10 ms·
Look, either it's worth it or it's not. Costs may be soaring, but companies wouldn't be buying them if they weren't providing more value than they cost. But: >
by crazygringo 7y ago
Look, either it's worth it or it's not. Costs may be soaring, but companies wouldn't be buying them if they weren't providing more value than they cost. But:
> enterprise companies are spending an average of more than $10,000 per employee per year on software
Sorry but I can't wrap my head around this. Is that really accurate? Between Office and cloud and HR/payroll and a few other tools I can imagine $1,000/year. And certain employees need SalesForce or Adobe CC or whatever which adds another, say, $500-2,000.
But I just cannot possibly imagine how an average employee is using $10K worth of subscription services?! Does anyone else think this is accurate?
- PopeDotNinja 7y ago> but companies wouldn't be buying them if they weren't providing more value than they cost Companies do stupid shit all the time. It only takes one person with authority to spend money to sign up for a service. Personally I've seen many software subscriptions that are complete garbage.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y ago“We’ve seen companies buy the same subscription over and over again—even within the same department,” he added. I think that's telling
- Aeolun 7y agoIt’s not so surprising, if the owners of the original subscription prevent access to new people because ‘their costs will rise’. I’m planning to request a new subscription for exactly that reason.
- tialaramex 7y agoOne of the worst things I've seen at an employer was more than one SSO. That's when you know the people paying your wages are truly dysfunctional. Because of course Fiefdom A doesn't want Fiefdom B's SSO to be used by their systems, that gives the person ruling Fiefdom B power - so instead get a separate SSO, what do you mean that's missing the point? If I worked for an SSO provider I think I'd be tempted to expontentially scale corporate pricing. Want just one SSO system for (say) 10 000 employees? That'll be $5000 pa. Oh you want a second one at the same company? $20k pa please. Third one? $100k. My reasoning would be: An outfit which buys more than one is completely irrational and so they are my best target to gouge as heavily as possible because they'll be least able to do anything about it.
- topkai22 7y agoI’ve mainly seen that situation in post M&A environments, and while fiefdoms are often a part of the problem, untangling auth across multiple enterprise systems is really hard.
- chopin 7y agoBut the GP's pricing scheme would put a hard incentive on fixing it.
- tialaramex 7y agoThe fiefdoms I'm thinking of were created naturally inside the organisation, not acquired. Somebody's power grows, a department with ten people becomes a business unit with a thousand people due to its success, other managers resent that, and senior management mistakes this as an opportunity for "internal competition" rather than a dysfunction which needs to be crushed, if necessary by terminating those who promote it. Lots of things are hard about M&A but it's made easier if people remember from the outset that their business exists in the world. You don't have and can't build a business which functions independently from the world, stop trying. On the technology side that means things like using FQDNs in URLs (https://webinar.mycorp.example/2020-New-Products https://webinar.mycorp.example/2020-New-Products not https://webinar/2020-New-Products https://webinar/2020-New-Products)
- notlukesky 7y agoThe benefits and pitfalls of multiple payment approvals
- mint2 7y agoAnd don’t forget the vendor lock in. why change what works and redo all the work done in that system. It would require a huge expense and time cost to port to another platform. And there’s the fact that longterm employees and more importantly managers are likely familiar with the old software and will see little reason to even test the waters with something else. And that’s how programs like emblem stay around.
- paulddraper 7y agoYeah, those numbers seem very suspicious. Cherry-picked maybe. Fifty dollars a month is a decently pricey subscription (like a lot more than Slack, JIRA, Lucidchart, Office, etc.), and you have twenty of those for every employee?
- jschwartzi 7y agoI've used specialized embedded system tools that cost $10,000/year per seat for tooling. Our QNX licenses were about $5,000 or $10,000/year alone. That's just to be able to run a piece of software. Autodesk tooling is $20 to 30k a year. Some of the more specialized tools cost six-figures. So I guess if you're just doing some basic web development those numbers are suspect. But if you do hardware or embedded software projects $20,000/year per person is cheap.
- Aeolun 7y agoMaybe 1% of enterprises do hardware or embedded development.
- WoahNoun 7y agoYou can pick a industrial vertical and find analogues though. Aerospace, automative, chemical, materials, biosciences. And even within a company each departments like finance, marketing, supply chain, etc have their own specialized software. Inventory management isn't cheap. Marketing software like marketo isn't cheap. ERP systems for the finance department aren't cheap. Accounting and tax software isn't cheap.
- paulddraper 7y agoI agree, but how much employees at an enterprise have the software? Like 5%.
- fiter 7y agoFor such products, there's the per seat license and the per device license. Depending on volume and vendor pricing model more of the cost will either be in the seat or device license. The value of these the seat license is so that you can distribute their software on your devices versus the value of the seat license of Adobe CC is so that you can use the software directly.
- SonicScrub 7y agoThat number doesn't surprise me. Your quick $1000-$2000 estimate is probably accurate for a typical office worker, but the more specialized positions skew the average. I work in mechanical/aerospace engineering for a large company. A lot of the software we use is very specialized and very costly. Here's the yearly costs from the top 4 softwares I use based on a quick google search: 1) $35,000 2) $15,000 3) $10,000 4) $4,500 So I'm costing the company ~$65,000 per year in software licenses alone.
- baddox 7y agoDo you mean that no one else at your company uses any of those 4 softwares?
- jachee 7y agoNot if they're per-seat licenses.
- a13n 7y agoThat's per license, per employee? Or company-wide license fee? If the latter, you still need to divide by the total number of users of the product.
- leetcrew 7y agoif GP works in aerospace, those are very likely per-seat license costs.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoCompletely out of curiousity -- what software costs $35k per seat per year??
- IggleSniggle 7y agoVxWorks is about that I believe. When you reach these kinds of price tags though it's hard to evaluate them on a per seat basis, because they tend to come with built-in consultants, etc. CryEngine 3 is notoriously $1.2 million, but I believe that's a "total cost" rather than a per seat style license.
- swiley 7y agoMS office is probably one of them. Office 365 isn’t worth it but most people don’t seem to know that.
- svartkanin 7y agoAll companies I've worked at had dev environments that did not require any licensing. The tools used where mainly free or under the free tier (sublime, eclipse, CurcleCI, AWS...) For larger products those will require to purchase certain usage since the workload will be higher but that's a company product cost and not per dev. Unless one is developing MS products or is dependent on MS software I can't see how the numbers mentioned add up
- geogra4 7y agoRight but MS has such a stranglehold that no business dare run without office. It's a shame that no one really has competition for them
- prostheticvamp 7y agoFor whom is it not worth it? Software devs? Are they representative of the average white collar? I couldn’t live without excel.
- adjkant 7y agoSheets will fit a lot of excel use cases for those not doing serious heavy lifting with it. FWIW, I'm a software engineer and our IT department actually let people opt out of Microsoft office if they weren't using it to save money, and encouraging people to use Google Docs/Sheets (as most do anyways). I'm guessing a good deal of software engineers did that but there are plenty of non-engineers that probably also did outside of finance / some sales people.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoand even if it is worth it, Why aren't they switching to equally good subscriptions that are cheaper? that's the real question.
- rodgerd 7y agoThen someone gets Slack because they don't like Teams, and they think that's worth it. Someone else wants Flowdock. Your new exec used Zoom at his old job and wants everyone to have that for video calling. Your IT security team have half a dozen anti-virus tools, two data loss prevention tools, three monitoring solutions because they're overwhelmed by the amount of data coming out of them. You use a third party RAS solution that doesn't work as well as the one built into Windows, but boy does it add a chunk per-user. You're still running a few JVM applications which you now owe Oracle for the pleasure of using an old JRE. No-one uses the three knowledge management tools you've bought over the years to try and organize your documentation, but you can't decommission any of them yet, because you never migrated everything out of them. Then someone in the finance team decides the way to tackle out-of-control costs is to buy a tool to monitor installed software on all the desktops. It has another agent. Welcome to the swamp.
- sixdimensional 7y agoYou speak the truth!
- tryitnow 7y agoI think it may depend on the company and on how these "averages" are calculated. For a company where almost all the workforce is white collar then yes, $10K seems reasonable. In fact, I'm surprised it's not more. For a company like Wal-Mart, I'd be shocked to see that much spend on software subscription.
- iamaelephant 7y ago> Between Office and cloud and HR/payroll and a few other tools I can imagine $1,000/year. Really? You can imagine only #83/mo in software costs for a working professional? I think you're being really rather unimaginative.
- crazygringo 7y agoI'm not trying to be super-imaginative, I'm trying to be realistic. That's the point. Considering Office 365 is $10/mo (before volume discounts) and is probably the main tool most office workers use, I am having a hard time how on earth you get to $10K/12=$833/mo. I'm supposed to believe the average office worker uses a total of subscription software that is eighty times more expensive than Microsoft Office?
- WoahNoun 7y agoAccounting software, payroll software, financial planning software, supply chain management/inventory, health insurance/401k/benefits/PTO software, JIRA/Ticketing, knowledge management (sharepoint/internal wiki/confluence), data warehouse licenses, reporting software (tableau, looker), IT and device management software, expense and reimbursement, business travel scheduling, performance management, contract management, backups and disaster planning, etc. And then any specialized software for actually doing different jobs roles (CAD, photo/video editing (think of the marketing and design departments of any F1000 company), IDE's for the developers, operations software for running a warehouse or factory, etc.
- luckylion 7y agoYou've listed a ton of tools, but not every office employee uses those, and I hope that payroll software isn't costing $1000 per employee/year. To get to those large numbers, you'll need to hand-pick companies that have few non-specialized employees.
- lwb 7y agoQualtrics, a company I have worked for in the past, specializes in selling huge experience management packages to global enterprises. Deal size ranges anywhere from $10k to $1mil+ (yearly). Then there's SAP which is something like $3k per user per year. These things can seriously add up.
- Aeolun 7y agoSAP might be worth it, but my first experience with it has been absolutely awful. Some buttons are hidden behind 3 layers of scrollbars because they’ve put panes inside of panes inside of panes. It’s ridiculous...
- theklub 7y agoWhat about VMware, backup software, system monitoring software, update software, remote support and meeting apps. Spam filter, Terminal server licensing. There’s more I’m forgetting
- pas 7y agoWhy would any of them be per employee?
- the8472 7y agoper-user licensing.
- pas 7y agoReally every user needs a VMware VM and terminal server, and monitoring license? Maybe they do, but they better do something that makes a lot of money to cover the costs.
- theklub 7y agoWhy wouldn't it be? The size of your infrastructure depends on the amount of employees you have.
- achenatx 7y agoonce you start talking about SAP and other enterprise software you are talking big $$
- hexl 7y ago> companies wouldn't be buying them if they weren't providing more value than they cost At first, but value may decrease in time and companies will still be dependent because it may not be possible to take the data out, logistics, contracts, bureaucracy, etc...
- rkagerer 7y agoIt's probably total SaaS spend divided by headcount. There are lots of bits you may not interface with directly, e.g. backup & compliance, infrastructure monitoring, advertising. And as another comment suggested, certain specialized applications with sky-high license fees.
- mywittyname 7y agoI used to work for a company whose licensing fees were mid-five figures a seat. Granted, not every person in the company needed a license; but nearly everyone involved in the production process did. The company also benefited from vendor lock-in, because skilled workers tend to get pretty attached to their workflows and competitors in niche software tend not to have 1-to-1 feature overlaps. It seems like nearly every profession has high-priced software that's required: artists, engineers, accountants, lawyers, doctors/nurses, research scientists, architects, etc, are buying products from Adobe, Quicken, West Law, Reed Elsevier, Epic. None of those are small companies, yet all of them focus in somewhat niche information technology sectors. I'm struggling to come up with a profession that doesn't touch software anymore; even retail workers use point of sale and inventory software. I do agree with your sentiment though. The software is expensive because it's so niche. The market for all of this stuff is pretty limited, meaning there's only a few products offered, and the capital required to build competitive products makes it prohibitive for a company to build their own. The companies making the software also understand their target industries intimately enough to know exactly what price the market will bare. However, it does leave an interesting market opportunity for and engineer + domain expert to tap into the market with cheap, low-feature offerings. Or maybe we will see more companies bringing development back in-house.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoSoftware isn't expensive because it's niche. It's about case and effect: seat costs for specialised tools are high because they can be. People with limited B2B experience underestimate just how much cash large corporates can throw around without even noticing, and how rarely ROI is assessed on this spending. The development costs required to create a competitor to an industry standard product can be relatively small. (Sometimes they aren't - but they can be.) The real costs are in marketing and sales. Quicken doesn't do anything outstandingly clever, but good luck trying to sell your new competitor to existing accountants. Generally there's only a change if the incumbent gets too greedy and complacent, or if the industry changes significantly and a new generation of companies appears with new ideas about which software is "standard."
- chaosbutters314 7y agoI'm with SonicScrub. In my last job, my yearly licenses for me and my group of about 6 were $1 million annually not including hardware. We likely heavily skewed the average workers costs since we used extremely expensive, specialized software
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- caseysoftware 7y agoWe - at Okta - publish a report on this every year. Here's the January 2020 study: https://www.okta.com/businesses-at-work/2020 https://www.okta.com/businesses-at-work/2020 A key finding: "Over the years, we’ve seen app adoption steadily rise, across all industries and company sizes. This year, the average number of apps per customer reached 88: that’s a 6% increase from 83 apps a year ago, and a 21% increase from 72 apps three years ago. And now 10% of our customers deploy a substantial 200 apps or more. When we look at customers that have been with Okta for more than four years, they deploy an average of 190 apps." Odds are, a good chunk of those are free but if the average subscription cost is $10/month => $10/month * 12 months * 88 apps => $10560/year aka well within the estimate cited.
- johnmaguire2013 7y agoOf course this also assumes every app is licensed to every employee.
- ratsmack 7y agoWe used Epicore Vantage ERP for manufacturing. The starting cost per seat was $175 per user per month. With many added modules it can easily reach twice that per user. Our $30 million a year company was spending about $150K per year licencing this product, and this was only one of our software packages. I think the $10K number is reality for many companies.
- ramphastidae 7y agoIn addition to that, some equivalent of Gsuite, Jira, Confluence, Trello, Slack, Figma, Expensify, Github, Looker, Tripactions, Greenhouse, and Jenkins all feel like table stakes for an enterprise firm these days.
- hef19898 7y agoWell, it depends. Only considering Saas, i have a hard time to imagine that as well. If include highly specialized stuff, Catia and so on, SAP etcc.., and devide that by total number of users (not employees) the picture changes. I am currently at roughly 40 per user. That includes MS Office 365, three mail accounts under Office 365 for the TMS / WMS suite, Wordpress and Slidebean. Hope I didn't forget nything. On the other hand so, Catia liscences are usually part of the service (for engineering corps.) or part of the product development costs (for manufacturing corps). in both cases costs are covered by customers. Especially in Aerospace these costs are the least f the cost problems.
- p0nce 7y agoIt think the point of the article is that with SaaS, the customer invariably end up spending more than she really wanted vs purchased locally-hosted software. Which is a big reason why there is so much SaaS in the first place, in both the consumer and professional world: the customer _forgets_ about this recurring cost.