2 ms·
Since when is free software about the freedoms of the owner of the software? You're trying to gaslight a new definition of free software that is going against t
by imtringued 7y ago
Since when is free software about the freedoms of the owner of the software? You're trying to gaslight a new definition of free software that is going against the user of your software.
When you look at the four software freedoms you will notice that not even once is the author of the software mentioned. Your definition of free software is 100% incompatible with the four software freedoms.
>A program is “free software” if the program’s users have the four essential freedoms:
>The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose.
>The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish. Access to the source code is a precondition for this.
>The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor.
>The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others. By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes. Access to the source code is a precondition for this.
By running a modified GPL project on a web server without allowing access to the source code to users you are violating all 4 software freedoms at once. Users can't run the same software as you do. Users can't change the program because they have no access to the source code. They can't redistribute modified or unmodified copies.
>My freedoms to keep my own code to myself should not change based upon whether or not I am running a web server process on my machine or not.
The user's freedom should not change based upon whether or not the free software is running a web server process on a machine or not. This is the exact opposite of your argument and it is in line with the four software freedoms. Therefore your argument has nothing to do with free software.
- kazinator 7y ago> By running a modified GPL project on a web server without allowing access to the source code to users you are violating all 4 software freedoms at once. That is nonsense. Firstly, you can't violate freedoms, only exercise them or not. You're just running the program as you wish, for any purpose, exercising the first freedom. Since you modified it, you obviously had freedom to study how it works and change it how you wish. You haven't exercised your freedom to redistribute the program. > The user's freedom should not change based upon whether or not the free software is running a web server process on a machine or not. Yes, it should; the server is my private property. It is a social problem that people are allowing themselves to become locked to SaaS programs, and those programs are blackboxes whose behavior changes on a whim, and can be nefarious. That problem can't be solved by turning free software licenses into screwed-up non-free licenses. Even if you have the exact source code of some SaaS, that still doesn't help you because you don't control the installation. Users who are stuck with some system that they are pressured by others into using cannot just walk away from it just because they don't like what some piece of code is doing (in plain view, thanks to AGPL compliance).
- tzs 7y agoIf your understanding of the four essential freedoms and whom they apply to were correct, then someone using a kiosk that runs GPL software would be entitled to a copy of the source code. This is covered in the GNU licenses FAQ [1]: > Does GPLv3 require that voters be able to modify the software running in a voting machine? > No. Companies distributing devices that include software under GPLv3 are at most required to provide the source and Installation Information for the software to people who possess a copy of the object code. The voter who uses a voting machine (like any other kiosk) doesn't get possession of it, not even temporarily, so the voter also does not get possession of the binary software in it. [1] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html