3 ms·
Careful, the hammer of logic is quite small. It is a mighty but very restricted tool. Cambridge Analytica was made responsible for large scale social media man
by raxxorrax 7y ago
Careful, the hammer of logic is quite small. It is a mighty but very restricted tool.
Cambridge Analytica was made responsible for large scale social media manipulation. I don't think logical positivism lets you confirm this widely believed story. At least not without even identifying the type of manipulation.
What kind of message was employed? Who and how many were targeted? Did it really change the opinions of people and influenced their voting behavior?
These questions were just left unanswered.
Additionally and maybe a completely different angle, but rational society doesn't mean that much.
The criticism in your link seems valid, but I see it can be applied to the behavior described in the original article.
- pjc50 7y agoI think the distinction I was looking for was between statements like "advertising affects behaviour" and "propaganda affects behaviour" which, in the 21st century, are generally considered true and almost obvious even if we can't identify the specific pump handle to remove to stop the cholera epidemic; versus "wifi is beaming images into my brain". Certainly "person X made a political decision based on the information they saw on the TV news and on Facebook, despite that information being either false or grossly misleading" isn't delusional in the same way that "person X made a political decision because the electromagnetic radiation of wifi disrupted their mind" is. (I can sort of see if I squint how they're drawing an analogy between being affected by having images "beamed into your head" via some kind of scifi process and the plain old regular one of having them beamed to some kind of screen then interpreted by your eyes into images which have an effect on your mental and emotional state. But the former is witchcraft and the latter is media studies.) > rational society doesn't mean that much Only if you care about, say, coronavirus, and taking evidence-based interventions like handwashing rather than faith-based or panic-based ones. Edit: someone downthread has provided the name of Bernays that I was thinking of and couldn't remember.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThere certainly is a qualitative difference, I agree. But the societal relevance cannot be derived from the degree or order of irrational thought. Someone believing he is regularly abducted by aliens is perhaps more irrational than someone saying a company distorted and manipulated voters on a large scale. The latter allows you to dismiss a whole plethora of different opinions without effort and it was used for political talking points while the former might summon some smiles from others. On the other hand it is quite rational for people getting angry if they are told they are the victim of propaganda or anything really. And this is where both cases you presented can converge. I think the author of the article was hinting at this. A case where both perpetrator and victims can be dismissed as irrational. > even if we can't identify the specific pump handle I think we often can and it is shocking we use the handle excessively and with glee. We know it for classical advertising at least. Although today there are more empirical approaches because social media allows to conduct various tests. In these cases the handle is indeed yet unknown. >> rational society doesn't mean that much > Only if you care about [..] evidence-based interventions I was thinking more about the self perception as a rational actor. The 18th/19th century had a lot of rationalists and they were instrumental in secularizing societies. But in the end their approaches fell flat somewhat. Some went the way of utilitarianism or egoism because they were lacking answers they thought could be rationally derived. I think the criticism of Kant is on spot here. I don't think that many people would want to live in a purely rational society on that matter, because it would be horrible. But you see it resurfacing a lot. You like the color blue more than red? -> Irrational, your mental state needs fixing... Exaggerated of course.
- jancsika 7y agoThere's one candidate who has spent billions of his own money laying the groundwork for his campaign. He's spent hundreds of millions on both traditional ads and "gray area" social media stuff like paying influencers to post memes. Wouldn't a rational back-and-forth about the efficacy of his spending happen after the election results come in?
- pjc50 7y agoCouldn't we have a postmortem about the previous elections first? People are still happily claiming that the advertising and use of Facebook had no effect.
- atoav 7y agoWouldn't a rational society also deal with likely and possible scenarios? Targeted advertisement in social media is seen as something that works, because someone has a huge interest in convincing someone else that it does (although I wouldn't be surprised if it really works). And if you move conventional targeted ads to the political space you get Cambridge analytica. And a rational society could have multiple problems with this regardless of whether it works. Elections are public for a reason — shouldn't the official party lead advertisement then also be public? I see a strong case of banning targeted personal political ads purely based on that.
- pjc50 7y ago> Wouldn't a rational society also deal with likely and possible scenarios? I have yet to find a good way of phrasing this, but there is the phrase "justified true belief" that captures a whole discussion in philosophy on knowledge. However, that debate only covers the past and present, it can't cover the future. Perhaps what I'm looking for is something like "forward-looking statements" in the SEC sense - statements about the future which are inherently probabilistic, but the statement-maker has a responsibility to be truthful and advance a reasoned argument for their plausibility.
- rjsw 7y agoCambridge Analytica claimed they could do large scale social media manipulation. I care less about what they did than I do about the fact that other people bought what they were selling.