6 ms·
I see a lot of panicky comments, both in real life and in this very thread. I know COVID19 is different from a regular flu, but is it more serious? "Regular" f
by the_af 7y ago
I see a lot of panicky comments, both in real life and in this very thread.
I know COVID19 is different from a regular flu, but is it more serious? "Regular" flu is very contagious and kills lots of people every year. It's ok to study coronavirus and to try to find ways to effectively manage it, combat it or prevent the disease -- but why are we panicking? Nobody panics about the flu and it's proven to be fatal for a lot of people every year. Why the panic with coronavirus, why are people in this very thread worrying about "the death toll"? Is there any projection that the death toll is going to be higher than usual for a flu?
For what it's worth, my doctor told me "it's like a flu, don't worry". A doctor friend of mine told me the same.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAnecdotal reporting is useless. Read some more, and stop spreading false sense of security. That could actually get somebody killed.
- the_af 7y agoNot sure if you're accusing me of something, but just in case: I'm not spreading a false sense of security. I do think prophylaxis and management of the disease is urgent. I think the same of the flu. People at risk tend to die from these diseases. I think health systems of every country should deal with the infection, as well as manage seasonal flu. If anything, I'm asking why people worry more about this than about regular flu, when we know the flu can be deadly. I'm asking for data, projections, etc. Do we know it's more serious? If so, the data is welcome. As usual, judging by the media, coronavirus is the apocalypsis and journalists are playing this up for all it's worth. Some people already told me the measured death rate is already higher than regular flu. That's data I can understand. I'd like to know how this compares with initial death rate of any new type of flu, before it stabilizes itself.
- chrisco255 7y agoGood stats on number of cases, deaths, recoveries etc: https://thewuhanvirus.com/ https://thewuhanvirus.com/ Comparisons to H1N1 and SARS included.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pavelrub 7y ago1. It is both more contagious and lethal than flu. There were estimates that 40% to 70% of the world population will eventually get infected. Depending on how the world responds to this - millions might die. 2. This isn't flu. The same amount of people will die from flu this year as last year. COVID-19 deaths are additional deaths on top of that. Saying that we shouldn't worry about it because every year many of people die of flu, is like saying that we shouldn't make a big deal of the 2004 Indian tsunami because many people die of drowning anyway.
- the_af 7y agoTo be clear, I'm not saying we shouldn't worry. We should worry about the flu too. And if COVID19 is more dangerous, we should definitely look into it. I'm just questioning the panic-mongering. We should be scientific about this, not panic like those guys in the media.
- sachdevap 7y agoThe death rate of COVID-19 is at about 3.4% on average. In comparison, the death rate of seasonal flu is about 0.1% in the US. No, it is not "like" the flu. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/03/who-says-coronavirus-death-rate-is-3point4percent-globally-higher-than-previously-thought.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/03/who-says-coronavirus-death-r...
- kfarr 7y agoTo be clear, the article says "Globally, about 3.4% of reported COVID-19 cases have died." The issue is with reporting (the denominator). The bar for "reporting" COVID-19 positive is very high relative to the flu, especially as some countries (ahem USA) don't / didn't even permit testing of all symptomatic patients. So yes maybe it is orders of magnitude more deadly than the flu but it doesn't seem clear at all that we have sufficient information to say that it is 3.4%
- makomk 7y agoNot just the US. Crucially, Wuhan and I think also the rest of Hubei pretty much only tested patients who showed lung abnormalities on CT scans, so only the more severe cases were diagnosed. The WHO knows this. In fact, they've been appearing in the pages of the New York Times and anywhere else that'll have them and gushing about how great this Chinese testing methodology is and how everyone should copy it.
- fspeech 7y agoThey test much more widely but only those with pneumonia are counted as confirmed. But this is a viral pneumonia. So the undercounting is not that much.
- username90 7y agoIt was 1% in diamond princess, and cruises are known to be full of retirees so it should be a lot lower than that in the general population. I believe the reason it looks so high is severe lack of testing.
- chrisco255 7y agoIt's 1-2 orders of magnitude more deadly than the flu. Some estimates are between 2 and 4% fatality rate for the Covid-19. Flu is 0.1%. That fatality rate average masks that it is far deadlier for the elderly and high risk patients, with as much as 10-20% fatality rate for that demographic.
- the_af 7y agoThanks for the reply. What is the fatality rate among the elderly and high risk patients for seasonal flu? (say, in the US if there are no worldwide statistics). I understand the real problem with any flu-like disease is precisely with the elderly and high risk patients. Usually, of course there are always cases of healthy people who die from a flu.
- eric-hu 7y agohttps://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-age-sex-demographics/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-age-se... These are worldwide statistics. Breakdown is by age, but I don't recall if there's other categories.
- tomtheelder 7y agoSomewhere around 1%. The 10x multiplier on fatality rate seems to be fairly consistent across age groups. Note that the CFR for this virus is still largely unknown, and is vastly different in different regions. https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2018-2019.html https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2018-2019.html
- anthonypasq 7y agoyou are getting that number by dividing reported infections by reported deaths. The reported infections number is not accurate. Its a major underestimate of the actual number of infected
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shawabawa3 7y agoSpanish flu was also "just a flu" and killed between 17 and 50million people world wide Covid19 is more contagious and more deadly than "regular flu"
- the_af 7y agoBut that's what I'm saying. The flu is already a serious deal and nobody panics. In any case, surely there are some differences between the 1918 world of the Spanish flu and the current world, both in actual medicine and what we learned about how to manage contagious diseases? Maybe the Spanish flu today (I mean, if it started today and hadn't happened before) wouldn't have as many victims.
- cygx 7y agoOn the flip side, we're traveling farther in greater numbers than in 1918.
- anthonypasq 7y ago1918 was the height of ww1 btw.
- ibejoeb 7y agoApparently it's quite a bit more infectious. This coronavirus is something like 1:2.5, whereas the typical flu is about 1:1. People do worry about the flu, too. This past flu season in Australia was particularly rough, and it was all over the media. It came up in day-to-day conversation. Part of the reaction is political, too, ostensibly to appear to be actively doing something, e.g., Los Angeles declaring an emergency for 9 infections.
- lenzm 7y agoSeasonal flu has an R0 value of ~1.2 [1] while the estimate for COVID-19 was estimated at 2.2 [2]. This can be interpreted as each person infecting 2.2 other people vs. 1.2, the spread of the virus will probably be exponentially faster. 1: https://bmcinfectdis.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1471-2334-14-480 https://bmcinfectdis.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1471... 2: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32097725 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32097725
- mrb 7y agoThe coronavirus is a magnitude deadlier than the flu, according to all studies I know of that attempt to estimate the Infection Fatality Ratio. The IFR is estimated between 0.5% and 1.6% which is between 5x and 16x deadlier than the flu (0.1%): see links to the 4 studies at https://blog.zorinaq.com/case-fatality-ratio-ncov/#updates--validation https://blog.zorinaq.com/case-fatality-ratio-ncov/#updates--... Given that the flu kills half a million per year, I'll let you image how many could be killed by a disease a magnitude deadlier... But of course the death toll will depend on how the world reacts to the outbreak. If every country implements measures as severe as China by locking down most major cities worldwide, we may limit damages. Incidentally, the upper end of this range makes COVID19 comparable to the 1918 Spanish Flu (IFR ~2%) according to experts (for example see https://institutefordiseasemodeling.github.io/nCoV-public/analyses/first_adjusted_mortality_estimates_and_risk_assessment/2019-nCoV-preliminary_age_and_time_adjusted_mortality_rates_and_pandemic_risk_assessment.html https://institutefordiseasemodeling.github.io/nCoV-public/an...). And keep in mind the IFR, unlike the CFR (Case Fatility Ratio), is the metric that takes into account undetected mild or asymptomatic cases.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoThe real danger here is that far fewer people will have immunity to this because it is novel. This means that if we aren't careful the infections could snowball and serious cases could overwhelm healthcare infrastructure. This would lead to the tragedy of people dying not just because they were basically bound to but because there wasn't enough care to go around. 1,000,000 people infected over 3 months looks a lot different than 1,000,000 people infected over 18 months.
- lima 7y agoAvailable data points to it being more dangerous than the flu, especially to the elderly and immunocompromised. Your doctor might have been talking about the danger to you in particular, which is very low, similar to the flu, if you're young and healthy.
- jennyyang 7y agoA single individual getting coronavirus isn't a big deal. Chances are they will be fine. The problem is that it's very infectious, R0 could be 6+ where the flu is about 1-2. That means it's 3-6 times more contagious than the flu, so it spreads very very quickly. At the same time, it causes severe symptoms in 15-20% of cases. When these people have access to medical care, they will likely survive. But if they don't get access to timely health care, they might die, which is what happened in China. The problem with both the above is that you will get many, many people infected all at the same time, and you might get a few hundred people with severe symptoms in a small city. That's enough to overrun several hospitals all at the same time. The US has about 2.5 hospital beds for 10,000 citizens, which is 31st in the world. Japan and Korea have over 12 per 10,000 citizens. the top 2 in the world. And the patients that get severe need ventilators which are even less than this. Once the hospital beds are filled, people start dying, which causes panic. Then economies will start to suffer because no one will eat at restaurants, people will panic at Costco like we've seen, businesses will go out of business. People forget that this is simple math. Coronavirus will spread very quickly in the US and across the world. And many people will die and all hospitals will get overrun. What we need is at-home treatment and to somehow get people to avoid getting severe symptoms. If warm summer weather decreases the R0, then we might be able to avoid it, but some parts of the Northern Hemisphere are still in winter and won't be warm for at least 2 months.
- hackeer 7y agowhere are you getting the info to say only 15-20% percent of the cases show symptoms?
- asdfman123 7y agoI believe reading that 14% of cases are severe, so it sounds roughly accurate. I think a lot more show symptoms, though, even if they're mild.
- jennyyang 7y ago15-20% show severe symptoms, not just "symptoms". 80%+ show mild symptoms or are asymptomatic.
- Slartie 7y agoSomething to consider: even if it was "just like a flu" (which it isn't, enough commenters already pointed out the differences, but let's just for the sake of my argument assume that it was), it is a matter of fact that this would then be a "second flu" going around at a time at which doctors and hospitals are already well-loaded with caring for patients that have more serious trouble with the "real flu" that happens to be at the peak of its activity just at the same time. The "real flu" is relatively non-deadly for most people (even though it still kills a lot of people in absolute numbers) precisely because the healthcare system is capable of providing care to those requiring it because of the flu. It can do this because the flu is a relatively well-understood phenomenon, it comes every year, and although the exact mutations of the virus differ between the years, the overall characteristics of the outbreak are relatively well-known in advance. There are also vaccines against the flu (these are a big thing in allowing the personnel in the healthcare sector to do their work, which of course exposes them to flu patients) and there is medication available that's able to quicken the recovery. Nevertheless, the flu still puts a lot of strain on the system, and having a "second flu" of entirely unknown characteristics going around, possibly even infecting the same patients, for which there is no vaccination and no medication at all is not exactly a thing to take light-hearted. I would not be surprised at all if the "real flu" would later be found to be much more deadly this year than in the years before, not because the virus was any different than before, but because the additional strain due to COVID-19 negatively impacted care for flu patients.
- the_af 7y agoThanks. The overloading of the healthcare system, which you and others mentioned, is something I had not considered. It makes sense that two flu-like[1] virulent diseases at the same time can overload it and that it would be a very serious matter. I still think panicking is not the answer, but I'm now convinced it's a more serious matter than I first thought. [1] for the sake of argument, even if coronavirus is not actually similar to any flu strand. I'm not a specialist and I cannot tell the actual differences.