3 ms·
And it works the other way too: as a consumer I don't care about whether something is open or not, if it doesn't stream the things I want to stream.
by alkonaut 7y ago
And it works the other way too: as a consumer I don't care about whether something is open or not, if it doesn't stream the things I want to stream.
- _eht 7y agoConsider caring.
- alkonaut 7y agoI do care. I just care less about openness than convenience notice the "IF it doesn't stream...". Given two systems that work equally well, I'd pick the open one. That's rarely the case though. So I pick the polished one. I think this goes for most consumers.
- the_gipsy 7y agoIt affects consumers, though. Closed platforms work against consumers' interest way too often.
- _jal 7y agoYou start caring when 'your' devices are suborned into a proxy fight against their actual owner's competitors.
- alkonaut 7y agoNo. I care about both convenience and openness. At some point perhaps the proxy fight makes the producs inconvenient? Perhaps even less convenient than the open alternative? At that point consumers might reconsider. Not until then.
- diffeomorphism 7y agoOn the other hand the non-streaming downloaded movies/music/games etc. will stop working when the company loses interest in providing the DRM servers. See Microsoft's PlaysForSure, ultraviolet, .... Or they "work" but only in low resolution because your HDCP version is not good enough. If the pirated version is objectively better, then something is wrong with your product.
- alkonaut 7y agoConsumers in general have no idea whether their offline media is dependent on DRM services so it’s an inconvenience they’ll only know when it’s too late. I agree it’s bad but I also think it’s a problem that disappeared when people stopped handling offline media. My convenience choice (and most I assume these days) is to completely skip offline/non-streamed media apart from what I create myself.
- diffeomorphism 7y agoIn contrast with online media you can be certain that it depends on DRM services. So it is less that it disappeared and more that it is now extremely widespread. Sure, it is convenient until your software/hardware is no longer supported (same HDCP problems, codecs, DRM schemes), 4k is only available on... , the monthly rent increases, it is now bundled with Amazon Prime Plus Ultra, the company pulls an Adobe in Venezuela, the company gets bought by Comcast, the company goes bankrupt, ... . For movies you unfortunately don't have much choice, but for games, ebooks and music you can find DRM free stores.
- alkonaut 7y agoIt's the same storey with all products. Of course I'd prefer just buying DRM free games, avoiding single player games that require connecting to services that can be down (looking at you Origin) etc. But the price and the product itself (the game, move, tv-series or whatever) is the deciding factor. There is never going to be enough people choosing services based on technical reaosns and not only content+price.
- diffeomorphism 7y ago> There is never going to be enough people choosing services based on technical reaosns and not only content+price. That sounds needlessly pessimistic. You could have said the same thing about music downloads several years ago, yet here we are (though music streaming admittedly goes in the other direction). People tend to choose based on convenience and music that I can easily take from my pc to put on my phone or wherever is more convenient than DRM stuff.