6 ms·
> Even after recovering from an infection there will always be a piece of that virus encoded within your DNA. I did a little research and this appears to be al
by crazygringo 7y ago
> Even after recovering from an infection there will always be a piece of that virus encoded within your DNA.
I did a little research and this appears to be almost completely false.
This sentence makes it sound like every time you get a cold, your body's DNA is permanently altered. Which would be insane if true.
The reality is that this insane outcome is incredibly rare, but nevertheless has happened enough times over all of human history that we have genetic code from viruses in our DNA, because a virus at some point managed to alter the DNA in a sperm or egg cell.
But the quoted sentence is just not how infections work 99.99...+% of the time. The cold I got last month isn't in my DNA forever. It's very sloppy writing that appears to be aiming for sensationalism instead of accuracy.
- thombat 7y agoIf it was true then presumably we'd see the DNA of identical twins diverging with age (proxy for number of infections). Do we?
- ezoe 7y agoNot just twin, but your former self too.
- im3w1l 7y agoThis happens even from just spontaneous mutations. The body has many copies of DNA and they are not in sync with each other. Your cells diverge from your twins' cells, but also from each other.
- orestarod 7y agoThe DNA of every single cell in your body can have spontaneous mutations. But what is important for what you become in general is the DNA of your first cell that is rapidly multiplied to form your body. And what is important for what you leave on the next generation, is the DNA of your reproducing cells, which can too be individually altered, of course.
- ourlordcaffeine 7y agoIn addition, only retroviruses are capable of altering DNA in such a manner. The common cold is not a retrovirus.
- kalium_xyz 7y agoSometimes it is, it depends on the virus causing it.
- vikramkr 7y agoDo you have any examples of retroviruses that cause the common cold? I did a quick search but couldn't find anything, but that sounds like something that would be really interesting to read up on - the classical retrovirus isn't necessarily something that can go away after a couple days of sniffles and I'm curious to know if there are long term consequences to colds caused by retroviruses.
- kalium_xyz 7y agoThe search results are probably flooded, if you need good info look for anything from before the resent outbreak. Its on the wikipedia page for common cold, I think I got the factoid when I was searching google patents for coronavirus (might be interesting to check out as well) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_cold#Viruses https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_cold#Viruses
- vikramkr 7y agoI don't think coronavirus is an integrating retrovirus? It's an RNA virus for sure, but I haven't ever heard of it causing genome integration, and it would probably be a lot more dangerous (ability to cause cancer for instance) if it did?
- rubicon33 7y agoMind linking some of the research? I've heard otherwise, but would be happy to read what you've read.
- PunchTornado 7y agoyes. that is completely false. now I'm doubting the whole article.
- vikramkr 7y agoThere's also some stuff about circadian rythms in there that makes no sense - the main point of the article that our genome has viral dna in it is true and really cool, the details of the article are kind of fantasy though. If you're interested in learning more probably better to do your own research or read through the wiki or something rather than sift through this article which, while an admirable attempt by a non-scientist to explore an interesting phenomenon, is not a very successful attempt.
- WoahNoun 7y agoThe author of this article is a philosopher promoting a book and not a scientist.
- MarkusQ 7y ago> Viruses [...]have circadian rhythms like all living things. > circadian adj. of, relating to, or showing rhythmic behaviour with a period of 24 hours; especially of a biological process No, they don't. And the rest of the paragraph is equally goofy.
- vikramkr 7y agoThe circadian rythm thing is so egregiously absurd that it's easy to overlook the other spectacular claim in that sentence. Some people could argue that viruses are alive, but that's far from the mainstream interpretation and to say that the statement is wading into some potentially really be controversial territory is an understatement.
- Retric 7y agoThe human body has around 40 trillion cells, and only DNA from one of gets passed on to each child. Considering how frequently that cell happened to be infected in human history the average person like has many individual cells with some new viral DNA. But, criticaly those changes are neither inherented by children or widespread across every cell. In effect what’s being described is an interesting oddity rather than a significant effect on an individual level. Unless it happens to cause cancer, etc.
- dharma1 7y agoTo pass a viral alteration of DNA to offspring, the retrovirus has to infect germline cells, which they usually don't - and in a way that produces a viable offspring, which is even rarer. That's not to say it doesn't happen over long enough time period - it clearly does. From wikipedia- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endogenous_retrovirus Most retroviruses infect somatic cells, but occasional infection of germline cells (cells that produce eggs and sperm) can also occur. Rarely, retroviral integration may occur in a germline cell that goes on to develop into a viable organism. This organism will carry the inserted retroviral genome as an integral part of its own genome—an "endogenous" retrovirus (ERV) that may be inherited by its offspring as a novel allele.
- jhbadger 7y agoThe article is rather fancifully written (and by a non-scientist) but as a professional genomicist, I can assure you that the human genome is full of viruses, the remnants of which are almost entirely non-functional, but are interesting in the way meteor craters are to geology. Here is a review (nearly twenty years old from when the human genome was first sequenced) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC138943/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC138943/
- colechristensen 7y agoPresumably there are some effects to the large amount of non-functional DNA we carry around, has anybody looked in to this or thought about what would happen if we removed much of it (a sort of cleaning house gene editing for an experimental line of some species)
- svaigsq 7y agoThe article gives very clear idea, that "non-functional DNA" can become very functional after transposons spring into action(at birth, during illness, whatever the trigger), so writing it off as something that can be spring cleaned is too early. As for clean house - what exactly is template here? Some humans have genes, that others don't have - DNA is not something, that has all the attributes of all humans with true/false values attached to them. Some humans have slanted eyes and have genes that are responsible for that look and others don't have such genes when they have no such feature and there are other genes responsible for their look. And this looks a sh!t job to sort out all "functional" genes of every human, as DNA of them is not going to be the same. Editing out nonfunctional DNA looks like one of those ideas from 60s, when it was in fashion to remove appendix and make smaller stomach and they in the end paid with shorter lifespan.
- sudoaza 7y agoHuh, can we remove those? isn't there a cost to have all those extra sequences lying around?
- bananamerica 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ivanhoe 7y agoRetroviruses spread by altering host cells' DNA, so I doubt it is really such an "incredibly rare" event for those infected by them, like e.g. HIV positive people.