4 ms·
Every time you see a claim like this, remember the Shannon–Hartley theorem[1]. If you want to get a decent bandwidth in aggregate for your mobile network, you'
by londons_explore 7y ago
Every time you see a claim like this, remember the Shannon–Hartley theorem[1].
If you want to get a decent bandwidth in aggregate for your mobile network, you're going to need to consider:
* Maximize transmit Power: which is hard because phones are battery powered, and power is limited by law. Satellites are also battery powered.
* Maximize bandwidth: Also limited by rules and regulations.
* Maximize Directionality: If you have physically large antennas, you can direct your transmit power towards the receiver to make best use of it.
* Minimize Distance: Received signal power goes down the the square of he distance. Double the distance, and you get one quarter of the bandwidth, all other things being the same.
This proposal uses tiny existing antennas in phones, which means it must be making other tradeoffs. My guess is it seriously sacrifices the total throughput.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theore...
- amelius 7y ago> Satellites are also battery powered. I thought they have solar panels. Also, don't phones and satellites use small antenna arrays to direct power in a certain direction?
- fareesh 7y agoI think the panels recharge a battery. Is the satellite always within line of sight of the sun?
- gpm 7y agoSolar panels when illuminated by the sun, battery power while in the Earth's shadow. To be low latency they need to be in a low orbit, so probably on battery power for a significant fraction of the time.
- moopling 7y agoThe batteries are powered by solar panels. In either case the same arguments apply - space is notoriously low power. Phones can't use directional antennas, otherwise you'd have to point them at radio towers. Using phased array antennas in which directionality is software controlled, there's a trade off between size of antenna and how much you can focus the beam - it wouldn't work in a phone (and would be too expensive anyway).
- amelius 7y agoOk, but there is a lot of power to be saved. If you can prevent the beam from going in the "opposite" general direction, you can already save 50%. I'm not convinced there is nothing to be gained by using a small array.
- exar0815 7y agoIts just physically not feasible. For an antenna array with 2 dimensional beamforming you need an array of NxN antennas, which all have the dimension of a fraction of a wavelength, so we are talking about a not insignificant size. Additionally, to limit mutual coupling via substrate and stray radiation, you need certain distances. Third, you need to be careful to prevent grating lobes (side emissions of unwanted radiation). And even then, you will need individually controlled phase shifters for each array element, adding cost, complexity and mostly negating energy savings. Edit: All of that in addition to the problem that you need to know the location of the base station and have you array antenna roughly oriented towards it.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoIn addition to all the above, phones move a lot during a call. You'd need very good sensors to keep track of the phone's orientation in space. If you're only shooting for 50%, the sensors in phones are probably good enough, but what happens when the user puts their head between the phone and the base station? The phone could say "please rotate your body to reconnect call" but that would be a lousy user experience.
- londons_explore 7y agoThere are neat tricks to keep phased array antennas in alignment. One for example is to just send the signal back in the same direction you're receiving from. (ie. Same phase delays in every antenna element) Then however much the phone is tumbling, you'll always be exactly sending the data in the right direction. Turns out the problem is moot anyway - unless you have a huge antenna to get a really narrow beam, sub-degree positional errors won't make any impact.
- exar0815 7y agoWhat you mean is either achieved with conventional high-gain antennas (Dishes, mostly) or with beamforming by either a passive, or in this case more likely, active phased array. TBH, I dont know of any commercial handsets doing so (albeit I am not that deep into the consumer market). On Base Stations, on the other hand, yes they are using this technology to improve reception and to limit inter-cell interference.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoThey also have batteries. When their orbit takes them into Earth's shadow, the solar panels stop working.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 14 7y agoReading your comment I immediately thought probably enough throughput to covertly track a phone. I thought maybe this company isn’t really trying to sell to the public but rather get some attention to their new tech before they ultimately sell it off to the government.
- londons_explore 7y agoI'm pretty sure you can already track all phones from satellites already. Phone initial handshakes with the tower are done at high power and are always identical, meaning you can get a ridiculous coding gain to detect them.
- thedrbrian 7y agoBut starlink. Seriously how are they going to make it work?
- m463 7y agoI've wondered about that too, but their satellites are close to the ground - 620 miles vs 22,236 miles. I don't know how far away the average cellular tower is, but I imagine line of sight could be a better signal than a closer occluded signal. Wikipedia says cell tower range on hilly terrain can be 5 miles, while on flat ground it can be 30-45 miles (which is still over the horizon). What I wonder about is how many phones per satellite is supportable.