5 ms·
The "toxic loonytoon" part, referencing a prominent candidate to the OSI board? I mean, surely we can all have our own opinions about any candidate, but the opt
by zozbot234 7y ago
The "toxic loonytoon" part, referencing a prominent candidate to the OSI board? I mean, surely we can all have our own opinions about any candidate, but the optics aren't that good.
- monksy 7y agoYes, he has his own opinion. What is wrong with that? IMO: His opinion has a lot of weight here. He founded the project. Without his philosphy in the start you wouldn't be where it is today.
- joe_the_user 7y agoI'm pretty the point is that OSI already laid down guidelines that asked for civil communication - and name calling is epitome of uncivil communication. Indeed, his comment is basically contesting those guidelines. So this was clearly one of those no recovery situations. Either guidelines for civil behavior or "show me the code" meritocracy wins but it's hard to see "agreeing to disagree" being possible here.
- monksy 7y agoBeing a prior mod of a city sub.. "toxic loonytoon" is a rather light thing to be called. My concern is if you're drawing the line over this what you're communicating to people is that you cannot negatively sum up another individual, even when it's warranted. A productive conversation can be had on the merits of the label. Are you trying to incentivize long posts about all of the non-sensical policies that the individual is pushing?
- joe_the_user 7y agoAvoiding name calling a standard guideline for civil communication. Maybe there's some moderation standard where just really bad name calling or something is the only no-no that's avoided but that's really the question here. The point is it's pretty plausible the ESR was breaking guidelines that had been laid down already. Maybe he should have broken them for all I know but all I'm saying really is that for an authority to remain credible they have to enforce guidelines specifically when someone is openly defying them. That's it.
- kazinator 7y agoThat sort of language is normal in the parliament houses of the developed world, upon which our constitutional democracies are based. If there is some sort of evidence that the candidate in question is in fact a toxic loonytoon, by some sort of objective standard, then it's perfectly fine to use that language. At some point, you have to call a spade a spade, and a toxic loonytoon a toxic loonytoon.
- iron0013 7y agoWell okay, if you insist: Eric S. Raymond is a toxic loonytoon. And there’s plenty of evidence to support that assertion.
- kazinator 7y agoBy the "takes one to know one" principle, we should pay attention to Raymond when the calls out another toxic loonytoon.
- iron0013 7y agoExcept it obviously doesn’t take one to know one. Are we having an actual conversation or just lobbing empty rhetoric
- a1369209993 7y agoI disagree vehemently with this moronic opinion, but am strongly opposed to any attempts to ban you for holding or expressing it.
- duskwuff 7y agoCalling a person a "toxic loonytoon" for the offense of trying to establish standards of acceptable behavior is ridiculous by any sort of "objective standard". If anything, it demonstrates the importance of having those standards, by serving as an example of the sort of behavior that such a standard should condemn.
- 7y ago
- downerending 7y agoI think it's a reference to one of the people pushing very hard on spreading CoCs everywhere. Can't recall the name. (Corin?) Reading some of that person's tweets, though, left me with a very bad impression. Anyway, search and form your own opinion.
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoAny idea who that may be?
- larrywright 7y agoI’m not going to post it here, but if you email me I will share it. My email is my HN username at gmail.
- cgh 7y agohttps://wiki.opensource.org/bin/Main/OSI+Board+of+Directors/Board+Member+Elections/2020+Individual+and+Affiliate+Elections/ https://wiki.opensource.org/bin/Main/OSI+Board+of+Directors/... He is referring to one of the people running for the board of directors whose major goal is to introduce Codes of Conduct into open source projects.
- josteink 7y agoSo someone who wants to destroy open source then, at the core of its foundations. I can’t wait until this identity politics pendulum starts swinging back. Some people are going to be really embarrassed about the legacy they left for themselves while it was still around.
- jshevek 7y agoI glanced at the OSI page. I found someone who overtly stated opposition to core FLOSS principals: >"Giving everyone freedom means giving evil people freedom, too." (OSD FAQ) It doesn't have to be like this. It's time to stop bad actors from using our work in unethical ways. It's time to give open source developers around the world the tools they need to exercise their ethical responsibilities as engineers and members of human society. It's time for us to stop shirking our ethical obligations, and take responsibility for the use of our work. From: https://wiki.opensource.org/bin/Main/OSI+Board+of+Directors/Board+Member+Elections/2020+Individual+and+Affiliate+Elections/Ehmke2020 https://wiki.opensource.org/bin/Main/OSI+Board+of+Directors/... Also: https://mobile.twitter.com/CoralineAda/status/1229456857317683201 https://mobile.twitter.com/CoralineAda/status/12294568573176... (Edited to include her position in her own words)