4 ms·
I'm not convinced about the underlying premise that age is an important factor here. If people think Biden or Trump or McConnell or Pelosi are effective leaders
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I'm not convinced about the underlying premise that age is an important factor here. If people think Biden or Trump or McConnell or Pelosi are effective leaders, why should it matter what age they are? I suspect that only the most politically engaged people even consider the question.
- Reedx 7y agoLife expectancy and health (mental & physical) matters. Especially in the case of a President. Plus you want them to be able to serve 2 terms, so you need to consider current age + 8 years.
- _marlowe_ 7y agoAge related cognitive decline is a real thing.
- ThinkBeat 7y agoBecause when you are 70 years or older your cognitive abilities are not what they used to be. Would you want a 70 year old person to be trained as a fighter pilot? Would you want him or her as a fireman, trying to carry people out of a fire? A lot of great people are sharp and intelligent far into their old age, and a lot more people are not. But their brain doesnt learn as fast, doesnt adapt as well. I want the person sitting on the nuclear button, who decides our climate policy, that decides about health care, about using our military, to be in their prime. There are reasons for mandatory limits in certain professions, having one for becoming president is a good idea.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoA lot of decision making is made by staffers. They rely on staffers to due the heavy lifting, and then the elected public official goes through the motion of reading statements written by staffers, introducing legislation, etc. Parliamentarians are quite important to Congress' day-to-day functioning. Also, as a public official, your party's platform already outlines what sides of issues you are on.
- D-Coder 7y ago"Would you want a 70 year old person to be trained as a fighter pilot? Would you want him or her as a fireman, trying to carry people out of a fire?" No, but those aren't the jobs under consideration here. The President can usually check with advisors and take five minutes or a couple of weeks to work out a response. "Nuclear button" is the only one of the items listed that would be a five-minute response; policies can easily wait a week or more to work out. How long did it take to put the ACA together?