5 ms·
> There really is a sweet spot in most people's disposable income and on-road costs and range anxiety (also a highly irrational place btw) which is just around
by pengaru 7y ago
> There really is a sweet spot in most people's disposable income and on-road costs and range anxiety (also a highly irrational place btw) which is just around the corner
I often jump at the opportunity to talk EVs with common folks who aren't car enthusiasts but do own/operate automobiles.
What I've come to appreciate is that range anxiety isn't even the primary anxiety anymore. There's enough EVs out in the wild and just general evidence of their being usable as daily drivers that it seems to be a thing of the past.
What does seem to be a major source of anxiety is battery lifetime and serviceability/cost.
And I think that's a perfectly rational thing. Consider what most people experience with laptops and smartphones when it comes to modern rechargeable battery technology. They swell up, they catch fire, they lose capacity, they're not even standardized on EVs so you're locked into a specific vendor, it might not even be made by the OEM anymore so you're stuck with shoddy reverse-engineered replacements (classic thinkpad owners know this experience all to well). With volatile companies like Tesla you can't even be confident they'll still be around to service the electrics/battery in 5-10 years.
What I wish companies like Tesla would do is define some standard form factors for things like batteries, motors, motor controllers, and charge systems. If they'd just get things to where EVs are very much like oversized electric RC vehicles, where we can buy the vehicles potentially without any battery at all with a competitive market of battery vendors to choose from fulfilling requirements of an open standard, a lot of these sources of anxiety completely vanish.
Imagine a world where you could have a Tesla delivered to your local mechanic without a motor, motor controller, or battery. It's a roller conforming to a set of standards for those components. Then you buy those to your liking from whatever vendors you prefer in the size/capacities/costs you prefer.
I'm pretty confident such a situation would have EV adoption explode everywhere, nobody would be worried about having an unmaintainable rube goldberg machine of proprietary electronics collecting dust on their driveway in 10 years.
- sk0g 7y agoMaybe standards would be good too for degradation. Might make the batteries more expensive as they would be a guarantee of sorts. So say silver tier - 70% max range after 7 years. gold tier - 80% max range after 7 years, etc.
- nradov 7y agoThe battery pack kind of has to be an integral part of the structure of modern passenger EVs. So I doubt we will see a standard form factor anytime soon. Leasing is probably a better approach for customers concerned over battery life.
- clouddrover 7y ago> What I wish companies like Tesla would do is define some standard form factors for things like batteries The Fiat Centoventi (aka the electric Panda) is closest to what you want for batteries. It has a battery system with modules which are easy to install and remove. The idea is you can buy the battery capacity that suits your needs and then you can buy or rent extra capacity as needed: https://www.drivingelectric.com/fiat/933/fiat-centoventi-concept-previews-future-electric-panda https://www.drivingelectric.com/fiat/933/fiat-centoventi-con... Being able to rent some extra battery capacity for the occasional road trip is an interesting idea. And the modular system makes it easy to replace modules that fail over time.
- londons_explore 7y agoPutting together modules that are different ages or levels of charge presents some pretty large technical difficulties. It makes your motor controllers, safety systems, and chargers significantly more complex and more expensive.
- Retric 7y agoWith increasing range battery replacement is no longer a significant issue. Averaging about 250 mile range and 800 charge cycles you get 200,000 miles. That range may go up or down a little, but cars are with such a small fraction of their initial value at 150+k makes that it makes little difference for a new car buyer. A much larger issue is the loss of range as a car ages. Used cars are more noticeably degraded which is going to seriously impact the used car market over time. That may eventually be a non issue if range keeps increasing, but it’s a real consideration.
- ericd 7y agoThis kind of degradation impacts cars with bad battery thermal management systems (the early Leaf) much much more than cars with good liquid cooling systems (Tesla, others). I think Tesla’s degradation curve is supposed to keep it usable well past 250k. They’re targeting 1MM miles, not sure if they’ve demonstrated that they’ve hit it.
- tdhz77 7y ago1M with new battery technology currently in S3XY’s.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoOn the flip side, in the used Tesla market over here it's surprisingly common to see "battery replaced last year under warranty" on cars that have done ~80k miles.
- ggm 7y agoWhy didn't we design to standard format swappable battery? if nothing else, it would have made for faster "charging".
- jsight 7y agoI just wish they'd offer a decent battery warranty. The current battery warranties are very weak, especially on the Tesla.
- jansan 7y agoBetter Place tried and failed big time, after spending next to a billion dollars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Better_Place_(company)
- m463 7y ago> What does seem to be a major source of anxiety is battery lifetime and serviceability/cost. Battery lifetime is way more of a concern for cars with small batteries. For an original leaf with a 20kwh battery pack, you have to charge it to higher levels and discharge to lower levels just to get your daily range. For a tesla model 3 you can charge for battery health and still have convenience and longevity. Basically, to predict car lifetime calculate battery cycles * range for one cycle. If a battery will survive 2000 cycles, a leaf @ 50 miles range will get 100k miles, a tesla model 3 @250 miles range will get 500k. And service seems to be working out to significantly less than gasoline cars. I do dislike that teslas are not "open" cars, tesla carefully hoarding service procedures unless the law requires it.
- solatic 7y agoIt's really ironic that you bring this up because Better Place burned through $850 million in capital building out the infrastructure and intellectual property for hot-swappable batteries before they gave up the ghost. Their model was based on car owners not owning the batteries, instead paying Better Place per distance driven, and in return getting free battery swaps at special stations that would swap out depleted batteries for fresh ones in two minutes, plus "free" charging at branded charging points that were built into parking spaces. Under such a model, Better Place was on the hook for battery health - not the car owner. They failed because Renault didn't deliver in the quantities needed and they tried to make up the cash shortfall by over-pricing the distance fees (more expensive than gasoline costs unless you regularly drove huge distances). Too many ducks needed to line up and investors stopped ponying up. It's fair to say that they were before their time - they probably could have gotten SoftBank to throw them another ten figures, but the Vision Fund didn't exist back then. Tesla looked at battery swapping after Better Place proved feasibility and passed, probably due to the cost of retrofitting to the existing design and various engineering compromises (specifically related to speed and acceleration, which Musk prizes) that would be needed.
- jsight 7y ago> Tesla looked at battery swapping after Better Place proved feasibility and passed, probably due to the cost of retrofitting to the existing design and various engineering compromises (specifically related to speed and acceleration, which Musk prizes) that would be needed. The Model S demonstrated battery swapping technology. There was no retrofitting to the design needed, as it was designed to support it from the beginning.