13 ms·
This sentiment seems to be rooted in a misunderstanding of what trusted computing is trying to achieve on a fundamental level. The idea is not to "take control
by lxgr 7y ago
This sentiment seems to be rooted in a misunderstanding of what trusted computing is trying to achieve on a fundamental level.
The idea is not to "take control over people's computers", i.e. your trust in your own computer. It is rather to enable somebody to gain some level of trust in the computations that are happening on somebody else's computer.
Yes, this technology is commonly used for DRM, and that was one of its earliest applications. But it's not limited to that. Trusted computing can switch the roles and give you as a user certainty over the computations a third party provider performs in the cloud on your behalf. The Signal team is doing a lot of very interesting experiments there [1].
If your concern is a hardware backdoor or something similar, this is less of a question of trusted computing, and rather one of trust in hardware vendors. Your hardware vendor can screw you over entirely without TPM, TEE, secure elements and the like.
On the other hand, Intel's trusted computing platform being horribly broken does not magically give you FOSS replacements for all the firmware, ROMs and microcode running on the dozens of peripherals in your computer.
[1] https://signal.org/blog/secure-value-recovery/ https://signal.org/blog/secure-value-recovery/
- guerrilla 7y ago> Your hardware vendor can screw you over entirely without TPM, TEE, secure elements and the like. Yes they can, but as I understand it they are using TPM to screw us over, hence people celebrating its being popped. No misunderstanding of trusted computing necessary: there aren't, in practice, other vendors to choose from here.
- lxgr 7y agoCould you elaborate on the ways that people are being screwed over by TPM? I do see that the existence of both trusted and untrusted systems could exert some pressure on consumers to adopt the latter, due to the unavailability of certain services on the former (e.g. DRM, banking apps on rooted Android phones etc). The danger here is a loss of "freedom to tinker", which I do appreciate very much, and I share that concern. But has that actually happened with TPM?
- ghostpepper 7y agoWhat about the fact that the newest Intel CPU that can run Coreboot is from 2012 since all the subsequent ones have been locked by Intel? Isn't the TPM directly responsible for loss of that freedom to tinker?
- wmf 7y agoCoreboot runs on the latest Intel CPUs (and work is underway for CPUs that haven't even been released yet) but it uses binary blobs. Those blobs have nothing to do with TPMs, the ME, or whatever.
- floatboth 7y agoAs already mentioned the coreboot bit is false, but also: the TPM is a PASSIVE component. It only responds to your requests and you can do cool things with it. https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-10564-hacking_with_a_tpm https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-10564-hacking_with_a_tpm
- mokus 7y agoJust a few months ago I bought a comet lake laptop that shipped with coreboot, so I have no idea what you’re talking about here.
- hedora 7y agoCertain 4K/ HDR content is only available on PCs if you use edge.
- bepvte 7y agoThats not TPM.
- johncolanduoni 7y agoI'm curious, where are TPMs being used to screw people over in your opinion?
- wmf 7y agoThat's all correct, yet it doesn't consider the politics. The people on this thread are concerned about a huge power imbalance between customers and companies; specifically, customers have zero bargaining power so they should expect trusted computing to be used "against" them far more often than it's used "for" them.
- conradev 7y agoI think we need to come up with solutions to problems like key escrow (i.e. in Signal's case) that don't require trusted computing because a single root of trust for hardware is a single point of failure and depends on trusting the hardware manufacturer. There are a lot of possibilities with distributed computing
- josh2600 7y agoDo you have any narrative of how to do key recovery safely without an enclave or a human in the loop? I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about this and I don’t really know how to do it without one of those two things. Edit: like I hear you saying there are possibilities in a distributed computing world, but I don’t have any idea what distributed computing enables for key recovery (except possibly k of n schemes but that’s just replication, not safety). Edit 2: also, presume that users suck at key management and can’t remember long password strings, 24 words, or be trusted to store a key for a meaningful period of time.
- lxgr 7y agoIt would still be an enclave of sorts, but white box cryptography is generally trying to achieve a similar goal as trusted computing, without relying on trusted hardware.
- josh2600 7y agoI don’t think the enclave you’re describing exists, nor do I believe there is an enclave that is untrusted hardware. Do you have an example of such an enclave and how it would operate without a remote attention service in the model where a user can trust that a distributed network they don’t control is safeguarding their key?
- sounds 7y agoIf homomorphic encryption advances to the point where it's usable, that would be an example of security on untrusted hardware. (But I suppose that just proves your point.)
- Hello71 7y agothat sounds vastly overgenerous. if that were truly the case, then TEE wouldn't be built into every consumer system. if it were actually to protect against malicious cloud providers, then TEE would be only available for special (read: expensive) processors. see: intel and ECC memory. the goal of TEE is to benefit big corp and fuck the user, and just because it can in theory be used for other purposes is barely a consolation.
- lxgr 7y agoTEE is practically used for mainly two things in current smartphones: DRM and hardware key storage. DRM lets users watch Netflix on their phones while on an airplane. Hardware key storage significantly decreases the attack surface for malware trying to extract them, compared to storing them on the application processor. How is the average user being fucked here, exactly?
- Hello71 7y agoso what you're saying is that without TEE, Netflix would shut down? come on. Netflix would clearly keep operating with or without DRM, all TEE does is make it harder for the user to access their legitimate (non-Netflix) content in anything but the most approved way. it entrenches mainstream operating systems and makes it harder to use FOSS. sure, I'll concede that Netflix is not the most damaging to user freedom, but that's not what OP is about. nobody would give a shit about this vulnerability if it was just Netflix, because Netflix is broken against hardcore attackers anyways. TEE proponents want to expand its use to more user-hostile applications. that's my concern. hardware encryption is arguably a better use of TEE, but as far as I know, no actual implementations use SGX for that purpose. the TPM is used, but it's not fast enough for actual encryption. the OS loads the keys from the TPM and does the encryption in regular software.
- rcxdude 7y ago> DRM lets users watch Netflix on their phones while on an airplane. No, DRM exists to restrict users, it does not enable anything for them.