5 ms·
I can understand why people want refunds (it's not their fault), but also understand why SXSW may find it financially impossible to cancel (it's not their fault
by crazygringo 7y ago
I can understand why people want refunds (it's not their fault), but also understand why SXSW may find it financially impossible to cancel (it's not their fault either).
To be honest, this is the type of call that ought to be made by governments, not individually by private citizens/organizations. Either all conferences nationwide should be cancelled, or none, but that's not a decision any can make individually.
If this is a national emergency, let's take national responsibility and share the burden nationally. Have the government shut down conferences, if that's the right call, and use tax dollars to reimburse the conference organizers to a reasonable level, that they are also forced to use to reimburse attendees to a reasonable level.
Really, how is this any different from flooding or hurricane damage that gets federal money to rebuild? A national emergency is a national emergency, period.
- lgats 7y agoReally shouldn't conferences be paying for insurance against X?
- crazygringo 7y agoYes but this kind of thing generally falls under "act of god" which you simply cannot buy insurance against. Now I'd be curious to see SXSW's actual insurance policy, but honestly I don't believe there's anything available they could possibly have done to protect against this.
- mongol 7y agoForce majeure. If that would not be in insurance agreements then every insurance company in the world could go broke in case of a pandemic.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ipnon 7y agoThe problem with this type of call being made by governments, which I hope will become abundantly clear in retrospect, is that governments are incentivized to lie about the severity of the situation (consider CCP response to Wuhan, White House response to unsafe quarantines, etc.).
- Seenso 7y ago> The problem with this type of call being made by governments, which I hope will become abundantly clear in retrospect, is that governments are incentivized to lie about the severity of the situation (consider CCP response to Wuhan, White House response to unsafe quarantines, etc.). No. "[G]overnments" aren't "incentivized to lie about the severity of the situation" any more than anyone is incentivized to lie about anything. It's true that some governments and some government officials are in the habit of blatantly lying, but that shouldn't be turned into some kind of anti-government generalization. Pretty much all the accurate information and advice we currently have about this outbreak comes from governments as well.
- claudeganon 7y agoThe government has already shown itself to be wildly irresponsible with regard to testing, allowing community transmission to take place with little hope for contract tracing and effective quarantines, leaving six dead in Seattle. They should absolutely get their shit together, but we can’t all just wash our hands of our collective responsibility to each other until they do. Adopting their bumbling as a “wait and see” response is just another form of denialism that will cost lives. I’m glad that some companies and events have had enough sanity and courage to respond proactively.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- myself248 7y agoThe sane way to do this would be to let everyone take a slight hit. Some money has already been spent, so full refunds aren't possible nor are they reasonable -- doing so would leave the organizers in the lurch and torpedo any hopes of a future event when this all blows over. But keeping all the money for a non-event wouldn't be right either. There should be an equitable way to figure out what percentage of the money can be refunded without anyone going bankrupt in the process. The government's role could be to vet that math and declare that it's OK and if attendees get whatever percentage refund, they're done and have no further recourse. Cuz otherwise a cranky con-goer will suck the place dry with legal fees.
- mongol 7y agoI agree with that. This is a pandemic, no benevolence, no one's fault, everyone will be hurt in different ways. There are costs to prepare an event, the venue will want to be paid even if the organizer cancels and so on. Force majeure as it is called in insurance lingo. A full refund is not realistic.
- Proziam 7y agoCalling it a pandemic is giving far more credit than is due at this point. It's essentially only lethal to elderly or immunocompromised people. It would need to kill [0]220x more people than it already has to even be [1]comparable to the flu. The media is making a huge deal about it, when really the situation calls for more handwashing for everyone, and an n95 mask for those who are or may be infected. [0]https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/coronavirus-deaths-china-cases-slow-live-updates-200303003539680.html https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/coronavirus-deaths-ch... [1]https://www.health.com/condition/cold-flu-sinus/how-many-people-die-of-the-flu-every-year https://www.health.com/condition/cold-flu-sinus/how-many-peo...
- mongol 7y agoWe will see. I think it can kill 220x more people than it already has if it continues to spread like it has been doing so far.
- AlchemistCamp 7y agoTax dollars definitely shouldn't be spent bailing out huge, influential tech conferences. If they choose to run at such thin margins they can't survive one tail risk event and have failed to buy appropriate insurance even after a decade of growth, they shouldn't be able to socialize their loses.
- gamblor956 7y agoAlmost all commercial insurance policies exclude pandemics and terrorist acts. Where exactly do you propose they buy this mythical insurance policy that includes pandemic coverage? (On another note, insurance is literally the socialization of losses. It's just a privately run socialization of losses with your fellow policyholders.)
- SilasX 7y agoWhen people complain about socialization of losses, they're talking about socialization across parties that did not consent to bearing those losses, which doesn't cover the privately-run case, so I don't know why you think that comment is applicable.
- grayed-down 7y agoIf I understand correctly, why do you think it's proper for the organizers and attendees of SXSW who would lose money if the event was cancelled, then be compensated for such losses by other individuals who DO NOT consent to bear such responsibility?
- SilasX 7y agoI wasn't taking a position on that, I was addressing the oh-so-clever remark that was trivializing complaints of "socialization of losses" with the argument that "duh, that's what insurance is, what's the problem?".
- grayed-down 7y ago
- robbyt 7y agoThere's insurance for this type of thing, and I'm guessing that the organizers do not have it.
- nikolay 7y agoTrue! Many of the ticketing companies offer insurance in terms the buyer decides to cancel or the event cancels - they still get their money. But it's extra cost, which not everybody is willing to cover!