6 ms·
I swung by the Atrium booth at the Startup Grind conference a few weeks ago. A former lawyer, I was curious to hear their pitch. It was basically: we get you ch
by gnicholas 7y ago
I swung by the Atrium booth at the Startup Grind conference a few weeks ago. A former lawyer, I was curious to hear their pitch. It was basically: we get you cheap lawyers, and we help them find new clients.
I asked if all of their lawyers are based in the US, and they couldn't give me a straight answer. Eventually, when I said "well, of course they must all be US-licensed lawyers, right?" they said "oh, yeah, they must all be in the US then."
It was not a confidence-inspiring conversation, and I can't say I'm surprised that they're shutting down.
- taneq 7y agoSo it was basically Craigslist for lawyers?
- Gorbzel 7y agoPut another way, it was doomed (good riddance). I've mentored aspiring entrepreneurs in the legal tech + services space for a number of years now and go out of my way to provide additional guidance (and some well intentioned ribbing) to those who pitch any sort of legal referral idea. The concepts are (without fail) derivative and lack novelty, equivalent to pitching "Uber rideshare, but for [INDUSTRY]" without more to sophisticated VCs. The problem is very real, but the margins are so thin that venture shouldn't be anywhere near it. Solutions should be non-profit and left to those heroes in the A2J space (whose funding should be significantly increased).
- eganist 7y agoLegal is a notoriously sluggish industry, one that's almost infuriatingly incapable of adopting change and technology. Atrium's original pitch was exactly the opposite of what most legal teams are used to interacting with, and I can't think of a single biglaw attorney (sorry for the anecdote) who had faith in the idea or its execution. The original concept, as a reminder: https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/10/atrium-legal/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/10/atrium-legal/ Now it's easy to say that this should've been obvious in hindsight. (Should've been obvious to me, anyway; I cold-mailed Justin and Nick years ago looking to build a specific function within Atrium to address concerns I'd heard on background about the service offering; I never did hear anything back about that.) But that said, I can't help but think the original pitch by Atrium was just too bitter a pill for the most conservative industry in the United States to swallow. Shoot, lawyers are bizarrely resistant to moving to e.g. Signal to preserve attorney-client privilege; given this, I have a hard time thinking of many who would trust ML models with understanding case-law.
- paultopia 7y agoThe other thing about the original vision is that it isn't even remotely clear what the hell they're doing. Are we really talk about having ML models understand caselaw? (In which case, thompson reuters is going to be way ahead anyway always, and they suck, see, e.g., the horror that is the latest version of westlaw.) Or are they talking about building a bunch of efficiency tools? I feel like the latter model could have worked as a law firm doing the latter. Like, an actual, ordinary, perfectly milquetoast, law firm, hourly billing and all, except with an R&D division that tries to build workflow efficiencies and uses them to compete on hourly rate. Which, come to think of it, isn't that just what Dentons is doing? So maybe it's just American lawyers that are hopelessly hidebound.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIt sounds as it wasn't remotely clear to them what the hell they were doing. "Disrupt all the law things!" was always a very vague pitch. I suspect this was really a tribal play. The real plan wasn't automation, it was to pitch the company as a specialised law firm for techpreneurs that had recognisable tribal tech features - less of the "them" that tech people feel around lawyers, and more of the "us." The problem with law is that you need the "them" parts to be at least competitive with the rest of the industry, on its own terms. Not only did that not happen, but the "us" parts made no real difference.
- gnicholas 7y agoPart of the reason law firms are resistant to technological change is that they are paid hourly (for the most part) and therefore do not yearn for efficiencies. If it increases efficiency, they will literally lose money in hourly billings.
- eganist 7y agoWell if you think about it, the original concept behind Atrium was to kill a business model. Kinda difficult to effectively pay lawyers to shoot their own feet.
- optimiz3 7y agoThe most expensive lawyer is one the one that loses. Going cheap on legal representation is not great business advice.
- gnicholas 7y agoI'm not sure what your first sentence means, but you're absolutely right that some GCs go with expensive outside counsel precisely because they're expensive. If it's a legal matter that's critical for the company, the GC can get blamed for going with a cut-rate firm, but not for going with a firm that's 'too expensive'.
- optimiz3 7y agoIt's a lawyer joke. They saying goes that if you win your case, it's worth every penny.
- gnicholas 7y agoNot sure why the downvotes. There is literally a saying in law: "nobody ever got fired for hiring Skadden". If you think this is ridiculous, don't shoot the messenger. And if you disagree that GCs hire blue-chip firms partly for CYA, please share your experience!
- gumby 7y agoAlso they could have hired lawyers with US law degrees who passed various US bars but who live in India. Doesn't sound like whoever was at the both had the faintest idea of what was going on. That's how radiologists could analyze x-rays and such remotely: they were actual US-trained radiologists with licenses in US states who preferred to go home to India.
- gnicholas 7y agoTrue, and I actually considered possibilities like this. But it would be pretty difficult/expensive/time-consuming for people to come to the US, go to law school, study for and pass the bar, and then go back to a low-cost-of-living place to practice law. In most states, you have to go to an accredited law school in order to even sit for the bar, and all of such law schools are located in the US (and charge commensurately-priced tuition). I believe there are ways around this in medicine because you can go to medical school elsewhere and then sit for boards in the US. Even if you have a foreign law degree, you still have to get a 1-year LLM ($60k) in order to sit for the bar.
- gumby 7y agoGuessing they’d be mainly those that attended the lowest tier of accredited law school on an H-1 and then couldn’t find gainful employment here. OTOH, after sept 11 my cousin (or, I think, his wife) decided they didn’t want to raise kids in NY so he moved back to Mumbai, but kept his job with a major ibank and salary, just working mostly remotely. I suspect though he’s an exception.