5 ms·
I've been trying to find a source to clarify and have come up empty: what happened in Italy that they were hit so disproportionately hard relative to other coun
by shadowgovt 7y ago
I've been trying to find a source to clarify and have come up empty: what happened in Italy that they were hit so disproportionately hard relative to other countries?
- vernie 7y agoOlder population?
- kome 7y agothat's actually a very good answer.
- 1_player 7y agoCorrect. The average age of deceased in Italy from COVID-19 is 81.4. Which is mental and puts the current crisis in perspective. 14.3% Case Fatality Rate, 90+ years old 8.2% CFR, 80-89 4% CFR, 70-79 1.4% CFR, 60-69 0.1% CFR, 50-59 0% under 50 Source: https://www.iss.it/primo-piano/-/asset_publisher/o4oGR9qmvUz9/content/id/5289474 https://www.iss.it/primo-piano/-/asset_publisher/o4oGR9qmvUz... (Official Italian health service, 7 March 2020)
- allovernow 7y agoNothing. They're just one of the early hot spots. This virus evolves somewhat slowly- up to 2 weeks incubation period plus another 3-6 weeks of illness. But because it spreads during incubation, and has a high R0 value, once it starts spreading it does extremely rapidly in dense areas, after the 1-3 week lull. It is allegedly aerosolized and one paper reported surface contamination for >1 week. The us is in week ≈2 now. Week ≈3 is where the whole country lights up with outbreak and the government is pressed into extreme measures. This is based primarily on South Korea's timeline. On the bright side, the sprawl of the US may make this easier to deal with, but you can probably expect some domestic travel restrictions soon. I don't know if states have authority to close borders but I won't be surprised to hear about it.
- Zolomon 7y agoWhere have you read that it spreads during the incubation time? So far Swedish epidemiologs have not seen any evidence of that fact.
- swsieber 7y agoI've heard 1-14 days with an average of 3 days, but I'd have to dig up sources. But even if the long incubation periods are rare, they'll still have an outsized impact.
- toohotatopic 7y ago>average of 3 days That should be 'mean'
- vikramkr 7y agoMean is a type of average. And for communicating to the public, unless there's a strong reason otherwise, statistical jargon should absolutely be avoided in favor of more universally understood terminology.
- toohotatopic 7y agoEven worse, this is a total blunder, I meant 'median'.
- mariushn 7y agohttps://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/q-a-coronaviruses https://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/q-a-coronaviruses
- Someone 7y agoAlso, what would the mechanism be? Coughing is the ‘normal’ mechanism to move viruses out of your lungs. If it spreads before the coughing starts, i.e. during normal breathing, doesn’t it get out of your body too easily?
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> what happened in Italy that they were hit so disproportionately hard relative to other countries? Short answer: we don't know. My hypothesis: Italy was the first G7 nation to join China's Belt & Road Initiative [1]. Its populist government also bet heavily on integration with Russia and China. That caused it, alongside Germany, to get hit early. Its sclerotic state then let it fester. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative#Italy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative#Italy
- simion314 7y agoI do not understand what Russia has to do with this? If you claim that there are more people traveling between China and Italy because some commercial interests why not say that? I have no idea about such people traveling but from what I see as an outsider a lot of US business people are traveling to China and Taiwan too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eecc 7y agoOh bullshit, come on! How can a couple photo-ops and the promise to work out some favorable trade deal in the future got to do with a disease spreading today?! What happened is that someone in Germany got infected and spread it to Italy via open Schengen borders (ironically, everyone was looking at the leaky direct flight bans with China) Poor protocol in a couple ER waiting rooms caused superclusters and now it’s spreading endemically. Stop that factious blabber, please
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- haunter 7y ago- Older population - lot of heavy smokers - the typical european old people attitude (and i'm saying that as a european too): "you don't take me anywhere". My grandparents passed away long ago but they never went to doctor only in the very last minute all the time. It's a kind of mentality and you can see that in the Italy cases. When they take people to the hospital and they die the next day it means they had a heavy fever for a week or more already. They have been sick for a long time but no, we don't go to the hospital. That's why what South Korea does is important, 20k tests daily, and they have done 200k already.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agophysical contact, kiss on the cheeks common.
- jaclaz 7y agoAll three may account for higher number of fatalities, but not for the speed of the virus spreading. There is no real evidence that smokers or older people more easily get the virus, and of course if they stayed put at home they did not contribute to the spreading (they had no or however less contacts).
- haunter 7y agoAs bryanrasmussen pointed out physical contact is also more common on meeting, especially kiss on the cheek. Like that's how you greet everyone and the best way to spread viruses I've never been to the US but I don't think kiss on the cheek is that common there.
- lacker 7y agoI see a kiss on the cheek as a greeting in the US about once a year, usually between two visiting Europeans.
- anticensor 7y ago> the a typical Thanks for fixing.
- Leary 7y ago"The Lombardy outbreak came to light when a 38-year-old Italian tested positive in Codogno, a comune in the province of Lodi. According to his wife, he had met an Italian friend who had returned from China on 21 January, who subsequently tested negative.[20] On 14 February, he felt unwell and went to a doctor in Castiglione d'Adda. He was prescribed treatments for influenza.[20] On 16 February, as the 38-year-old man's condition worsened, he went to Codogno Hospital, reporting respiratory problems.[20] Initially, there was no suspicion of COVID-19, so no additional precautionary measures were taken, and the virus was able to infect other patients and health workers.[21] Later, the patient, his pregnant wife, and a friend tested positive.[20] Three more cases were confirmed on the same day, after the patients reported symptoms of pneumonia.[22] Thereafter, extensive screenings and checks were performed on everyone that had possibly been in contact or near the infected subjects.[23] The 38-year-old man was asymptomatic for weeks, reportedly led an active social life, and potentially interacted with dozens of people before spreading the virus at Codogno Hospital.[20][21] Afterwards, he was transferred to Policlinico San Matteo in Pavia,[24] and his wife to Sacco Hospital in Milan.[25][26] " [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_outbreak_in_Italy#Lombardy_cluster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_outbreak_in_I...
- cies 7y agoHeard it went through some winter sports locations. If you've ever been in such a place you know that you will at times be transported in jam-packed cable cars and buses. I can imagine one person can infect the whole car/bus, and they all leave in a few days (most people stay <10 days) and bring the virus to new lands.
- dbcurtis 7y agoBad luck. Ski season? All it takes is one person coming home from 6 weeks trying to ramp manufacturing in China taking a week's break to ski and unwind. Boom. Total speculation on my part, but you can imagine a dozen similar scenarios that are just bad luck. Heck, in Germany, there was a cross-training event at an auto manufacturer, with Chinese workers visiting plant in Germany. Imagine: "Ok, let's all take turns at the controls of this metal press..." Boom. The same thing has no doubt happened in the USA, we just don't know about it yet. I just looked at an annual event that I go to most Aprils, and.... not cancelled yet. I sure am not going this year -- I can't believe the organizers are not cancelling out -- knowing them, I suspect greed. Edit: Typo's and grammo's.
- vad_ 7y agoAll European countries are growing at the same rate. Italy just started first
- bonzini 7y agoYou're not used to the exponential nature of the spread, which makes the numbers look disproportionate, but we aren't being hit much harder. We were only hit earlier, and not that much earlier even. Most other European countries are now at 20-40 cases per million inhabitants, where Italy was 5-10 days ago[1]. They will be in our situation or worse in a week, since Italy had already started putting (mild) containment measures in place in the last week of February. [1] https://twitter.com/fagiolinux/status/1237059898304847874/photo/1 https://twitter.com/fagiolinux/status/1237059898304847874/ph...
- mrtksn 7y agoHow was the sentiment in the public before it hit the fan? Do you have politicians or celebrities who peddle the "It's only a flu" argument?
- bonzini 7y agoWe did during the first week, i.e. 10 days ago approximately, including the opposition pandering to their base about how the government was incompetent. They have since backtracked, and the opposition leader (Salvini) has never been so silent.
- mrtksn 7y agoIt feels as if all these people were trained in a secret CIA guerilla training camp and spread across the world to champion the same bullshit. I find it creepy.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIt wasn't a secret CIA camp; it was the Internet. We created systems for like-minded individuals who were previously geographically separated to find each other and cross-communicate easily, asynchronously, peer-to-peer, and globally. What you're seeing that looks like organized planning by a central office is more the effect of these people all reading (and posting on) the same news sources and message boards regardless of country of origin.
- chewz 7y agoGermany or France are only 4-5 days behind Italy in number of infected. (Germany 1100 : Italy 7300). As for number of deaths in Italy - they are already in warlike conditions where patients are going through selection and some are simply left to die. > Since there is, unfortunately, a disproportion between hospital resources, resuscitation beds and critically ill patients, not everyone can be intubated,” Salaroli said. “We decide based on age and state of health,” he added. [1] [1 https://www.brusselstimes.com/all-news/belgium-all-news/health/99412/coronavirus-we-must-choose-who-to-treat-says-italian-doctor-covid-19-christian-salaroli/ https://www.brusselstimes.com/all-news/belgium-all-news/heal...]
- Craighead 7y agoChina's belt and road initiative
- Izkata 7y agoThey did extensive testing and were finding cases other countries weren't. They changed this a bit over a week ago [0] to be more in line with other countries, so the numbers wouldn't increase quite as quickly. > Italian health officials are making another change in their testing protocols that may slow the growth of new case numbers. The country expects to limit coronavirus testing to at-risk people showing symptoms of COVID-19, said Giuseppe Ippolito, scientific director at Italy’s National Institute for Infectious Diseases. > Previously, Italy was testing anyone who visited certain towns in northern Italy or came into contact with someone infected with the virus but not necessarily showing symptoms. > Ippolito said the shift corresponds with updated recommendations from the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control,. [0] https://abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/italy-virus-count-methods-agencys-urging-69254949 https://abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/italy-virus-count-me...
- bwilli123 7y agoTextile workers from Wuhan https://www.bbc.com/news/business-21350013 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-21350013 and ..."According to data published by the Italian Ministry of Labor and Social Policies, 309,110 Chinese people were officially living in the country in 2018, comprising 155,305 men and 153,805 women with an average age of 31 years. Lombardy and Tuscany emerged as the two regions that received the largest number. Specifically, several businesses producing or selling clothes, supermarkets, and technological-device stores have been concentrated in the city of Milan, boosting a vibrant multicultural environment in Lombardy."... https://asiatimes.com/2020/03/on-being-a-chinese-in-italy-during-virus-crisis/ https://asiatimes.com/2020/03/on-being-a-chinese-in-italy-du...