9 ms·
SVT-AV1: open-source AV1 encoder and decoder
- sho_hn 7y agoNo further mention of rav1e from Mozilla/Xiph/Vimeo, which seems like the more relevant benchmark comparison than libaom.
- clouddrover 7y agoWhy? rav1e doesn't yet achieve the same quality as libaom.
- ComputerGuru 7y agoI definitely got better quality with rav1e than libaom (via ffmpeg), before I gave up on the latter altogether.
- clouddrover 7y agoHere are some measured results. rav1e is worse than libaom and SVT-AV1: https://www.reddit.com/r/AV1/comments/f1h2u1/aom_vs_rav1e_vs_svtav1_vs_x265_vs_vp9_vs_svtvp9/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AV1/comments/f1h2u1/aom_vs_rav1e_vs... https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?p=1893776#post1893776 https://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?p=1893776#post1893776
- zbraniecki 7y agoIn numbers, yes, but, quoting from reddit: ``` I agree AOM is the best quality now. But between Rav1e and SVT-AV1 it's not so clear for me. When you look metrics, SVT-AV1 is clearly the winner. But when I do side to side comparison ( e.g with online comparison tool like https://svt.github.io/vivict/ https://svt.github.io/vivict/ ) for me SVT-AV1 blur too much and don't have the same details retention than rav1e and I found rav1e much more pleasant ( my opinion) . I hope at some point there will be some real human a/b testing study. ```
- ComputerGuru 7y agoPerhaps things have improved for libaom since the last time I tried it but my issue wasn’t overall quality so much as sections of videos that had way too many very much visible artifacts (to me it looked like there were likely bugs rather than a poor design).
- clouddrover 7y agoYouTube is using libaom for its many, many AV1 encodes. Without knowing the version you used or the settings you used there isn't much that can be usefully talked about. What we can say is that libaom is good enough to be used on the world's biggest video website.
- mekster 7y agoA personal use and a company with massive computing power is so different.
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoI agree with the OP’s assessment - as recently as two weeks ago, Libaom was too slow to even do quality testing on real footage. And that’s with forty modern Xeon cores. The fact that YouTube uses it only proves the increasingly obvious business model they use in the space, namely the monopolization of the encoding ecosystem by literally throwing away money to steer people clear of rav1e.
- clouddrover 7y agoThe practical reality is that libaom is benchmarked against routinely. It is the benchmark. See some benchmarks here: https://videocodectracker.dev/ https://videocodectracker.dev/ https://arewecompressedyet.com/ https://arewecompressedyet.com/
- sho_hn 7y agoThey're the real-production-use competitors to me, since it's a performance vs. quality trade-off game. libaom is slow! In reality I am going to use SVT or rav1e, so anything that helps me pick ...
- clouddrover 7y agoIf the question is speed then the answer is SVT-AV1. It already does well versus libvpx VP9 and x265 HEVC: https://medium.com/@ewoutterhoeven/av1-is-ready-for-prime-time-svt-av1-beats-x265-and-libvpx-in-quality-bitrate-and-speed-31c1960703db https://medium.com/@ewoutterhoeven/av1-is-ready-for-prime-ti... rav1e has a ways to go to match it.
- codelord 7y agoWhy does Netflix publish articles on paywalled websites? Are they aware that users need to pay Medium to read their articles? I get this error: "You’ve reached the end of your free member preview for this month. Become a member now for $5/month to read this story and get unlimited access to all of the best stories on Medium."
- neophyt3 7y agoClear the cookies, and use it
- aaronblohowiak 7y agoThe medium publishing flow is weird, let me look at this and see if i can fix it. Edit: Update, it looks like the story is not opted into distribution / should not be part of the paywall. Can anyone from Medium chime in?
- encom 7y ago>Why does Netflix publish articles on paywalled websites? Maybe nobody there can figure out how to set up a web server? Maybe they get a kickback from Medium subscriptions? So many questions. You can usually bypass the paywall with the archiver: https://archive.ph/gv8T6 https://archive.ph/gv8T6
- mekster 7y ago> Maybe nobody there can figure out how to set up a web server? Huh? It's their business for sake.
- toohotatopic 7y agoAre you aware that users need to pay Netflix to watch their videos? They believe in pay-for-content. If it is right for their videos, why should it be wrong for their articles?
- dabei 7y agoAV1 Encoding is ready for prime time. However hardware decoder is mostly absent, which blocks adoption in mobile apps. (Dav1d is great, but consumes too much power on mobile devices)
- y0ssar1an 7y agoThe 2020 iPhones are rumored to have hardware AV1 decoders.
- ksec 7y agoI seriously doubt that.
- clouddrover 7y agoI wouldn't seriously doubt it. It will be fast enough to do it in software anyway. Netflix has rolled out AV1 to Android and you can opt-in if you want: https://netflixtechblog.com/netflix-now-streaming-av1-on-android-d5264a515202 https://netflixtechblog.com/netflix-now-streaming-av1-on-and...
- sjwright 7y agoLet's look at the basic facts: Apple is a governing member of AOM (Alliance for Open Media). A patent-free implementation of a hardware AV1 decoder is available right now. Apple makes its own chips with significant revisions every year. Apple seems to like being on the forefront of mobile silicon and already stuffs its chips full of things orders of magnitude more elaborate than this. Apple now runs their own streaming network and being able to offer AV1 encodes stretches their bandwidth further. Consider also that iPhone chips of today inevitably become the Apple TV chips of tomorrow. But most importantly of all, there's no commercial or competitive incentive for Apple not to do it. All of its serious competitors license the patent encumbered codecs and would need to continue doing so indefinitely just like Apple.
- mekster 7y ago
- e12e 7y agoNice. > For estimating encoding times, we used Intel(R) Xeon(R) Platinum 8170 CPU @ 2.10GHz machine with 52 physical cores and 96 GB of RAM, with 60 jobs running in parallel. Would love to see some comparisons with amd, at some point. Is there currently an easy way to run this on multiple machines? Back in the day, I'd probably try a single image cluster, like openmosix - but I'm not aware of anything similar for modern setups - neither self-host or "hardware on tap"?
- clouddrover 7y ago> Would love to see some comparisons with amd Here are some comparisons of various SVT-AV1 releases on Intel and AMD CPUs: https://openbenchmarking.org/showdown/pts/svt-av1 https://openbenchmarking.org/showdown/pts/svt-av1
- e12e 7y agoThanks. Nice to see 60fps 1080p is within reach for certain profiles. Anyone know how big the difference is up to 4k for typical video? Is it more or less than 4x?
- mstade 7y agoSeeing the title I thought this was something developed by the Swedish public service broadcasting company SVT, which also has a pretty extensive online streaming service and so it wouldn't be too far fetched an idea that they might work on something like this. Finally – I thought – taxpayer money being out to good use. Anyway, cool tech, well done! Hope it takes off and hardware encoders/decoders start to become common place as well.
- ksec 7y ago>The results are presented for 1-pass mode with fixed frame-level QP offsets. A single-threaded compression mode is used. Why is it 1-Pass? and if I may, use the word "again". Every time when it is compared to LibAOM, it is always one pass.
- clouddrover 7y agoThere's a 2 pass comparison in the article. The graph comes from their comparison site which uses 2 pass encoding for both SVT-AV1 and libaom: https://videocodectracker.dev/ https://videocodectracker.dev/