3 ms·
This article would be way better without blurry references to contemporary politics, even if you would immediately think it on-topic. I think Arendt is wrong o
by raxxorrax 7y ago
This article would be way better without blurry references to contemporary politics, even if you would immediately think it on-topic.
I think Arendt is wrong on some things, but it really doesn't hurt to read about her views. Idealism for example is something she thought being a root for nationalism and that it would impose an ideal that is striving towards what nature dictates. But I don't think that is how idealism is understood today, something that doesn't need an attachment to anything and can be freely defined. I would think Romanticism as a form of it, which doesn't have that connection "to nature" at all.
The article is a bit strange though, for example:
Precursors to Nazism and Stalinism, however, were the late nineteenth-century movements of pan-Germanism and pan-Slavism, which explicitly called themselves “movements” in order to signal their distrust of political parties and national parliaments.
I heavily doubt she would have said or thought anything like this. It is not clear if this are the authors thoughts or maybe some other statements.
The distrust can come from the already mentioned and real corruption, not because of any form of governance. Totalitarian movements have in common that they need their followers to believe that injustice was or is done to them. That allows to restrict the consciences of people and allows for the grab of power. Embarrassing, but I think the mechanism is quite trivial.
Totalitarianism needs the antagonist to breath. Be that Jews or yes, capitalists. That is also why you do not feed trolls.