9 ms·
The Facebook container is great, but I wish there was an option for the built-in Multi-Account containers to work this way. I've been doing what the Facebook Co
by stavros 7y ago
The Facebook container is great, but I wish there was an option for the built-in Multi-Account containers to work this way. I've been doing what the Facebook Container extension does, but with built-in containers, and the experience is very clunky.
The two biggest issues are that I can't give the container a list of domains beforehand and say "everything under google.com should open here". I have to go to each Google subdomain and set it to "always open in this container" with three or four clicks. The other major issue is that there's no way to have links outside those domains open outside the container, so whenever I click a link on Gmail that goes to Github, Github opens in the Google container and I always have to copy/paste the address to a new tab.
Fixing those two annoyances would make the built-in containers feature amazing. Maybe I should file a feature request.
EDIT: I have filed a feature request: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1621276 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1621276
- IanSanders 7y agoI wish every domain could automatically be opened in an individual container. I don't even need to know about them.
- matsemann 7y agoThat would break a lot of stuff, though. And then I don't just mean "bad" tracking, but normal auth flows etc
- katet 7y agoYou're quite right - I have some trouble with "modal" popup windows and the Atlassian Single Sign On in particular with the temporary extensions tab. But I eventually figured out to copy and paste those URLs and manually whitelist them to a specific container tab I wouldn't recommend it for family or friends, but I'm happy with the trade off
- pyr0hu 7y agoThere is a temp container extension that does exactly this.
- katet 7y agoAsk and ye shall receive: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-containers https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-con... I use this in combination with "normal" containers and it works a treat
- SAI_Peregrinus 7y agoSame. The mix is IMO the best way to get privacy while keeping usability. It obsoletes things like cookie auto-delete. There is some annoying UI lag when opening a new tab though, as it takes a fraction of a second to swap from default to a new temporary container.
- xenophonf 7y agoI use this plus Containerise, but with recent updates to Temporary Containers, I don't think I need Containerise any more.
- Yhippa 7y agoJust curious: is there significant overhead to running each domain in it's own container?
- markosaric 7y agoThere's also the privacy.firstparty.isolate in about:config which isolates each site.
- 0-_-0 7y agoThat's an existing Firefox feature called First Party Isolation. Here's a plugin that toggles it: https://github.com/mozfreddyb/webext-firstpartyisolation https://github.com/mozfreddyb/webext-firstpartyisolation It sometimes (rarely) breaks payment processors but otherwise works fine
- stinos 7y agoApart from those 2 issues, a smaller annoyance but I really wish 'Reopen in Container' would just reuse the tab. At least I've personally not once felt the need to keep the original tab open.
- sirmoveon 7y agoDo you know of Firefox Multi-Account Containers?
- StavrosK 7y agoYes, those are the ones I'm talking about.
- sirmoveon 7y agoYou are right the user experience is chunky and not self explanatory. But what you are trying to achieve is possible. Play with the settings a bit. I have it in a way that if I type a domain that is assigned to a container, it will ask me first if I want to open it in its default container or a different one.
- Tomte 7y agoThat's not what he (and I and many others) are asking for. The site linked to is not assigned to any container. It opens in the old container, while it should open in the default container.
- sirmoveon 7y agoI'm just trying to help. The idea of having a link clicked inside a container and expect it to go to a different container as a default setting, seems to contradict web standars. Now, if you've explicitly assigned the clicked domain to a different container, then yes, it should go to its container (which is how it works, to me at least).
- StavrosK 7y ago> seems to contradict web standars But if I click a Google link, it already goes to a different container (the Google one), because I've told it to. > Now, if you've explicitly assigned the clicked domain to a different container, then yes, it should go to its container I am trying to assign "all non-google.com links" to open in the default container.
- addandsubtract 7y ago> whenever I click a link on Gmail that goes to Github, Github opens in the Google container and I always have to copy/paste the address to a new tab. You can right-click links and open them in a "New Container Tab" (including "No Container"). Edit: You can also right-click on the tabs and select "Reopen in Container"
- StavrosK 7y agoSure, but it's not as convenient as doing it automatically.
- wexxy 7y agoI feel like that's probably by design. If you were in a session and clicking links, the assumption is if you're in the container already, you'd want to remain in the container. I don't disagree it would be nice for you to be able to specify domains per containers, but yeah, maybe that'll come in the future..
- StavrosK 7y agoIt's definitely by design, since the containers are meant to segregate accounts (e.g. a company container and a personal container), but a second mode would be useful since many people are using them for per-site isolation.
- dmit 7y agoIf you specify a catch-all url to open in No Container, would that work? !*.google.com , Google !* , No Container
- StavrosK 7y agoOh wow, that did work, thanks! It's odd, because the extension reordered the catch-all URL to the top, so I'm not sure how the specificity goes.
- skrowl 7y agoWith the base multi account container extension https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account-containers https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account... you can right click in any page and have it remember the container for that domain. For example you open abc.com in container "Personal" once, then you can tell it do remember to use that container whenever you go to abc.com. The Conex extension https://github.com/kesselborn/conex https://github.com/kesselborn/conex goes beyond by (optionally) prompting you for which container you want. The best part of this extension is that it lets you hide tabs that aren't in the same container, effectively giving you tab groups based on container. Once you get used to it, you won't want to go back to having 80 tabs displayed at once. In addition
- StavrosK 7y ago> you can tell it do remember to use that container whenever you go to abc.com My problem with that is that, even if I do this, it doesn't remember it for foo.abc.com, and when I'm in the container, links to def.com won't open outside the container.
- untog 7y agoI use Containise for that, it lets you set wildcards: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containerise/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containerise/
- StavrosK 7y agoUnfortunately that doesn't open other links outside the container :/
- sjagoe 7y agoTemporary containers will do that https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-containers https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-con... All urls that are not "pinned" to a container open in a temporary container.
- comboy 7y agoI use FF, I don't use FB, but I still think this is wrong. Browser is not a place to decide which companies are good and which are bad. As much as I despise Facebook I still don't think it's fair. "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it". All companies should have the same access to the technology in user's browser. Favoring Google by Chrome seems no different than blocking Facebook by Firefox. It's the same behavior, just a difference in opinions. edit: to clarify, I am in agreement with the parent comment, the above is just about Facebook container being a feature
- onyva 7y agoEven it were true, which is not, Facebook had been anything but fair to its users (and non users) in case you didn’t get a chance to follow the news. Since Mozilla is all about user’s privacy and safety online and Facebook is such a huge menace than it actually makes sense to offer a targeted solution. But again, it’s just an implementation of a container, nothing specific to Facebook.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoHow is this tantamount to deciding which companies are good and bad? Mozilla have simply identified an extremely common way people are tracked online and are doing their best to contain it.
- comboy 7y agoSame rules should apply to everybody. You should be able to decide some rules, even heuristics that can catch tracking across multiple sites and suggest user to disable it rather than pointing to entity and applying different rules to it than to everybody else.
- majewsky 7y agoYou can set up containers for every domain you like. Facebook just comes as a predefined option because 90% of users are going to choose that domain anyway.
- 7y ago
- cptskippy 7y ago> whenever I click a link on Gmail that goes to Github, Github opens in the Google container Google intercepts clicks and redirects them through a Google Domain to track clickthru. If you're in Gmail and hover over a link it will show the actual destination but onclick your browser opens a mail.google.com URL that redirects to the destination URL.
- TheKnack 7y agoThis extension removes the URL intercept/redirect on Gmail and many other sites: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/skip-redirect/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/skip-redirect... This one handles the other situation, tracking parameters added to the URL that are intentionally passed to the target site: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/neat-url/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/neat-url/
- mark_l_watson 7y agoThanks for the link. I just spent a few minutes looking at this extention’s creator’s github activity. Installing this will be my first todo list activity whenever I first use my laptop today. That redirect always bugged me. EDIT: I just noticed on the install page "This is not a Recommended Extension. Make sure you trust it before installing.Learn more" which is annoying.
- j1elo 7y agoClearURLs by Kevin R. is recommended by Mozilla, so maybe that's a better option: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/clearurls/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/clearurls/
- StavrosK 7y agoIt doesn't matter though, the tracking domain would run in the container and github outside it.
- 7y ago
- cypressious 7y ago> The other major issue is that there's no way to have links outside those domains open outside the container, so whenever I click a link on Gmail that goes to Github, Github opens in the Google container and I always have to copy/paste the address to a new tab. I had the same problem so I made a small extension that does that: https://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/container-outgoing-links/ https://addons.mozilla.org/de/firefox/addon/container-outgoi...
- kiwidrew 7y agoI also wish that the basic container feature worked like this. In the meantime, I am very happy with the unofficial "Google Container" addon [1], which is just a copy of the Facebook container that works its magic on Google domains instead. Give it a try. It doesn't interfere with the official Facebook container addon. [1] https://github.com/containers-everywhere/contain-google https://github.com/containers-everywhere/contain-google
- StavrosK 7y agoThat's great, thank you!
- Fnoord 7y agoTo complete GAFAN/GAFAM or whatever it is called there's also one for Amazon [1] and Microsoft [2] (I wouldn't care to avoid tracking by Apple or Netflix). [1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/contain-amazon https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/contain-amazo... [2] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/microsoft-container https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/microsoft-con...
- blahyawnblah 7y agoWhy is it OK to be track by Apple or Netflix?
- Fnoord 7y ago> Why is it OK to be track by Apple or Netflix? That is not what I asserted. I asserted I don't care about it. I don't believe Netflix tracks me outside of .netflix.com and I don't believe Apple tracks me outside of .apple.com (and the other domains ofc). If they do, you have to convince me it is harming my interests (ie. my privacy or freedom of choice). I know Google tracks me, I know Facebook tracks me. Their profit model is surrounded by this tracking. I know Amazon and Microsoft track me. Their profit model partly relies on tracking.
- 7y ago
- sylens 7y agoDo containers sync across devices yet? Having to re-establish all of my container rules on my work and personal computers is tedious
- StavrosK 7y agoI just opened mine and got a notification that they can now sync, so it appears that they added it recently.
- mozillamaxx 7y agoYes — We added it last month! (Mozilla Containers dev here.) See this blog post for more info: https://blog.mozilla.org/security/2020/02/06/multi-account-containers-sync/ https://blog.mozilla.org/security/2020/02/06/multi-account-c...
- 725686 7y agoSorry to bomb you like this, but I don't have the time/energy to find where to file a ff container bug: twitter.com never opens in it's designated container for me. That is the only site I always have to "Reopen in container".
- extra88 7y agoWorks for me, maybe the issue is specific to the site linking to Twitter.
- girzel 7y agoSame here: that's the only site that doesn't work. I wonder if it has something to do with the post-login redirects: it's impossible to say "always open this site in this container", because you've already been redirected to a different url.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI guess following a link that goes to a different container will break session cookies, and such, which for some/most is going to be annoying.
- groovecoder 7y agoNote: we have an update coming that includes a "Limit to Designated Sites" feature in the base Multi-Account Containers extension: https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/pull/1654 https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/pull/165...
- darkwater 7y agoI also miss the option to choose in which container open a new tab by default. I try to not use at all "container-less tabs" and it breaks keyboard-only usage.
- input_sh 7y agoCouldn't agree more. Open default links in separate container + delete all data from this container would make the desktop experience like Focus on mobile.
- itwy 7y agoWhy you keep saying "built-in containers", it's not built-in, it's an add-on.
- sfink 7y agoThe core functionality is and must be built in. You can't do very much with it in that state, so Multi-Account Containers is an user interface to configure and access most of the user-facing functionality. Some of that can be enabled just by toggling a couple of about:config settings, though. And as far as I know, though, it doesn't have privileged access to container APIs, so you could replace it with other addons. So whether it's more correct to be referring to the built-in functionality (including some of the UI elements), or the add-on, depends on exactly what you're talking about. And it's hard to distinguish.
- itwy 7y agoI see, thanks for the clarification. I wonder why Mozilla didn't just ship the add-on. It seems far-fetched to think it was to make the add-on replaceable by another.
- SwiftyBug 7y agoDo you know if there is any way one can configure a container to disable specific extensions?
- atombender 7y agoPersonally, I don't want to micromanage "containers" as a user. I truly don't understand why this is considered a nice feature. Who wants to micromanage anything? What I want is for every web page to run in its own container by default. Zero configuration. If it wants to access anything outside of its allowed domain hiearchy (like call an external API), I'd like the browser to ask for permission on its behalf. "Github.com would like to share data with Microsoft.com. Allow/Deny?" There could be some kind of trust standard so that Github.com can prove that they are the same legal entity as Microsoft.com and is therefore authorized to share information without asking. Or perhaps something simpler that is DNS-based, like with email.
- sadfklsjlkjwt 7y agoTry umatrix you could use it a little like this. Sadly most sites use a lot of third party javascript, css etc so it will be a clunkier experience than you are hoping for.
- atombender 7y agoThat just sounds like more micromanagement to me?
- dorgo 7y agoWhat is the difference to answering 10 to 20 "Allow/Deny?" question on each website? The website just won't work until you figure out which 3 of the 15 requests are needed to render the website properly. Most of these domains aren't "microsoft.com" but something like "gibberish123.net". Good luck guessing whether the request is legitime/usefull. edit: sounds like another addon idea: find the minimal set of 3rd parties needed to render a website.
- atombender 7y agoYou can eliminate most of those things based on general blacklisting rules for ads and beacons of the kind that adblockers currently rely on.