3 ms·
Engineering has a long tradition of trial and error. That is how the field of architecture got its current knowledge that currently probably focuses more on mat
by raxxorrax 7y ago
Engineering has a long tradition of trial and error. That is how the field of architecture got its current knowledge that currently probably focuses more on material research.
I don't see how software is different. We try new patterns, languages, deployment techniques and think about the optimal way to store data with specific operations in mind. And here you cannot just do anything if you want to solve a problem efficiently.
If we find better practices or more use cases, the environment becomes more restricted. We already have quite a few constrains for a relatively young field because there are many developers.
On the contrary I believe engineering to be a creative process. Of course lacking constrains might make it seem unfocused, but I still call that engineering.
- atoav 7y ago> Engineering has a long tradition of trial and error. That is how the field of architecture got its current knowledge that currently probably focuses more on material research. Imagine you are building a cathedral and every month the material you use changes to something that behaves totally different. While there is knowledge you can extract even when the material you work with and the fundament you work on seems to change every time, we live in a world that has given up to build systems that last. In times where deploying a patch meant sending out CDs, software that didn't have to do that was quality software. Nowadays that feeling has flipped: if software doesn't offer updates at least once a month people feel like there is something wrong with it. To me it feels like we collectively gave up on building things that last in software.
- WalterBright 7y agoThe grand cathedrals in Europe do sort of last, but not without continuing efforts to keep them from collapsing. Nearly everyone I've looked at had centuries of reinforcement of various kinds added.
- floriol 7y agoStrangely, I am on the opposite site - that programming is more of a subset of mathematics (or at least should be) than engineering and since theoretically many parts of the program can be inferred without running, trial and error should not be as acceptable as it is (I don't mean it on a small scale like I do feel sometimes all I do is try different word combinations until the compiler is happy :D).