9 ms·
I expect a lot of people will focus on the problematic BBB in the comments here, but it's important to focus on the core problem: Molekule's marketing claims h
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
I expect a lot of people will focus on the problematic BBB in the comments here, but it's important to focus on the core problem:
Molekule's marketing claims have been debunked from the start. Their massive social media advertising campaigns have fed a lot of misinformation to a lot of people since their launch. It's amazing how many people I know who confidently recommend Molekule air filters as superior technology based on nothing more than having seen their Instagram ads. Molekule has secured media puff pieces from several influential media outlets as well as several print publications, none of whom seem to have done the slightest amount of testing to verify their claims.
Both Wirecutter and Consumer Reports actually tested the Molekule and found the performance to be abysmal. Wirecutter went so far as to declare it the worst air purifier they've ever tested: https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-air-purifier/#molekule-the-worst-air-purifier-weve-ever-tested https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-air-purifier/#molekul...
The product just plain does not work, and their marketing material appears to be pure lies. I hope they see some consequences for this.
Perhaps the worst part is that the underlying PECO technology is potentially promising as an adjunct to a traditional HEPA filter. Instead, the Molekule company has gone all-in in their anti-HEPA marketing strategy, creating a false dichotomy for marketing hype instead of trying to create an evolution of the standard HEPA filter.
- fortran77 7y agoIn general, you can't "purify air" without passing all the air in the room through a filter every "n" minutes, and maintaining some sort of barrier for outside air, like a pressurized room so air won't flow in naturally. Any little filter that you can stand in the corner can't do much to clean the air in the room. It may remove some large items like pet dander. A good filter in an HVAC system may do a little bit, but those are mainly to protect the HVAC system from gunk. This has always been a fertile area for scams, like the air filter that caused the demise of the Sharper Image, once it was established that it caused dangerous ozone levels.
- naravara 7y agoI think you’re taking the term “purify” too literally. These are just filters meant to reduce the concentrations of dust and other particulates. Nobody is expecting to create like, a microprocessor clean room with these.
- fortran77 7y agowhen Molekule claims they can eliminate airborne viruses they are!
- BubRoss 7y agoThat has nothing to do with what you claimed in the grandparent post and what this person was replying to. You said you can't 'purify' air with a small off the shelf air filter and many people gave you examples to the contrary.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 7y agoThey work for their intended purpose. I live in a city block with nut trees and a dog. The pollen, dander and pollen+diesel soot from the main road sucks and creates a mess. Running one of these machines in our front room makes a noticeable difference during peak pollen and shedding seasons.
- wongarsu 7y agoThere are plenty of good products out there that are basically a fan with a HEPA filter and an activated charcoal filter. Even at fairly low airflow it does continously filter the entire room air, and can radically reduce particle counts within half an hour.
- tbrock 7y agoWe have several Winix filters from amazon and they work great! They are HEPA w activated charcoal.
- heliodor 7y agoI see unsubstantiated statements like this one so frequently. Please explain how you have determined that "it works great".
- shock 7y agoNot the OP, but I have bought a Sensirion particulates sensor which I have used to measure the number of particles coming out of two air purifiers. It showed all 0 in the case of one purifier and very low values compared to ambient in the case of the other. Here's what it shows in my bedroom: measured values: 0.88 pm1.0 0.93 pm2.5 0.93 pm4.0 0.93 pm10.0 5.87 nc0.5 6.95 nc1.0 7.00 nc2.5 7.00 nc4.5 7.00 nc10.0 0.52 typical particle size
- antisthenes 7y agoEven a box fan and 2 Merv-13 furnace filters glued to it in a V-shape will perform FAR better than 99% of non-HEPA consumer purifiers out there, for a fraction of the price.
- clairity 7y agoyes, a few years ago, i bought a blueair 211+, which has a hepa and activated charcoal filter, and felt a noticeable improvement in my coughing and sneezing right away (and since then). the 211+ performed the best on wirecutter's own tests, but wasn't the top recommendation for what seemed like arbitrary reasons. you change the filter twice a year for about $100 in yearly costs. i hvae some air leakage around doors and windows (old building), but it's not enough to overwhelm the 211+ (as noted by my air quality sensor). in fact, i'm ok with some external air exchange, because CO2 levels can otherwise get unacceptably high overnight.
- peferron 7y ago> Any little filter that you can stand in the corner can't do much to clean the air in the room. It may remove some large items like pet dander. A consumer-grade HEPA air purifier (DIY or < $200 on Amazon) against a wall in your bedroom will commonly cut PM 2.5 concentrations by 10x in a few hours if you keep your windows and doors closed. Source: I own a PM 2.5 counter and have operated air purifiers in China smog and California wildfires. There's also plenty of evidence out there.
- kurthr 7y agoWhat I find interesting about InstaAds is that whatever product you find advertised is likely garbage... whether it is or isn’t you can find it (at the same or higher quality) for 50% off by searching eBay/Alibaba. It’s almost a joke now. Maybe I should make a meme and post it to the Gram.
- organsnyder 7y agoMy favorite is a fancy "plug strip" that is comprised of a metal junction box and a couple of standard outlets. Sure, the junction box is painted, and the cord is braided, but they're selling it for ~$100.
- FireBeyond 7y agoShinola? https://www.shinola.com/power-supply-5-port-usb.html https://www.shinola.com/power-supply-5-port-usb.html - $185 power supply
- organsnyder 7y agoClose. Though this one at least looks somewhat custom-manufactured (that's not a standard junction box, nor are those standard outlets). If you have to consider a payment plan for a plug strip, you might want to question your priorities...
- volkk 7y agoI've noticed this as well! I think there are tons of dropship companies that are run by a single person looking to make a quick buck selling rebranded low quality alibaba products. It's endless on my instagram, and I now ignore every single one of them because I know that it's essentially nothing more than spam. My gf ordered a few things that took AGES to arrive (probably because its shipping straight from China), with 0 customer support (primarily because it's likely run by a single person that couldn't care less about the actual customer who probably subscribes to /r/entrepreneur or /r/juststart). And the final product was as you put it, garbage.
- 76543210 7y ago>Molekule air filters as superior technology based on nothing more than having seen their Instagram ads. Reminds me of an overpriced tech company that claim security but continuously gets their devices hacked.
- gist 7y ago> Molekule air filters as superior technology based on nothing more than having seen their Instagram ads. Is this any different than people buying any luxury product based on marketing? Look at any designer clothing item. It's all based on (close to 100%) what people feel as a result of marketing and branding. The actual product sure is sometimes higher quality and better but not to the extent that it costs. Take a women's pocketbook for $5000 (Gucci). It's a pocketbook. Woman buys it because of marketing and image. Same here I say (Tesla is another example and note that Bill Gates still buys Porsche because that was the car in the era he was raised in).
- erentz 7y agoTheir marketing claims are complete lies about the effectiveness of their product for the purpose of filtering air. People shopping for air purifiers/filters are often enough doing so because they have health problems such as allergies. Not because they want a buzzing cylinder to sit in the middle of their room as some piece of art.
- oefrha 7y agoNot the same thing. People buying luxury clothing or accessories are basically buying into the fashion and/or status symbol. Whereas people buying high end air filters are probably expecting functionally better air filters.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> Take a women's pocketbook for $5000 (Gucci). It's a pocketbook. Woman buys it because of marketing and image. OK, but if the $5,000 pocketbook secretly incinerated anything you put in it, you'd probably get some frustrated customers. A Gucci pocketbook may be overpriced, but you're at least getting something that works.
- 0_____0 7y ago> pocketbook [that] secretly incinerate[s] anything you put in it is it weird that i kind of want to build this?
- fossuser 7y agoFrom the wire cutter review: ### Molekule claimed at the time that its “scientifically-proven nanotechnology outperforms HEPA filters in every category of pollutant.” Our tests proved otherwise. The Molekule turned in the worst performance on particulates of any purifier, of any size, of any price, that we have tested in the seven years that we have been producing this guide. Not long after we published our findings, that statement was removed from the Molekule website. Guide author Tim Heffernan asked Molekule CEO Dilip Goswami why. He answered, “the point about ‘in all categories’ is that we see a device that outperforms across all of the categories. Right? So we’re not trying to say that individually, on any particular metric, we would be number one. Right? What we’re saying is, when you look across all the categories, we outperform HEPA. Right? And that’s what we’re attempting to convey with that. And so—it’s fair to say that we needed to re-examine some of the language to make sure that it’s saying what we’re intending to say.” ### This seems like it rises to the level of criminally false?
- samstave 7y agoWell that sucks - so the Theranos of Purifiers, then?
- eternalny1 7y agoTo be honest, as human beings we've evolved over millions of years to be able to handle all of this stuff. If you are immuno-compromised or otherwise in poor health, then maybe these are worth something, but I highly doubt it. The volume of air they "purify" versus a given room is nothing. Imagine visualizing the air around you in a room that you are breathing, do you think a small device in the corner with a HEPA filter is going to solve anything? It's all smoke and mirrors.
- samstave 7y agoHa! I totally agree with you. I never take any meds. Not even aspirin or ibuprofen. My immune system is very strong - what we should be doing is gut biome transplants - not hepa and hand sanitizer crap.
- 7y ago
- borkt 7y agoI work for a municipal government in an area where wildfires hit. During the emergency our city’s fire department gave city hall a molekule air filter to run in the office. Knowing our typical budget I can only assume these were sent to us free by molekule, and I did not notice any improvement in air quality, likely as the technology is more for voc’s than large air particles. Felt super shady to me
- syshum 7y agoOnce Again the FTC is proving to be useless in the one area where there should be actually providing consumer protections Truth in Advertisement. It is takes a Corrupt organization like the BBB is "expose" this bad company (meaning they simply did not pay the BBB enough money) then really the "core" of the problem is not with Molekule at all, but with a system that allows companies like Molekule to exist with little to no liability. There should be a way to actually economically harm these companies that make these false claims, but instead it is up to the FTC to "regulate" their advertisements and clearly they (the FTC) do not actually do anything