2 ms·
The U.S. Isn't Ready for What’s About to Happen
- mjevans 7y agoHaving read the article, I find myself unable to recall any actual steps it recommended for preparing; aside from expecting the unknown.
- bsaul 7y agoi completely agree.. This article doesn't even assess in which way the US isn't ready (in the sense of : which country is best prepared and why)
- oefrha 7y agoI’ve been taking COVID-19 very seriously from the start (my comment history would back this claim), but the first concrete statement in this article about the danger of COVID-19 is > Last week, the World Health Organization assessed the fatality rate at a shocking 3.4 percent, much higher than previously believed. And that’s very misleading. Here’s what WHO director general actually said [1] > Globally, about 3.4% of reported COVID-19 cases have died. Which is accurate, but that’s not WHO’s accessed fatality rate. I’ve seen media roll with this accurate stat and twist it into things it isn’t, and it makes my stomach turn. Maybe they’re trying to overturn the earlier things are all good narrative, but this kind of misleading reporting doesn’t inspire confidence at all. [1] https://www.who.int/dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general-s-opening-remarks-at-the-media-briefing-on-covid-19---3-march-2020 https://www.who.int/dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general-... Edit: can’t respond on a dead article, but I’m not saying case fatality rate can’t be as high as 3.4%. It could even be higher when hospitals are overwhelmed, e.g. in Wuhan. But (reported) case fatality rate isn’t fatality rate among all infected, and certainly isn’t fatality rate among the entire population. Look no further than another comment claiming “For context, 3.4% would kill 329,000 people in the SF Bay Area” to see how people are misled.
- saiya-jin 7y agoIf you look at Italy's situation (which might be more representative for things to come compared to unique China's one as source of outbreak - initial denial and delays, and on the other side ability to stop the whole country and have population following the orders to get shit done), fatality last time I checked was above 4%. Yes, they have older population, but generally its a first world country and their health care level is definitely above world's average.
- cameldrv 7y agoThe point about parents needing to stay home is valid, but wouldn't generally apply to older children. This is an emergency -- if a ten year old kid's doctor mom and police officer dad need to show up to work, the kid can stay home. This used to be commonplace. Particularly if lessons are online over videoconference, teachers can help verify that the kids are at home and studying. Younger kids can be left with friends or relatives. This isn't ideal for infection control, but groups of 2-3 kids is much safer than groups of 25.
- donw 7y agoA large part of the problem is the sheer amount of spin present in every form of news media. Is there a genuine level of threat beyond a particularly bad influenza season -- which is no joke! -- or is the quoted 3.4 percent mortality rate a realistic number for the US, or Japan, or ...? For context, 3.4% would kill 329,000 people in the SF Bay Area, likely more given the homelessness situation. That's a world-changing event. What does that breakdown look like in terms of age distribution and other health factors? Or is this just another "be afraid! be scared!" push that the 24/7 news cycle has latched on to for eyeballs and revenue? Before this, there was SARS, and H1N1, and the West Nile virus... you cry wolf so many times, no wonder the village is slow to get its act together when you report on imminent danger of canine predators. Given the death counts, I'm inclined to take things seriously, but panic never helps anything. So, personally, I'm sticking with my infectious disease protocol: work from home, wash hands and gargle every time I come in from outside, keep my storeroom stocked with the essentials, and overall, ignore every bit of panic being pumped out by news articles like this.
- roenxi 7y ago> ... he worries that misgivings like his will become self-fulfilling prophecies—that citizens will panic if their local authorities give voice to their own doubts ... This attitude is common and remarkably foolish. If people would behave differently if they had better information then they really need that information. Problems that get smaller when ignored are rare; and this is not one of them. Panic is vastly over-hyped as a threat. The threat is government responses to sudden increases in demand; like "banning price gouging" and cementing a shortage into the medium term. Supply chains don't move that quickly, but if there is a problem in the future then a few weeks notice via market signals is extremely useful.
- bestouff 7y agoI'll be very interested in following how a powerful nation with a perceived "selfish" way of life (extremely limited sick leave, no medicare, etc.) performs in this scenario.