9 ms·
By delaying the "pandemic" designation, the WHO has inadvertently cost more lives. They will strongly need to reevaluate their role and policies going forward,
by echelon 7y ago
By delaying the "pandemic" designation, the WHO has inadvertently cost more lives. They will strongly need to reevaluate their role and policies going forward, because this was a monumental process and leadership failure.
The messaging from the media (who are laypersons) and the politicians (who are economically motivated laypersons) has been that this is "just the flu". Weak messaging from both the WHO and the CDC has only reinforced this in the public's perception.
The WHO should have taken the decisive move to encourage greater caution by employing the "pandemic" label. That label comes with real power. While there is danger in crying wolf, it was evident months ago from the growth rate of the virus and the lack of quarantine procedures being put in place that this virus would reach the pandemic stage.
If the role of the WHO is to stave off pandemics and not just to monitor them, then elevating the risk profile of the virus should have been a top priority. Since people look to the WHO for guidance, their actions have direct impact to sequestration and bringing the outbreak under control.
Both the WHO and the CDC were too afraid to take early action. Their wait and see approach will ultimately result in more human deaths and suffering.
- gjs278 7y agooh my god I sincerely hope you catch the virus. you are annoying as hell. the WHO isn’t responsible for any of this shit. have some self reliance. you’re like a fucking turtle stuck upside down on its shell.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoI don’t know what “media” you’re referring to, put the idea that it’s being dismissed as “just the flu” by anyone except the US government and their alt-right propaganda channels strikes me as blatantly wrong.
- kortilla 7y ago> their alt-right propaganda channels Sure, those classic alt-right propaganda outlets like the Today show.
- sounds 7y agoThere's also the political backlash if the WHO accurately says, "this is a pandemic," early enough to flatten the curve and save lots of lives. Do you expect politicians to actually think? Especially when they can point at the "fakenews WHO." (I don't know how Trump would actually say it but you get the picture.) If the WHO declares a pandemic early, they _do_ save lives. But they take the political beating because "nothing happened." If the WHO declares a pandemic late, they don't save lives. They take a mild wrist slap because "they were late to declare it," which will not be remembered in about a month.
- hoka-one-one 7y agoExactly. The media has fallen victim to corporations and special interest groups. This is why I'm voting for Bernie Sanders, personally.
- airstrike 7y agoAnd, as leader of the Executive Branch of the government, what exactly will he do to change the private media so that it's not serving private interests?
- hoka-one-one 7y agoIt's about what we're saying, it's about sending a message. That we won't be bullied by the corporations and special interest groups, and we'll divert our aid to those who are in need and struggling. There is nothing radical about that.
- Bubbadoo 7y agoWell, if 30 years of public service Bernie has performed are any indicator, absolutely nothing. Bernie's full of these big, revolutionary, expensive ideas, but he's really accomplished very little in his career. Look at Vermont... second thought, don't look at Vermont (hint: business abandoned the high taxes of Vermont decades ago). Economically, VT is a basket case, do you want Bernie to work his magic on a national level?
- hoka-one-one 7y agoYes
- wolco 7y agoEvery mainstream news outlet in Canada. Followed by National, local polical leaders of all groups. On the advise from health official. Who get directives from the WHO.
- LeoNatan25 7y agoYou must not be watching a lot of TV. I constantly hear and see "experts" and talk show hosts claiming "don't panic, it's just a bad flu", or "nobody speaks about the dead of flu, why do you care now" and some such nonsense. The "wash your hands" meme is also spreading around.
- SuperFerret 7y agoYeah that's the alt-right propaganda you're falling for. Real experts simply said "Don't panic, be more sanitary."
- beaunative 7y agoTo be honest, it is a bad flu, as what we call as flu is also most commonly caused by coronavirus. Though its death rate is 200% worse than a common flu with proper hospitalization.
- rsynnott 7y ago... Eh? No; what we call the flu is caused by the influenza virus. What we call the common cold is sometimes caused by a coronavirus (about 25% of cases). And while actual mortality rates are unclear, even the most optimistic figures (South Korea, for instance), are far more than 200% normal seasonal flu rates.
- beaunative 7y agomy apologies
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- greenshackle2 7y agoMore like 900% to 2900% worse (10-30 times).
- rsynnott 7y agoThis may be a regional thing. I haven't seen anything like that in Ireland except from true crackpots (the actual insane people seem divided on whether COVID19 is imaginary or a bioweapon). Certainly not on any respectable news source.
- ascii_only 7y agoHow many people die each year from flu worldwide? How many times mortality of Covid-19 is bigger?
- tigershark 7y agoNot sure if it makes sense worldwide given that there are a lot of 3rd world countries, but in US the flu has a mortality rate 2 orders of magnitude less than covid-19.
- beaunative 7y agoMortality rate for COVID-19 is about 2-3% with medical care, and maybe 10% without. For common flu it's roughly 0.1% depends on when and where of the outbreak.
- mcguire 7y ago2-3% of confirmed cases or total estimated cases, including mild and asymptomatic cases that aren't reported?
- beaunative 7y agoMost mild cases are reported as they perform temperature check for everyone who enters and exit most if not all enclosures, so unless those people self-quarantined and never go out, they are likely be included in the statistics. Asymptomatic cases are extremely rare, if they infects multiple others, they will likely be identified through retrospection. Overall, I'd say those cases are unlikely to result in significant difference in the estimate.
- drusepth 7y agoAccording to the CDC, "between 291,000 and 646,000 people worldwide die from seasonal influenza-related respiratory illnesses each year" [1]. This is likely exacerbated by many countries not having ready access to flu vaccines and/or proper hospitalization for those that need it. Compare this to America-specific numbers, where 34,000,000 – 49,000,000 Americans catch a flu-related illness each year, yet only 20,000 – 52,000 result in death [2]. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2017/p1213-flu-death-estimate.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2017/p1213-flu-death-esti... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/preliminary-in-season-estimates.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/preliminary-in-season-e...
- xienze 7y ago> I don’t know what “media” you’re referring to, put the idea that it’s being dismissed as “just the flu” by anyone except the US government and their alt-right propaganda channels strikes me as blatantly wrong. Are you sure you've been paying attention longer than a week or two? The virus was being downplayed all of January and February by the media and other people not named Trump as "not a big deal" because "the common flu kills way more people."
- SuperFerret 7y agoLike Fox News. And other conservative owned stations.
- jfk13 7y ago> The virus was being downplayed all of January and February by the media That's not been my impression at all. But then, I don't live in the US. Maybe it's an American media thing?
- chasd00 7y agoAmerica is so polarized politically it depends on which side you're on. If you're a fan of the current administration then they're doing their best and handling things in a realistic pragmatic fashion. If you're not, then the admin is doing everything wrong at every turn. Also, the media is everyone's bogey man because some media sides with the administration and some doesn't.
- seankimdesign 7y agoGenuine question: What do the alt-right have to gain by dismissing the potency of COVID? I know the South Korean government took that exact position because of their pro-China stance. They tried really hard to downplay the dangers of the virus simply because of its Wuhan origins. knowing that the Trump administration is on the other side of the fence regarding China, what do they have to gain by dismissing the situation?
- fzeroracer 7y agoThe point isn't that they have anything to gain. You're looking at it from the wrong angle. They genuinely believe that it's a non-issue. That it will go away and that it's simply a trivial virus that isn't worth worrying about.
- KarlKemp 7y agoThey get to excuse their government’s new Katrina. They also tend to be distrustful of science, and of our ability to change anything through centralized action.
- stronglikedan 7y agoWhat country are you in? Both the media and government in my country (US) have been sending the exact opposite message of "just the flu". As with anywhere, there are a few local outlets and politicians trying to downplay it, likely for economic reasons, but I haven't seen it downplayed on the Federal level at all. In fact, there's been an overabundance of information and caution.
- ddoolin 7y agoThe president himself severely downplayed it and gave the opposite advice as his own health officials (including [paraphrasing] "it's just the flu" and "go to work.")
- reaperducer 7y agoYou are correct. However, the point the previous commenter was making was that it wasn't being downplayed at the federal level. The president has been visibly out-of-step with the rest of the federal government messaging on this. One voice, no matter the position, doesn't evaporate what the hundreds of others have been saying.
- komali2 7y agoI disagree - the role of president in the USA is quickly marching towards "only voice of the government." This has been clear from many politicians acquiescing to the whims of that One Voice, sometimes to their own detriment, oftentimes to their benefit.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI really don’t understand why the guy can’t keep quiet and let people who obviously know more about the topic do their job. I don’t understand what he is trying to achieve constantly contradicting experts. He should support them.
- mikestew 7y ago
- oneplane 7y agoI suppose that depends on your local feeds; if you are in NA you probably have a hard time getting correct information/governance/leadership at this time. (hence your question) It used to be 'good enough' or even 'fine' over there, i.e. with HIV or malaria issues or even H1N1. But even with the research on pandemic readiness showing that neither capacity nor governance has been up to the task people are still pretending it's just a political choice and the results will be fine. If I remember correctly it as CSIS thing: https://healthsecurity.csis.org/final-report/ https://healthsecurity.csis.org/final-report/
- abstractbarista 7y agoFrom the death %, symptoms, and recovery stats, it really is mostly "just the flu". If you are otherwise healthy, this is like getting a cold with a fever for a week, then feeling better. Sure, call it a pandemic, because it is worldwide. But honestly it's just not that remarkable. This isn't some godly virus with 25% death rates!
- Waterluvian 7y agoWhere do you live that CV is 20-30x less deadly than elsewhere? From the numbers I'm seeing, it's not just the flu.
- abstractbarista 7y ago30x of 0.1% still ain't bad.
- TheCoelacanth 7y ago200 million people (probably more in reality because of how overwhelmed the healthcare system would be) dying isn't bad?
- abstractbarista 7y agoSeasonal flu kills 291k to 646k people each year...
- tigershark 7y agoThis will kill 2 orders of magnitude more. Sounds good to have 30-70 millions deaths?
- rsynnott 7y ago3% of people who catch a highly infectious disease dying of it is _ridiculously_ bad.
- 7y ago
- SkyPuncher 7y agoI was under the impression that the Pandemic label was a response to objective criteria, not subjective decision of leadership. In particular, one of those factors was sustained duration of the outbreak. My understanding is we finally crossed the time threshold for declaring this a Pandemic.
- reaperducer 7y agoI believe I read somewhere that it had to be declared an epidemic on two continents for it to be called a pandemic.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI've heard they were counting off countries with cases. My wife told me the other day that she read that "4 more countries with coronavirus and WHO will call it pandemic".
- tigershark 7y agoFor H1N1 as far as I remember the pandemic designation happened far earlier and that was a joke of virus compared to covid-19 comparing the mortality rates.
- sub7 7y agoAny successful containment measure will be later criticized as "too early" and/or "too aggressive". Much, much better than the alternative. H1N1 was serious and compared to this, well handled.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWas it? Maybe my perception is skewed from being in one of the earliest countries hit, but my memory of H1N1 is that we pretty much gave up everything but vaccine development once we realized it was uncontainable.
- StavrosK 7y ago
- willis936 7y agoBut months ago they really couldn’t have known. We still don’t know how many will be infected. All we can do is take precautionary measures. The WHO messaging should have been stronger and earlier, but it isn’t their fault for not labeling a pandemic months ago. Granted, there was enough data and research done to squarely label this as a pandemic, and that’s really where I assign blame on them. Here is a neat video that helps put things in perspective for most any viewer. https://youtu.be/Kas0tIxDvrg https://youtu.be/Kas0tIxDvrg
- pier25 7y ago> But months ago they really couldn’t have known It already looked pretty bad mid/late January when China started construction of hospitals. Were there any reasons to think it would no go global?
- fock 7y agoin Germany in January people talked about: - well, it's China, you know, they don't have nice hospitals there - the flu is killing people too and you're not vaccinated! - our democratic society will be much better at containing that, people are mord open - the methods in China are soooo stoneage, we are good at contact tracing. So: no, there was no objective reason to think it would not go global, but it was faaaar away...
- paulmd 7y ago"that's two-months-from-now-me's problem!"
- beaunative 7y agoTo be fair, China already delcared state of emergency months ago, but for the WHO to declare pandemic and recognize it as a international problem, it has to be that other countries has also done that. WHO cannot predict things, and they can't declare Pandemic when what they have is mere suspicion, it has to be an actual pandemic to declare. I'm pretty sure numerous experts have warned about the pandemic thing.
- reaperducer 7y agoFor the most part, the only place I've seen people saying "this is just the flu" is on the internet, and especially in tech-heavy circles. The only mass media where I've seen that was in a BBC television report from a soccer stadium, and that was only last night.
- sneak 7y agoThey also have to be careful about credibility. It wasn't clear how well the global containment efforts were going to work until very recently. Let's say a week or two ago there's a 33% probability of global pandemic: that means if they call it such then, 2 times out of 3 they're crying wolf and causing people to listen less carefully to the WHO. You already see people claiming all manner of conspiracy theory nonsense and not taking it as seriously as they should; they have to be careful not to amplify that, and balance that against acting too late when it's clear there is a high probability of global community spread. Other than their censorship in China (they give different advice on their website served to China, even on English-language pages, involving the effectiveness of traditional Chinese medicine against the virus), I think they're doing a mostly okay job so far, from what I can see in the current reporting.
- cm2187 7y agoWhat are you are dismissing as "conspiracy theory nonsense" includes calls to calm from infectious diseases experts and health authorities. When we will look back with hindsight, the conspirary theory nonsense may end up being the unecessary panicking, armchair epidemiologists, "the numbers are worse than we are told", etc.
- MiroF 7y agoI feel like containment had clearly failed by at least two weeks ago, we're just only now seeing policy catch up.
- raugustinus 7y ago"If the role of the WHO is to stave off pandemics and not just to monitor them". Not really no.
- yitianjian 7y agoI believe it was declared a PHEIC - Public Health Emergency of International Concern - and this should be the signal that governments need to take measures for containment to prevent it from spreading. I believe the pandemic label is when containment has failed and governments need to go into mitigation mode. Seeing as it had been relatively contained in China, South Korea, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, etc., it seemed reasonable that taking measures would be sufficient to prevent further escalation.
- hacym 7y agoI think it's easy to criticize their leadership from the outside, but I would assume that they make their decisions with great care, and aren't going to throw around "pandemic" or other words easily. If they do that, people stop listening. It's akin to people not caring about a major hurricane barreling towards them because they've heard the doomsday scenarios before and nothing has happened. They have to be careful, and that they were.
- rvz 7y agoThe delayed message of the WHO was really more like a very slow reaction at the cost of potentially millions infected with several thousands dead. By the time it spread to Europe and the US, it was essentially game over. Perhaps the 'doomsday clock' was right all along but didn't see this one coming.
- goodluckchuck 7y ago> Their wait and see approach will ultimately result in more human deaths and suffering. I'm not sure sure that's true. One way to "flatten the curve" is to make sure that some people catch it sooner rather than later, and thus you're able to provide care for them where you otherwise wouldn't be able. The more you're pushing people to "later" the more you're trying to push "containment" and if you already know "containment" isn't going to work, you're just risking that the spread gets out of control at some later time... when you're less prepared. Control means both preventing spread and causing spread.
- olalonde 7y agoAs a layperson, I'm not sure I agree with your layperson perception analysis. To me, calling it an epidemic meant that efforts should be focused on containment in order to slow it down or stop its progression. That signaled just how dangerous it was. Calling it a pandemic essentially means that we've given up on that and just like the common flu, most people will catch it. Basically, it's time to just "deal with" it instead of attempting to contain. I'd rather they had kept the epidemic label a bit longer.
- beaunative 7y agoDeclaring pandemic requires data which the WHO simply can't have if its member states do not submit or further, do not test for it. People like to think that international organizations like the UN, WTO, WHO is somewhat superior, or above the states, but they are not.
- wool_gather 7y agoIf it is a political and subjective decision as you say, then they have to balance the benefits of the declaration against the risk of the counter-narrative overwhelming it. Too early and even more people would dismiss the problem than are doing so now. And there's no "we said 'pandemic' before, well, it's 'really a pandemic' now" label that can be used. And leaving aside the immediate difficulties...let's save this kind of retrospective criticism for after, when we're closer to being out of the woods. If you have prospective criticism -- what should be done now and going forwards -- that would be worthwhile.
- tanilama 7y agoBut would political leaders actual take actions regardless of the pandemic categorization? I hope they do, but the reality starts to frighten me.
- pbourke 7y agoThe WHO's entire purpose is to act as health diplomats and coordinators. They have been ringing the alarm bell for weeks now, saying that countries need to take things seriously. Whether the WHO uses the term "pandemic" is honestly just semantics. You should direct the majority of your criticism at short-sighted governments who have prioritized the economy (or, even worse, markets) over health. It was incumbent on local authorities to take the WHO's message seriously, especially after their expedition to China released its report.
- andrewla 7y ago> By delaying the "pandemic" designation, the WHO has inadvertently cost more lives. ... why? I mean, it's not like the word of the WHO is a binding thing, where anyone is mandated to take action on any level because of a binary designation in a taxonomy. This whole this is just bureaucratic wheels turning; everyone who needs to take action has all the information they need to do so. This is just the WHO doing what it does best -- having committees meeting endlessly to decide whether to apply a certain meaningless designation and then announcing the conclusion of that exercise. Their actual job, of collating and disseminating information and trying to coordinate any large-scale responses, is actually hard, so nobody wants to do it, but having a meeting to decide IS IT A PANDEMIC is an easy bikeshedding meeting that all the MBAs and ex-McKinsey people can attend and offer their stupid opinion on what the definition of a word is. EDIT: I said "everyone who needs to take action has all the information they need to do so", and that could be interpreted as saying that we know enough to determine what actions to take. But what I mean is that we have enough data to start to make a range of predictions and bound the uncertainty to some degree; having a more precise metric for any aspect of COVID-19 should not affect the response since those metrics are essentially made up and not comparable even on a per-hospital level, much less a per-country level or even a per-test-kit-type level. Uncertainty is part of the game here, and understanding the risk profiles is how people and organizations and governments have to tune their response.
- afthonos 7y agoThey were asked about this in their briefing a few days ago and made a multi-point response: 1) There are no objective criteria for calling something a pandemic. 2) They did not feel they knew enough about the propagation pattern to make the subjective call. 3) They were deeply worried that calling it a pandemic would switch government strategies from containment to mitigation, resulting in higher contagion and loss of life. They especially emphasized the last point. The only question in my mind is whether (1) they decided containment was no longer viable or (2) they decided not calling it pandemic would be seen as unserious, even if containment could still potentially have benefits. Source: https://youtu.be/OJQTM4QbTsg https://youtu.be/OJQTM4QbTsg
- wcoenen 7y agoThe WHO defines a pandemic as the worldwide spread of a disease[1]. So the disease only becomes a pandemic after it has spread everywhere; it wouldn't make sense to call a disease a pandemic before it becomes one. [1]https://www.who.int/csr/disease/swineflu/frequently_asked_questions/pandemic/en/ https://www.who.int/csr/disease/swineflu/frequently_asked_qu...