4 ms·
It is a literally true statement. Universal means covering everybody. That some slices of the population have it in no way contradicts that. Indeed, most of you
by wpietri 7y ago
It is a literally true statement. Universal means covering everybody. That some slices of the population have it in no way contradicts that. Indeed, most of your numbers prove that sick leave in the US is not universal.
- ortusdux 7y agoOddly, in this instance, "Zero" seems like the wrong description for something that is binary.
- khawkins 7y agoIt's not "oddly", it's deliberately deceptive and trying to exaggerate the problem to advance a political narrative.
- wpietri 7y agoI read it as relating to the quantity of leave. E.g., a country could have "7 days per year of universal guaranteed paid sick leave".
- amalcon 7y agoBeing charitable, it's not actually binary, because sick leave has both a quantity axis and an accessibility access. The "universal" qualifier makes the accessibility axis binary. There's still a big difference between universal 1-day-per-year paid sick leave and universal 30-day-per-year paid sick leave or what have you.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>Universal means covering everybody. Wouldn't this mean it is an impossible goal since unemployed people don't have it. This might sound a bit snarky, but I am being serious because unemployed does account for people who are working under the radar, often through illegal means. An illegal sex worker, panhandler, or someone doing odd jobs and taking straight cash payments are likely not covered even in places that would be said to have universal paid sick leave.
- wpietri 7y agoDefinitely not impossible. Plenty of countries give money to unemployed people: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment_benefits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment_benefits
- SkyBelow 7y agoBut that doesn't covered the sick leave portion of the claim, and in general unemployment benefits do not cover everyone who is unemployed (such as children, which is another group who may be working under the radar). It would effectively require a UBI, and even then it wouldn't qualify as being sick leave. This is the problem with reducing it to a fully binary clarification where everything but fully true is false. 99.999% is so much easier to hit than 100%.
- wpietri 7y agoI'm afraid I don't understand what "sick leave" for children or people already receiving benefits would mean. Are you trying to make an actual point about real-world responses to pandemics? Or is this just some sort of language-is-imperfect cul-de-sac you're in? If the latter, please leave me out of it.
- SkyBelow 7y agoChildren work. Be it mowing a yard, working on a farm, or illegally violating labor laws and having an actual job. In some places, even in first world countries, there are children who are working under the radar (children of undocumented immigrants or children who are undocumented immigrants being an example). These children do not get paid sick leave, and thus if the standard for 'universal paid sick leave' is 'everyone gets it', then nowhere meets that standard. If you make your definition require perfection to meet it, then it won't be met. You set the standard on being literally universal a few comments ago, and I'm just showing that nowhere meets that standard. > Or is this just some sort of language-is-imperfect cul-de-sac you're in? Come now, have you forgotten when you said the following? >It is a literally true statement. Universal means covering everybody. That some slices of the population have it in no way contradicts that. Please do not suggest me being in some language-is-imperfect cul-de-sac when you were the one driving.