4 ms·
Part of why cashless works is the same reason the Swedish welfare state generally works: a trust of government. Contrast this with Germany and its history with.
by dehrmann 7y ago
Part of why cashless works is the same reason the Swedish welfare state generally works: a trust of government. Contrast this with Germany and its history with...lists; it's best not to have yourself be too traceable. I think the US is somewhere in-between, but at the end of the day, we'll hand over a lot for 2% cashback and avoid paying for journalism at all costs.
- LatteLazy 7y agoOf course, the German government that made lists did so without credit card records or electronic ids or anything like that...
- ColanR 7y agoAnd just think what they could have accomplished if that modern tech had existed.
- ce4 7y agoThis misses the point - the spying-on-your-citizens was decided by the state on purpose, going completely cashless enables dragnet surveillance that makes it really hard to evade if one has to (journalists, dissidents)
- LatteLazy 7y agoOh, I was just answering the German comparison. I agree that mass surveillance is a terrible idea and is incomparable with democracy.
- theshrike79 7y agoIt wasn't fully manual: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust
- johnlorentzson 7y agoI never thought I'd see "IBM" and "holocaust" in the same sentence, but here I am.
- theshrike79 7y agoThey're not exactly advertising it =) Just like Hugo Boss don't mention their Nazi Uniform Design Division in investor calls.
- marton78 7y agoThat's a common misconception. Hugo Boss didn't design the Nazi uniforms, but they manufactured it.
- dehrmann 7y agoI'll throw out Bayer, Volkswagen, Ford, and GM as companies with Nazi ties worth reading into.
- luckylion 7y ago> the German government that made lists Governments. We didn't stop making lists after 45, in neither the FRG nor the GDR, the outcomes were just not as severe if you ended up on one of them.
- mellavora 7y agoNot quite -- they did have some powerful support from IBM... so you are correct, not electronic IDs, but they did have a machine-readable datastore of everyone's address and other details (punchcards, I believe).
- Svip 7y agoAnother consideration is PoS cost. In Denmark, I know that credit card PoS's are super expensive to rent. And you need to rent them, because if you buy them - which is even more expensive - you'll have to replace them every year. So you need a certain amount of turnover to have a credit card PoS in Denmark. The card PoS's come in two forms; one that only takes the Danish Dankort (which is the cheaper) and one that also accepts foreign cards. Which is why merchants in Denmark - at least smaller ones - are still weary about upgrading to the fancy PoS, and therefore need to accept cash some times. Sure, there are alternatives to that, like MobilePay. But usually your problem will be with tourists, who don't have access to that, nor access to a Danish card, and can only pay cash. (Another good reason why governments won't abandon cash; they'd lose a lot of tourists too.) I don't know whether PoS's are cheaper in Sweden than in Denmark, but generally speaking, Danes and Swedes have about the same level of trust in government, yet there are far more cash transactions in Denmark compared to Sweden.
- jbergens 7y agoThere are newer solutions like iZettle for cards that costs less. In Sweden we also have Swish, payment by smartphone without cards, but that is also a bit harder for older people.
- Svip 7y agoI've encountered one merchant in Denmark using iZettle. He has since replaced it with the regular PoS. I can only imagine that is more expensive for him, but I wonder why he abandoned iZettle? Maybe it doesn't work that well? I am honestly wondering why I don't see more usage of iZettle. It could just be a Danish thing. And yes, there is Swish/MobilePay, but that only really works if you're local. A tourist - even one from a neighbouring country - will not have access to that.
- jks 7y agoWe have MobilePay in Finland, but I don't know if it interoperates with the Danish system. Denmark is part of the Single Euro Payments Area, so I would expect transfers to be possible. There were iZettles in many Helsinki cafés a few years ago, but it seems to me that most of them have been replaced by normal PoS terminals.
- anovikov 7y agoIn Russia, people logically, and quite justified, distrust the government as much as possible. Government there has a huge history of enslaving, torturing and killing their citizens all the way through today, in way Germany didn't know since the times of Nazis, not even in the GDR. Yet, everyday transactions in Russia are pretty much cashless, people pay to one another through card-to-card transfers and mobile payment are almost as universal as in China (where people don't trust their government at all btw).
- jjgreen 7y agoThat trust is ill-founded https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilisation_in_Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilisation_in_Sw...
- ElFitz 7y agoIt's surprising and worrying how many countries merrily jumped on that bandwagon https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization
- AdmiralGinge 7y agoThe UK is really weird in this regard, things like ID cards were massively rejected as far too authoritarian but we also have a government that wanted to bring in an insane internet restrictions. I think it comes of not having had a revolution in our recent history, much of Europe has the Nazis or Soviets in living memory to inoculate against trusting the government too much, our last experiment with overthrowing the government was Cromwell in the 17th century and he imposed a regime so austere and repressive we reverted back to a monarchy (albeit a constitutional one) and have stayed that way since.