20 ms·
>to me, an affordable health insurance plan would be between $50-$100 a month. Fat chance of that happening. And if it did, the deductible would be so high as
by Groxx 16y ago
>to me, an affordable health insurance plan would be between $50-$100 a month.
Fat chance of that happening. And if it did, the deductible would be so high as to make the plan worthless for anything short of a car-crash-emergency-type-situation.
This fits a fair number of cost complaints I hear over healthcare. Who wouldn't like to pay $50-100/month to have something better than emergency healthcare support? But think about the costs of such a system, regardless of inefficiencies / the problems of the current system that make things cost hundreds of thousands:
Doctors and nurses and supporting staff must exist. So must hospitals. They are highly trained, and will be expensive - period. They also have to keep learning, so they can't be busy making money all the time. And they must have such people available all the time, or people die.
Given that, and the equipment and check-up and hospital time, how much should a minor surgery cost? Not in cost to you, in cost. If the cost to you is mitigated in any way, it's extracted another way (taxes). I'd have trouble seeing it cost less than a few thousand dollars in the best, highly-used system. That's a lot of training and a lot of supporting necessities for any random surgery.
At $50-100/month, they would have to sap you for nearly a decade to make up a single surgery. It might even out for the insurance company if that was it - but certainly not when you get older, and not with any kind of routine, preventative care. Scale that up to emergency situations where major surgery and years of rehab for even 0.1% of the people they're covering - how many hundreds of years does that cost everyone on the plan?
Cataclysmic health insurance is cheap because it only covers cataclysms. Because one in a hundred lives cost an utterly enormous amount more than a single person generates.
---
None of this is to say that I think the healthcare system is efficient by any means, nor not full of corruption, waste, frivolous lawsuits, or damaging dogma. Merely that there is simply a bottom limit that the prices that people want to pay will never be able to support, unless all cataclysmic protection is dropped. And would you rather die from a car crash, or be rehab'd for a couple years and continue your life for another 60 years? So people choose the cataclysmic protection, and prices jump.
---
edit: because this seems it will come up often, some evidence for my claim based on Canada's setup, copied from another comment I made below: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Canada http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Canada
>In 2009, the government funded about 70% of Canadians' health care costs.
>Per capita expenditure in 2009: 3,895
$227 per month, per person, comes from the government, which means it comes from taxes. And an additional $100 per person is spent per month on average ($324.58 per month). Far in excess of $50-$100.
- muhfuhkuh 16y agoJapan forces their doctors to charge only what's published in a book that the government issues and negotiates prices periodically. Simple price fixing in an otherwise private healthcare market. In return, Japanese doctors and hospitals (FYI, there are more private hospitals in Japan than the US) are allowed to set whatever prices for ancillary services (like private or semi-private rooms) that they want. BTW, the average stay overnight in a private room at a Japanese hospital is about $100. An MRI (which was 1400 negotiated down to 700 FTA) is $98, due largely to the fact that the Japanese have more MRIs and CT scanners per capita than the US. I mean, wasn't technology supposed to be our superiority play? And, if you want to talk care and outcomes, let's pick the most grim of diagnostics: Cancer. Japan's 5-year survival rates are among the highest in the world, and the highest in particular cancers such as colon and rectal cancer. And, FYI, the US isn't #1 in survival rates for all cancers. It's spread evenly through the G8. And, the most free of supposed free markets and tax-friendly wonderlands, Singapore, also puts price controls on procedures, with similarly successful outcomes. So it isn't a cultural or "economic" thing, it's a government thing. It always will be. An adult just needs to come in, put their foot down similar to what Tommy Douglas did in Canada, and declare either we all buy in to a government-run healthcare system, or we buy in to the government completely regulating the market much like it does the stock market or agricultural industry. States will have no say, no quarter, or feedback. They can choose to secede from the union to opt-out of the program. And, while I love me some comment karma, I know that my position is tantamount to heresy on this board, so, get your dismissive hand cocked and ready to wave me away :D
- Groxx 16y agoThat's an interesting way to do things, didn't know Japan did that. Thanks for the info! How much do things like emergency services cost? Do they fall under ancillary or not? Anything that's nigh-essential that does? Know if the hospitals are supported by the government, and how much taxes it takes?
- muhfuhkuh 16y agoFor most insurance, patients pay 30% copay maximum for any procedure (emergency or standard), but the minimum monthly payment (yes, it's not due all at once, which I think should also be legislated here in the States) is capped according to income. Hospitals are private, and both they and doctors negotiate every two years to set prices for everything from MRIs to stitches. The insurance industry is also private, but they have a public-run insurer for Japanese poor. AFAIK, taxes are taken just for the public-run insurance, to which only a small percentage of Japanese apply, but for private insurance (which the rest are mandated to have), it's paid through premiums per month, which is on average about $250/mo per family (and employers pay for almost all of that).