17 ms·
From my personal point of view, basic income SHOULD disincentivise work; it's a boost for society, health, well-being, children, etc. Because in the current ec
by Cthulhu_ 7y ago
From my personal point of view, basic income SHOULD disincentivise work; it's a boost for society, health, well-being, children, etc.
Because in the current economy, a lot of people have to work unreasonable hours, multiple jobs, and have all people in a family work to make ends meet, at the cost of personal health and well-being, personal time, having children at all or having more children, getting married and buying a house, etc.
Right now I'm stressed because I'm earning less than I spend, my girlfriend is stressed because she doesn't have a job yet and due to personal reasons may find it hard to get, keep, and work enough hours at a job, etc. If she earned a basic income we'd be out of the woods already. If I then also earned one on top of my job we'd be VERY comfortable.
(And keep in mind I would already pay for both of our basic incomes through the income taxes I'm paying at the moment. I'm happily paying taxes because other people paying taxes put me through college and into my current job)
- sabarn01 7y agoPeople should fear being destitute its the natural human condition. Learning skills is the only way to make wealth.
- nennes 7y agoThat's a common argument to justify inequality. If learning is the key, then why is there such a huge income disparity between men and women? Are women lazy and don't learn?
- toolz 7y agoWhat you're arguing for is equity, not equality. We already have equal opportunity. As for the gender wage gap, if women are so disadvantaged - exactly how do they make up 85% of consumer spending?
- nennes 7y agoHow do we have equal opportunity? Can you point me towards evidence of this? I guess you're not arguing about the gender wage gap, as it's a well documented fact. What is the point you're trying to make?
- rstupek 7y agoAnd yet not everyone can agree on what the cause of said gender wage gap truly is. Is it because women take time off to raise children, thus setting back their wage advancement? Is it because women are less likely to be more vigorous in asking for wage increases than men? Or is just because men are keeping women down?
- munk-a 7y agoAs an example... for my wife, her salary was depressed because her boss thought that I make good enough money that she doesn't really need it. I think a lot of women still receive extremely slanted peer reviews due to gender biases (she's really catty, while he tends to raise good arguments), relationship drama (I mean, she's a good worker, but she turned down a drink with me... I don't know how good her judgement is), straight up appearance judgements (Oh, don't give the raise to nancy, she'll have a cushy life with looks like that, barbara could use it more), and harassment (I don't know about that raise - hey what are you doing friday?). I think that everyone feels like we've totally solved gender discrimination forever while it's still really deeply seated in our culture.
- toolz 7y agoWhat is the point, _you're_ trying to make? If you're trying to show women are financially burdened you can cherry-pick wage gap data to show that, sure, or you can take a more holistic view of society and what do you see? You see women with significantly more purchasing power than men. So are women disadvantaged or is there no incentive to be high earners? For me it's fairly obvious. There will be men and women who become high earners. There will be men and women who are overlooked based on gender. What I see with the wage gap can be fully explained by lack of necessity to earn for women. Think about that for a minute - they earn less than men, but they spend vastly more money than men. Exactly where is the incentive to earn more for women? Should they continue to work and earn more until they make up 90% of consumer spending? 95%? It's beyond me how anyone can claim a group that represents 85% of consumer spending is somehow financially burdened and suffers from inequality. It's almost unfathomable, but here we are.
- chickenpotpie 7y agoDude, we are faaaaaaaaar from equal opportunity. One of the largest predictors of one's ability to accumulate wealth is still the wealth of their own parents. The U.S. is one of the countries with the highest link between parents' and a child's wealth.
- bluGill 7y agoCitation needed. I hear this often, but no hard evidence that isn't easy to show is false.
- Shacklz 7y ago> Citation needed. Here you go: "The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobility since 1940", Raj Chetty et al. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/356/6336/398 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/356/6336/398
- denisw 7y agoI recommend „Capital in the 21st Century“ by Thomas Pikkety, an economist who has deeply studied wealth and income equality using historical data spanning three centuries. This book has all the evidence you need. https://www.amazon.com/-/de/dp/0674979850 https://www.amazon.com/-/de/dp/0674979850 Spoiler alert: income from wealth is on its way of becoming close to being as concentrated as it was in the 19th century (especially in the US), and the share of income from work in total national income is decreasing almost anywhere. So yes, increasingly you can only accrue significant wealth by already having significant wealth.
- isoskeles 7y agoBecause you're using data that doesn't control for occupation, hours worked, etc.
- nennes 7y agoSo as a gender, women choose lower paid jobs and work less? If this is true and it is a choice, that would mean that women as a gender are either lazy or less qualified. If this is not true then it is evidence of inequality in the selection of employees. I don't see either of the above making your point.
- isoskeles 7y ago> lazy or less qualified No one is saying that, it's more of a strawman you want to use to, I'm not sure, maybe accuse people who disagree with you of sexism. Or could you explain why you use those words rather than assume we think it's, let's suppose, just a choice based on differences in average values men and women have?
- nennes 7y agoMy argument is that -as a society- we don't really accept that women are facing tons of difficulties that men don't experience, because of their sex. For example, sometimes it's because they might choose to have a baby in the future and a lot of employers don't want to have that risk, so they avoid hiring women after say 25. I'm not saying that you're sexist, I'm saying that as a society we're comfortable saying that people who have less deserve it for some reason and we have more for just reasons. If we accept that the society is unfair, and part of why we're better off than others is either luck of because the game is rigged (ie rich parents), we'll be more generous and fair. Apologies if I insulted people, I was trying to make a point for generosity and I got carried away.
- rstupek 7y agoAnd as a society we need to understand that men are facing tons of difficulties women don't face too? Why are men killing themselves at a rate 4-5 times higher than women in the western world? Why is the life expectancy of a male always less than a female?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dleslie 7y agoWe've built civilization around the notion that escaping the natural order of things is desirable. I, for one, am happy to not be sleeping in shifts in order to stand guard against predation.
- mgolawala 7y agoUp until recently the natural human condition also involved going through the grief of losing at least one of your kids. https://ourworldindata.org/parents-losing-their-child https://ourworldindata.org/parents-losing-their-child The human condition evolves. Having said that, while I am supportive of UBI, I share your concerns over its impact on society. We do not understand the all what the knock on effects of such a program are. How it would be used/misused and how it would reshape incentives. We definitely need to dip our toe in the water before considering jumping in.
- hooande 7y agoNo person who was born rich has to learn skills to avoid destitution. And poverty isn't the natural condition for humans any more than it is for cats, or any other animal.
- captainredbeard 7y agoNot true.
- tenpies 7y ago> No person who was born rich has to learn skills to avoid destitution. I can only speak for the Western tradition, but for most of history, the wealthy took great pride in making sure their male children were at least trained in soldiering, knew the family business, and were well-educated. It was the bare minimum to be considered a gentleman.
- munk-a 7y agoAnd, if that child flubbed all those skills, then they'd skill live a comfortable and rich life, there just might not be much left for the next generation. Also, how is learning how to fence a good skill to avoid destitution? The rich had leisure time and invested that time in cultural skills, this isn't actually a bad thing either - it's my hope that everyone can afford to develop a hobby and be creative in their life... but that has nothing to do with avoiding destitution.
- easytiger 7y agoYea sure. No one ever blew a fortune
- MadWombat 7y ago> People should fear being destitute its the natural human condition. People should die of diseases, its the natural human condition. Women should die in childbirth, its the natural human condition. Men should die in wars, its the natural human condition. People should be hunted by sabre-tooth tigers, its the natural human condition.
- sabarn01 7y agoFear of failure is a useful social motivator. In rich societies that does't have to mean biological poverty. When I lived in a urban poor neighborhood I had one neighbor who drove a asphalt truck while the other was on benefits and drank on the porch all day. As an external observer there was little material difference in their standard of living.
- mhalle 7y agoThere are countless socially beneficial personal activities that aren't centric around wealth. Start with a list of things people volunteer to do. Then add jobs like teaching, nursing, health care aides, and social work that positively impact the lives of many but in many places pay extremely little. People are called to these jobs for reasons outside of wealth. UBI allows these people to continue to serve the rest of society in a sustainable way.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoDoes that mean you would support a 100% inheritance tax and say, confiscating all of someone's wealth every few years?
- sabarn01 7y agoI think a true meritocracy is only possible using some type of agoge system, but that also violates human rights. When I say destitution I guess I mean to the acceptable minimum which that most people would find unacceptable.
- econcon 7y agoThere will be workaround: You can't confiscate social capital or favours someone's parent did to someone as "young adult" then that young adult did it to these parents kid and barter continues.
- cortesoft 7y agoDying young from curable diseases is also the natural human condition... should we not use antibiotics?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- munk-a 7y agoSorry, can you clarify what lesson people who never were given a chance at an education should be learning? Maybe, instead of getting all social darwinist, we could actually take stock in the fact that we have enough that we can afford to share with those less well off than ourselves.
- luckylion 7y ago> From my personal point of view, basic income SHOULD disincentivise work; it's a boost for society, health, well-being, children, etc. Somebody has to do the work though, until robots do everything (and then declare war on us), you need somebody to take away the garbage, pick the fruits and unclog the toilets. Disincentivizing work doesn't make that go away, it just means you'll put that load on fewer shoulders.
- bena 7y agoThank you. That's the part of automation that no one wants to discuss. What happens when we're like 90% automated and there simply isn't enough jobs for everyone. Who do we force to work and is that ethical?
- I-M-S 7y agoloa_in_ just answered that question for you
- bena 7y agoNo, they didn't. "Pay more" is meaningless when most of what you want is provided for you. What are you going to use that money for? For some godawful reason people think near to full automation is going to look exactly like today, but without driving or something. It's not. It's going to look radically different. It will be unprecedented. It's very naive to believe the current methods of incentives will work for a society that doesn't need them.
- c22 7y agoI don't know who we can force to do the work for us, but if my toilet's backing up, the garbage is overflowing, and my back yard is filled with rotting fruit I guess I'd do those jobs.
- loa_in_ 7y agoBut lack of personnel to do jobs would bump the wages due to demand and that would quickly find people ready to fill them in
- Ericson2314 7y agoYes! If you all aren't destitute and your parents never worked, your family has time to accrue lots of social capital, which incidentally is extremely economically valuable in this weird age.
- ChrisLomont 7y ago> basic income SHOULD disincentivise work; it's a boost for society, health, well-being, children, etc Less work means less is produced, so society as a whole becomes poorer. There's simply less goods. Less produced also shrinks the tax base, so tax rates must be raised to continue to pay for the basic income. Higher taxes would then dissuade more people from working, or leading them also to work less. Now there's more people wanting basic income, so more needs raised...... Sure free money gives some people nicer lives, but in this case it is not free - it is taken from other people. Maybe instead of calling it basic income, call it "larger tax transfers for those not needing it as much as current tax transfer systems."
- stuartaxelowen 7y agoIs care of a sick family member "produced" in the same sense?
- neves 7y agoA stay at home parent education children "produces" anything?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Less produced also shrinks the tax base, so tax rates must be raised to continue to pay for the basic income. Higher taxes would then dissuade more people from working, or leading them also to work less. Now there's more people wanting basic income, so more needs raised...... This works the opposite of that. Everyone always gets the basic income, so there is no "more people wanting", but if the tax base was hypothetically reduced then less revenue would be generated to fund the UBI. At a lower UBI amount, more people would work. It's self-balancing.
- ChrisLomont 7y ago>This works the opposite of that. Everyone always gets the basic income, so there is no "more people wanting" ????? Less time worked correlates with less things made. Less things made means less sales. Less sales means less sales tax. Less people working means less income. Less income means less income tax.... Sure this doesn't shrink the tax base? After all, when a few percent of people are put out of work during a recession, there are severe tax revenue issues. Basic income experiments so far show that 10% of people simply drop out of the workforce..... >if the tax base was hypothetically reduced then less revenue would be generated to fund the UBI. At a lower UBI amount, more people would work. It's self-balancing. So your UBI pays people a fixed percent of the tax base, not a dollar amount? So during a recession, those UBI people will get really screwed....
- richardlblair 7y agoThis is especially true where the trial was run. Those places are in a bad spot and three isn't much to lift them up. > I'm happily paying taxes because other people paying taxes put me through college and into my current job Me too. I came up very poor, but access to a good education allowed me to learn how to code at 16... We need to raise these people up. We are paying the taxes to support it, we just need a government who doesn't misappropriate funds.
- free652 7y agoNo, you wouldn't pay for basic income from your taxes. Where did you get that? It's an extra tax that you are currently not paying.
- undersuit 7y agoYeah, taxes.
- Dansvidania 7y agoI think what he meant was "we already have enough tax-funded government income for it, but it is squandered elsewhere".
- CydeWeys 7y agoThis is simply not true. Giving every person the oft-quoted $1k/month would cost over $4T/year, which is more than the entire current tax revenue of the United States. So we'd need to more than double tax revenue to continue doing everything we are now plus pay the UBI.
- Griffinsauce 7y agoIt removes a shit load of misc. other benefits and all the bureaucracy needed to maintain them. That might not cancel out but it's not purely extra costs.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThose other benefits combined don't come remotely close to $4T. I'd be curious to see which benefits you think could be eliminated or cut back and how much that would save.
- refurb 7y agoThe logic of it is that you could increase taxes to pay for it and above a certain income level, 100% (or more) of it would be clawed back in taxes.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoI agree. Letting workers leave abusive employment situations is a benefit of UBI. UBI might even totally reorient the idea of work in that now an employer has the incentive to keep workers happy that must be balanced with the profit incentive.
- zazaalaza 7y agoUBI would reorient the idea of work in the sense that new generations won't think about work the way we do, for them it will be something that you can do, not something you have to do. Similarly how sport is today, you can do sports but you don't have to. Also with UBI you are guaranteed a certain amount of income for the duration of your life. You can go to a bank and take a loan against your UBI. A big portion of the UBI will end up at the banks because basically the loans are guaranteed by the government.
- spullara 7y agoI think they would have to make it illegal to borrow against your UBI to create a true safety net.
- Ericson2314 7y agoHmm, like dual of bank minimum reserve.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoWouldn't it just work to make it illegal to attach UBI for non-payment of loans. Then UBI would cease to work as collateral.
- danans 7y ago> You can go to a bank and take a loan against your UBI. Basically a government subsidy for loans. Trying to figure out how this would work. Presumably a bank would only lend a portion of the UBI to you
- refurb 7y agoOk, but work (productivity) is how you actually pay for UBI. So by giving UBI, you are decreasing the resources that pay for it.
- coffeecat 7y agoGive people money, and most of it will get spent. That spending is income for someone, and that income is taxed. I don't understand this argument.
- adwn 7y ago> Give people money, and most of it will get spent. That spending is income for someone, and that income is taxed. I don't understand this argument. You can't eat money, nor can money cut your hair. refurb's point is that a UBI leads to a decrease in wealth, not in the amount of money in existence.
- coffeecat 7y agoIt will lead to a new equilibrium for sure. Whether that equilibrium is more wealth than currently exists (due to the additional buying power in consumers' hands) or less wealth (due to increasing cost of labor), I don't claim to know. But in the latter case, this decrease in total wealth would be a result of a collective decision that we value our time more than unnecessary material shit. A leaner workforce would have the incentive of higher wages. So in either case (an increase or decrease in total wealth), I'd argue that we're better off for it.
- pixelbash 7y agoWith increasing automation less people can do more work and therefore earn more money, this is already causing some of the unemployment issues we see today.
- munk-a 7y agoWe currently have intense income inequality in the world - pretty sure we can shave some off the top and the middle to help everyone live a healthier life.
- kube-system 7y agoExactly. Too many people think about the relationship between employment, productivity, and prosperity way too linearly. The biggest problem is that we don't really have a good way to measure the value of free time or well-being. While someone could spend every penny of a minimum wage job on daycare services and it would boost productivity figures, it would be a pretty silly decision for someone to make in terms of actual prosperity. Society has decided for a long time to continue working the same or more hours as productivity rises, but at what point does it make more sense in terms of prosperity to cash out some of that productivity in the form of free-time rather than dollars?
- biql 7y agoNot necessarily if you account for the fact that people's expenses increase as soon as their income increase. Before UBI, they might want certain type of hobbies, a certain type of house, etc, and after UBI the same people might want more expensive hobbies, a bigger house, and so on. Even without UBI, many could choose less demanding jobs with more free time, lower salaries, and in less expensive cities, but they don't.