
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoYour comment about not being older than 60 to get tested made me so angry and shows how fucked the US is. Testing has nothing to do with protecting you (the current treatment for Covid-19 is the same as any other severe respiratory illness), it's about deciding who needs to be quarantined and have their contacts tracked to protect other people. While the severity of symptoms varies by age, the transmissibility does not. The numbers are many multiples of what is being reported.
- Vinnl 7y agoAs I understand it, in GP's case it's already clear that the decision should be to quarantine without needing a test. Additionally, at least were I live, the number of cases has gotten so big that it has become unfeasible to track their contacts. Thus, there's not much use in testing.
- Yetanfou 7y ago> Your comment about not being older than 60 to get tested made me so angry and shows how fucked the US is I live in the (presumed) social democratic paradise of Sweden where the "government" has just decided to stop testing anyone who is not already in a hospital and belongs to a risk group, i.e. anyone under ~65 years of age without any co-morbidities [1 - Swedish]. The "state epidemiologist" Anders Tegnell has other wisdom to spread to the world like the fact that a call for as many companies to have as many employees as possible working from home is "problematic" because it ends up exposing some people to more risk of infection than others and thus offset the principle of "fairness" in society [2 - Swedish]. In other words, if we can not lower the risk of exposure for everyone we should not lower the risk for anyone. He is also against school closures because children can not get infected - oh, they can? OK, because children don't get very ill - but they'll still spread the infection to those who can get very ill? OK, because some children don't have it all that nice at home so it would not be fair to them to close the schools. Again, if we can not make it better for everyone it is preferable to not do anything at all. Sweden is now coming under heavy criticism from other countries, China being one of them [3 - Swedish] when they state "Sweden has capitulated in front of the virus and stands to become a danger to other countries". This is probably part of an ongoing spat between Sweden and China where Sweden earlier criticised China's actions against a Chinese-Swedish citizen but there is no denying that the Swedish "government" has shown a lack of foresight and proactive strategies. There is a dearth of supplies, Sweden has the lowest number of hospital beds per capita in the OECD which is odd for the country with the highest taxes in the world, the health care system can not cope with the normal case load let alone with an influx of Corona-related patients. [1] https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/samhalle/a/70GQRV/nya-strategin--slutar-rakna-exakta-antalet-coronafall https://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/samhalle/a/70GQRV/nya-str... [2] https://nyheteridag.se/tegnell-ojamlikt-att-spotifys-anstallda-far-jobba-hemma/ https://nyheteridag.se/tegnell-ojamlikt-att-spotifys-anstall... [3] https://www.svd.se/kina-riktar-skarp-coronakritik-mot-sverige https://www.svd.se/kina-riktar-skarp-coronakritik-mot-sverig...
- batter 7y agoI would be rather interested if anyone tried zinc supplements. I do get that Choloquine is ideally should be also part of regimen, but since it's prescription only, so you can't simply get it.
- pillefitz 7y agoI bought Cinchona bark, which contains quinine, hypothesizing it might work against the virus. Hope I don't need to verify.
- 8fingerlouie 7y agoAccording to the danish health authorities, the symptoms include: Fever, airway infection/breathing problems, chills, muscle aches, sore throat, headache, diarrhea and vomiting. As far as I can tell they’re listed in order of frequency. As for “airway infection” they mention dry cough and runny nose. From what I can tell the symptoms are more or less similar to a regular seasonal flu or a common cold, but with much more severe outcomes for some.
- amiga_500 7y agoYet to see a post from someone healthy who can say: - Had covid - Had shortness of breath - Recovered - Back to running now - No notable lung capacity issues post recovery Not saying they are not out there.
- RalfWausE 7y agoI remember this guy from China who gave an interview titled "To Hell and back" or something like this... perhaps its just to early for the western media to bring recovery stories. As far as i remember from the things i have read, recovery takes around two to three weeks, add to this the recovery period from a "normal" pneumonia wich can take additional weeks (my father had a light pneumonia last winter, so i remember...). Perhaps in the chinese media / social media we could find more answers... anyone who can read chinese here?
- excitednumber 7y agohttps://nypost.com/2020/03/12/woman-who-survived-coronavirus-shares-her-early-symptoms/ https://nypost.com/2020/03/12/woman-who-survived-coronavirus...
- amiga_500 7y agoThanks, but this really doesn't discuss her post-illness lung capacity, it was simply that she didn't feel that ill during it.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoFYI everyone, you're going to get a huge selection bias here. The kind of infected person who's going to see and answer this question will likely have symptoms on the milder side. Answers here should not be expected to be remotely representative.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoExactly. The few really sick people who are 70-80+ years old will likely not be social media users.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoAnd really sick social media users are less likely to be posting.
- leereeves 7y agoThere's also a huge selection bias the other way, in that people with mild symptoms may not even know they have been infected with covid-19.
- vinni2 7y agoI was sick couple of weeks ago and symptoms were very similar to Coronavirus and my doctor dismissed the need to get tested for Coronavirus because I didn’t travel to any of the hotspots. I am feeling better now but I will never know if I had the virus.
- pfdietz 7y agoEventually there will be a test for antibodies, assuming you develop long lasting immunity.
- rv-de 7y agoA recurring symptom mentioned here is difficulty breathing. That's terrible and can easily cause harmful feedback loop. I'm mid-30s so I will try to defer medicinal interaction for as long as possible. To self-assess the seriousness of breathing issues I intend to make us of a pulsoxymeter. Is there somebody here who could suggest a rule set for when to seek help? Something like: seek help if SpO2 - between 85% and 90% for more than 48 hours - between 80% and 85% for more than 24 hours - below 80% immediately (actually I do feel mildly ill and as if breathing is a little bit more uncomfortable than usual - but according to my pulsoxymeter SpO2 is at healthy 98% with a pulse around 60 bpm. so everything seems perfectly fine)
- Eugeleo 7y agoAs per this reference [1] (that also has a lot of other useful info and links) > If you think you’ll fret a lot about whether you need to go the hospital, get a pulse oximeter ($20 on Amazon). Readings consistently below 90-94% are pretty bad and mean you should seek immediate treatment. [1]: https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/02/coronavirus-links-speculation-open-thread/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/02/coronavirus-links-spec...
- rsync 7y agoI am an EMR in California and provide (emergency) medical care relatively frequently. "To self-assess the seriousness of breathing issues I intend to make us of a pulsoxymeter." I like the idea of owning a pulse oximeter and have them in all of my first aid kits. However, I think of them as providing immediate information about an acute breathing problem. Your SpO2 should be around 98 always. If you go below 95, something is really wrong and requires immediate attention. You will be displaying signs of breathing difficulty and you're not going to see if it lasts 24 or 48 hours. If you are not tremendously affected by a cold/flu/coronavirus, I would expect you to have a ~98 SpO2 throughout, even if you feel terrible and perhaps feel your breathing is a bit labored. " ... below 80% immediately ..." Just to put this in perspective, all else being equal, you're not going to be coherent or functional in any way below 80%. I would personally call 911 if I saw an otherwise normal person below 90 and I would be very concerned if I saw readings below 95 - especially if the trendline was down ...
- japan-throwaway 7y agoI hesitate to post this because I haven’t been tested, but I can’t help but wonder. I live in Tokyo. 3 weeks ago I woke up in the middle of the night vomiting, and had a ~38.5C (101F) fever for 2 days. Muscle aches, very fatigued etc, but no real breathing problems - basically a tougher-than-average flu. I went to the doctor and tested negative for influenza. The policy at the time in Japan was not to test for COVID-19 unless the patient had a cough. My wife came down with the same symptoms a couple of days later and had an intermittent 38~9C (102F) fever for three days, and also tested negative for influenza (we both have flu shots every year, if that’s relevant). A couple of weeks later we (plus 2yo child) all have cold-like symptoms and a cough, and are keeping ourselves isolated. It isn’t possible to get tested now unless we have a fever, so who knows. Our child has not had a fever at all and seems quite cheerful apart from a runny nose and cough. 3 weeks ago I would have had to have been quite unlucky to catch it which makes me wonder if I’m just a hypochondriac, but the timing makes me wonder. We’re all on the mend and I don’t feel there’s any need to tie up medical resources, but it would be nice to know for sure if we have / had it. Again I hesitate to write this because I don’t wish to add to the mountain of misinformation out there, but at the same time I’d be very interested to learn if anyone has had a similar experience.
- andrewseanryan 7y agoI was not tested although I went to the doctor 4 times over 5 weeks. I went to Milan from Munich in January. Upon returning to Munich, I was hit with a sudden, dry cough. It was noticeably different from anything I had experienced before. I went to bed and woke with a fever of about 102. It lasted for days and I developed a very strange lung issue. On every exhale it sounded like 1000 pop rocks going off in my upper lungs/throat. The sound was loud enough to wake me. I “recovered”, with lasting lung issues for about two weeks. A week later I developed another fever that lasted 3 days. I then had intense night sweats for 2-3 weeks. If I had it, it would go against many of the models of when it reached Milan. If I didn’t have it, I had some other monster illness that hit the lungs hard.
- masonic 7y agoRequest: for those who report positive tests, please advise if they were told whether active virus was found or just viral DNA (contagious vs not), and sample source (oral swabs, anal, both).
- notahacker 7y ago34 year old healthy male, non smoker and no relevant medical conditions. Not tested [govt policy] but it's a completely unfamiliar infection of the lungs picked up in a major European city, so go figure... No proper fever [some of my sleep is the slightly fitful sleep I'd associate with fighting off mild infections, but my temperature is normal or very close], I've coughed only a literal handful of times and not painfully, so clearly sufficiently mild to miss those characteristic responses, no headache and only occasional feelings of fatigue and a bit more sleep than usual. Just inflamed lungs which are more uncomfortable than painful. Back when I felt completely healthy last Wednesday and went for a 3k outdoor run (no more uncomfortable or slower than I'd have expected considering I haven't run much this year) I obviously felt like I was breathing a bit too shallowly and breathing deoxygenated air at the end. This is basically that same feeling coming back the following day, except with a normal breathing rate [and heart rate]. I can still take a deeper breath whenever I want and I'm far from worrying I'm about to run out of oxygen, but just feels uncomfortable and I can imagine how it can cause much more serious problems for people with more severe symptoms, pre-existing lung conditions or immune system issues. It's been steady for the last five days.