3 ms·
I'm not sure why someone created a whole video that didn't even talk about the basics. No mention of CO2 levels or global average temperature. Instead the focus
by imtringued 7y ago
I'm not sure why someone created a whole video that didn't even talk about the basics. No mention of CO2 levels or global average temperature. Instead the focus is on some random cherry picked statistics that only have local impact. Wildfires don't matter to the average person because they are living in urban centers far away from a forest that could burn their house down.
The thing about CO2 is that it gets worse the more you have in the atmosphere. If you argue today that fear of climate change is merely alarmism then there is nothing standing in the way of burning coal or gasoline. So if we follow that logic to its conclusion we end up burning all fossil fuels and all of that carbon will be in the atmosphere one day. Maybe today's CO2 levels are not dangerous to us but what about in 80 years? Will it still be safe if we keep burning more and more fossil fuels as the people in India and China enter the middle class?
If you want to avoid burning all fossil fuels then you will need an alternative energy source and if you want to reduce the total emissions then you will need to start as soon as possible. If you overreact and reduce your CO2 emissions too early people may not appreciate your help. If you act too late then the future generation will blame everything on you. It's impossible to find a good solution for everyone.
- ximeng 7y agoThat video is really talking mostly about EPA report on impacts in the US, and doesn't particularly deny the science. But it doesn't have much to do with the article posted here, which talks about a very specific point regarding modelling likely impact of temperature changes on electricity consumption. I actually agree that the report and the science in general could be a lot better presented. It's not clear exactly why they've picked those ranges for the presentations referenced in the video, and it leaves it open to accusations of bias. The summary referenced in the opening of the PDF is at https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/downloads/NCA4_Report-in-Brief.pdf https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/downloads/NCA4_Report-in-Br... page 28 - an unwieldy PDF, with difficult to follow and vague references. (E.g. "Sources: (a) adapted from Vose et al. 2017, (b) EPA, (c–f and h–l) adapted from EPA 2016, (g and center infographic) EPA and NOAA.") - I can't immediately see the source data in that reference. It doesn't exactly make it easy to understand what's going on and why. And another source he references https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/6/ https://science2017.globalchange.gov/chapter/6/ mentions the increase in heat waves in the 1930s without suggesting a reason. It would be more helpful if the video actually referenced the source as a link in the description of the video rather than forcing interested watchers to copy out the link. Basically - poor presentation in the video and in the reports it references. Furthermore, it's clear that the examples analysed in the video have also been picked out to make a point. Not very encouraging from either side really. The answer is more science and better presented science, and the fact that this video, like much of the sceptical analysis about climate change opens with a political point shows the motivation clearly.