3 ms·
I had a trip booked to Italy starting on March 20 so have been following the news very closely since at least mid February... I Ask HN'd how people were trackin
by airstrike 7y ago
I had a trip booked to Italy starting on March 20 so have been following the news very closely since at least mid February... I Ask HN'd how people were tracking the virus, and the answers I got were "I'm not tracking it in any way, shape or form and I hope it reciprocates the courtesy."
Quite funny, but the stats don't lie[0]. The number of new cases in Italy has grown at an exponential rate. This is a developed economy. Similar rates are being seen in France, the UK and Switzerland. The same will happen in the US. We're all going to get this, and most of us will be fine, but if you take the midpoint of experts' forecast of 40-80% of people being infected and multiply that for a conservative 1% death rate (the WHO has mentioned 3.4% and 2% is also often thrown around), that yields
7.8 billion * 0.6 * 0.01 = 46.8 million dead
At an 80% infection rate and an 3.4% mortality rate (worst case scenario), you get 212.2 million dead.
That's a once-in-a-century, catastrophic black swan event.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_outbreak_in_Italy#Statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_outbreak_in_I... – see the chart below the table for the unbelievable exponential rate
- cm2187 7y agoThe range of mortality I see is rather 0.3-1% [1] [2] [1] https://twitter.com/EricTopol/status/1236321986122375168 https://twitter.com/EricTopol/status/1236321986122375168 [2] https://twitter.com/NBCNews/status/1235956761015783427 https://twitter.com/NBCNews/status/1235956761015783427 Not a doctor, but I suspect 3.4% is the upper end of the case fatality ratio (i.e. death among people tested positive) as opposed to the infection fatility ratio (i.e. death among estimate of people infected).
- int_19h 7y agoThe range varies a lot depending on the quality of the treatment. The early initial estimates were based on data from Wuhan, where hospitals were overwhelmed early. The later, lower numbers were from areas where all new cases had hospital beds and ICUs available if they needed them. Problem is, given the current numbers, the projected total number of people who will require hospitalization, and of those that will require ICU, significantly exceed availability. So if it spreads too fast, and all these people get sick at the same time, we won't have enough beds to go around - and that will cause the mortality rate to spike again.
- giovannibajo1 7y agoMortality rates are low because hospitals are working. Intensive care beds in Italy are projected to be full in less than 10 days. You’ll see the rate grow by then.
- toyg 7y agoAreas that were locked down exactly 15 days ago, now seem to have seen a significant decrease in infection rates in the last few days. So there is hope that the system will fire on all cylinders and hold the line just long enough to weather the storm. Also, Southern Italy is significantly drier and warmer than Northern Italy, which might (might) help. One of the issues working against this scenario is the fact that the worst-affected regions are also the ones with the best health services. The other regions might struggle to respond as efficiently as the "pioneers", although they will benefit from the accumulated experience.
- igravious 7y agoPeople keep extrapolating that tens of millions will die, and I don't doubt that tens of millions surely would _if_ there were no lock-downs! (The subject of this article!) The whole point of locking down Wuhan/Hubei and then northern Italy and now the whole country and other places and cancelling large public gatherings and events is that local, regional, and national authorities start seeing the numbers soaring and initiate extreme mitigation strategies. We don't know how successful these strategies will be individually/collectively in the long run but if China is anything to go by it can severely retard the spread of the virus. To show I'm not spouting out of my derriere compare the logarithmic infection and death rates of China[1] and Italy[2] So you have to modify your formula: `7.8 billion * 0.6 * 0.03 * mitigation_factor = ?` We just don't know what the mitigation_factor is yet and because the spread is exponential any dent in the rate of spread brings the fatality number tumbling down[3]. I happen to believe this virus is a very serious global threat and I assure you that I am not one given to alarmism. But I also have never seen governments respond to the onset of an epidemic like this before and I'm nearly fifty and my mother says she can't remember anything like this in her lifetime. So yes, tens of millions absolutely could die but I'm willing to bet that between lock-downs and modern medicine tens of millions won't and I pray to, you know, $deity I am not wrong. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/china/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/china/ [2] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/ [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kas0tIxDvrg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kas0tIxDvrg [Exponential growth and epidemics]
- senordevnyc 7y agoThis is impossible to contain. The purpose of the lockdown isn't to contain, it's just to spread out the infections over a larger period of time so that hospitals don't get overwhelmed. But there's likely not a plausible scenario at this point where we globally jump on this and only a few million or even tens of millions are infected. All we can do is slow it down.
- igravious 7y agoChina has demonstrated that it is in fact possible to contain the spread. Please use the links I provided to review the data. Do remember that the Chinese built two make-shift hospitals in something like 10 days. Once a couple of weeks pass we'll see if Italy is able to replicate what China did. Here are my calculations based on current data[1]: Country tot. deaths pop. (1m) tot. deaths/1m pop. Italy 463 62 7.46 Iran 237 83 2.85 China 3120 1384 2.25 South Korea 53 51 1.03 Spain 30 49 0.61 France 30 67 0.44 USA 26 329 0.08 Italy has blown past China which is why they've locked down the country. Iran will surely do so next if they are not already doing so unless they want a national calamity. South Korea reacted quicker. Spain, France, will have to act next, possibly next week or the week after, the USA will have to act in about 3 or 4 weeks assuming things remain the same but by that time it'll be early April and the weather will be getting warmer so who knows. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
- tunesmith 7y agoYou have to have number for each of: (chance of contracting virus) * (chance of contracting disease from virus) * (chance of fatality from disease). The first is dependent on containment efforts. The second is not 100%. The third is also partly dependent on containment efforts, as fatality goes up if hospitals get overwhelmed. I don't see how you get "we're all going to get this" when China and South Korea are already reporting decreases in daily cases.
- stevenwoo 7y agoI really want to know if the people who appeared to catch it after recovering simply had the disease in remission or what, because being unable to develop an immunity screws up all the numbers until there is a workable vaccine.
- jobigoud 7y ago> That's a once-in-a-century, catastrophic black swan event. It's a catastrphic event but I don't see any reason it won't happen again in the coming years / decades. The virus itself could even have worse characteristics in terms of transmissibility and mortality. Our transportation network is so great and modern society so dependent on it there is no hope stopping these outbreaks going global, only slowing them down. In fact it should probably be fairly easy for a malicious actor to engineer a worse virus. Longer incubation period, truly airborne, super lethal. Whatever the final death toll is, I don't think it'll be the last or the worst of the 21st century.