7 ms·
Anyone else think that nearly the entire financial industry is ready to be replaced with a lot of very short shell scripts? It seems to me that their value add
by zdw 16y ago
Anyone else think that nearly the entire financial industry is ready to be replaced with a lot of very short shell scripts?
It seems to me that their value add is negligible compared to how they're rewarded.
- kulkarnic 16y agoIt certainly looks like the industry is run with a bunch of shell scripts. Buddy scripts, of course. [Edit: Or maybe they're "features", not bugs.]
- michaelty 16y agohttp://www.pylaw.org/RegAB.html http://www.pylaw.org/RegAB.html "The Securities and Exchange Commission is proposing two new disclosure requirements for offerings of asset backed securities. See the RevisedRegAB site for details on the proposal."
- JonnieCache 16y agoIt basically is already, except they're all written in VBA/Excel. This goes some way towards explaining the mess we're in IMO.
- jrockway 16y agoWhile over-reliance on Excel spreadsheets does hurt day-to-day operations, it didn't cause the meltdown of the economy. That was caused by either not understanding that certain factors existed, or ignoring them despite what their analytics said. Software can only produce data according to the models that exist, rewriting them in C isn't going to cause someone to have some big insight about how the economy works.
- henryprecheur 16y agoYou should show more respect to what other people do. You're not the only one guilty of this, everybody tend to overestimate their contribution to the world. How many times did you hear/read about a business guy / manager saying that programmers are a disposable commodity? Saying that "the entire financial industry is ready to be replaced with a lot of very short shell scripts", you are acting exactly the same way. Did you forgot about the dot-com bubble when the tech industry was the one guilty of being over-rewarded for what was often was no value (pet.com)?
- acdha 16y agoYour general point is true and worth repeating but that's a very weak example: pets.com and the rest of the bubble companies were overhyped by speculators for business reasons and failed for reasons which have very little to do with the technology which they happened to use. In that particular example, having had some professional interactions with some of their senior web developers makes me inclined to say that they were if anything tech-starved rather than dominated.
- jbooth 16y agoAs stated below, your general point is certainly true.. But what is the financial industry accomplishing today that they didn't accomplish 25 years ago? As far as I can see, the most useful innovation has been the ATM machine (which is indeed quite useful). The rest of it? Is the economy running better? Does the financial system allocate capital more effectively? If not, then why are they taking home so much more money? I'm not going to argue that they're not smart -- they're plenty smart, I'm sure there are a lot of people in finance who are smarter than me. It just seems that those smarts have been applied towards rent-seeking and value extraction rather than "building things people want".
- jrwoodruff 16y agoI think the answer to that is they've made it a lot easier to borrow a lot of money very cheaply. I'm pretty sure when my parents got a mortgage 25-some years ago, the interest rate was around 18%. I wouldn't be able to afford my house at that rate. I'm sure this same cheap money has helped finance many people who build things, then helped them set up plants in China and Mexico as well. Whether cheap money is a good or a bad thing in the long run, I guess that has yet to be seen.
- kevin_morrill 16y agoWe can give Alan Greenspan most of the credit for that. Given the fallout, I am not sure it's much of an honor.
- jbooth 16y ago
- patrickgzill 16y agoI wonder how much longer realtors and mortgage brokers will be able to charge their hefty fees, once it is understood that house prices may stay the same or even decline during the next several years (at the least). Would you pay 6% over and above the price of a new car, to the car salesman as his fee?
- nitrogen 16y agoThe car salesman already makes a decent commission, but it's built in to the offered price of the car. With a house, the homeowner usually decides how much they want, and the agents' commissions are added to that. This all happens in the background with cars.
- mkramlich 16y agothe funny thing is that already much of what they "do" is done by automated software. picture millions of processes looking for opportunities to buy low and sell high, and you're not too far from the truth. speaking in general terms.
- asdkl234890 16y agoIsn't that essentially what lending tree is?
- retube 16y agoOh yeah? And who will write the shell scripts? And I can't imagine what a shell script which could properly model the convexity of a basket of mortgages would look like. Or for that matter I'd like to see a shell script execute an IPO, or advise on a buyout, or hedge a company's inflation exposure. I'm actually shocked this extremely ignorant, flame-bait comment has got so many upvotes on a site like hacker news which, in theory, is supposed to be a community of pretty smart and educated people.