8 ms·
How Retroactive makes Aperture, iPhoto, and iTunes work again on macOS Catalina (2019)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jtbayly 7y agoThis is great work. I'm not sure why somebody would want to run iPhoto instead of just upgrading to Photos, but to each his own. Since it takes a few clicks to get there from the article, here's the app that does all the work for you: https://github.com/cormiertyshawn895/Retroactive https://github.com/cormiertyshawn895/Retroactive
- Y-bar 7y agoiPhoto has much better keyword handling, better support for drag and drop (which for a long time was missing entirely from Photos), and the smart albums in Photos is still not as powerful as they were in iPhoto.
- dmitriid 7y agoBecause Photos is a horrible app with multiple issues that doesn't come close to any if the previous Apple offerings (esp. Aperture)? Just a small sample of issues: - https://grumpy.website/post/0SUrgqNju https://grumpy.website/post/0SUrgqNju - https://grumpy.website/post/0SZmcHq7V https://grumpy.website/post/0SZmcHq7V - https://grumpy.website/post/0Rz1BBnjz https://grumpy.website/post/0Rz1BBnjz
- throw03172019 7y agoDoes anyone actually want iTunes? As a Spotify user, my Mac opens iTunes when I press the Play button on my keyboard if Spotify has been not playing for X minutes (power nap?). I have to immediately kill iTunes before it begins playing a CD I bought 7 years ago.
- cold_fact 7y agoI 100% want iTunes. I like to listen to live music and Streaming services are pretty shit at archiving concerts. Also, on my work laptop, I used to be able to connect my iphone through USB and use iTunes to play my music without having to sync or have the physical WAV on my machine Now with the new Music app, I can't browse my music. I just recently had to upgrade to Catalina so maybe i'm missing something but i'm pretty pissed at that change
- psychometry 7y agoSome of us prefer to own and organize our own music rather than rely on streaming services. Sadly, Catalina Music isn't any less buggy than recent versions of iTunes.
- samatman 7y agoI have a (somewhat forlorn) hope that, now that Music neé iTunes is no longer a floor wax and a dessert topping, it might someday be a stable piece of software. Recent releases from Apple don't really encourage this hope, admittedly. I wish they would formalize a tick-tock strategy for OS and core apps, pushing new features on odd years and fixing their mess on even ones.
- filoleg 7y agoI actually don't think that would be a good idea, because it would result in a culture of "eh, why fix the bugs in this major OS release, we have a fix-up OS release next year just for that". I don't want to end up in the same situation as that of old Windows releases, where major OS versions were nigh unusable until the Service Pack 1 release.
- samatman 7y agoYou may be right. I just have good memories of Snow Leopard, I suppose.
- 7y ago
- scoot 7y agoI bought Aperture only shortly before they killed it off. Still seething about that. Since Photos can't seem to cope with my ~30K picture photo library (that I'm still trying to recover it after numerous attempts), can anyone suggest a viable alternative?
- zerkten 7y agoFrom your tone, I'm assuming you've tried and discounted Lightroom already?
- bradknowles 7y agoNo Adobe products, please.
- wiredfool 7y agoI'm in the same boat with Lightroom -- I've bought it 3 times and I've got a historic library in it with tens of thousands of images, but if I upgrade to Catalina my non-subscription Lightroom won't work anymore. I don't open it often, like maybe a couple of times a year, but I don't want to lose the work that's in there.
- zerkten 7y agoCould you run the old Lightroom in a VM? Ultimately, you might have to unless you migrate or pay up. Lightroom is inexpensive relative to other tools and everyday expenses I have. The same goes for other closed-source photography software mentioned on threads like this, to the point that I've bought some of it to experiment moving off Lightroom. Given the propensity of photographers to splurge huge amounts on gear, and their positions on intellectual property, I don't think I'm that unusual. Perhaps within the HN crowd the philosophy is different.
- wiredfool 7y agoI didn’t object to paying for upgrades when I was actively using the software, but at this point, I’d be paying tens per invocation of the program. I’ve moved on, I don’t do photography much anymore and if I’m going to be plowing money into something, I’d rather it be in a current hobby.
- okayVGA 7y agoAny love for OpenCL support on Catalina? It's all I want.
- cglong 7y agoAs someone who's actively avoided Catalina, what's wrong with OpenCL support?
- foxhill 7y agoi’m going to presume they followed through on their promise to drop support for it: https://www.extremetech.com/computing/270902-apple-defends-killing-opengl-opencl-as-developers-threaten-revolt https://www.extremetech.com/computing/270902-apple-defends-k...
- swerner 7y agoIn my experience, OepnCL in Catalina is about as good or bad as it was in Mojave.
- saagarjha 7y ago> The easiest way to swizzle something is just to make a category on NSObject and call method_exchangeImplementations in +load. Don't do this, declaring a method in a category with the same name as an already existing method is undefined behavior. Use a static constructor instead.
- lilyball 7y agoThe article isn't relying on method name conflict in the category. It's declaring a new method and swizzling in +load. If you meant the +load method itself conflicts, that's not true because +load on categories is handled specially by the Obj-C runtime. You can have 20 different categories define +load on the same class and the runtime will invoke all of them.
- saagarjha 7y agoOh, TIL!
- netsharc 7y ago"Who wants to hack around the command line? Mac OS, it just works!"
- pilif 7y agoWhat's crazy to me is how much functionality of Aperture was apparently powered by OS features that were just there to, well, power Aperture. Pro fonts. Pro table headers and so on. I guess that's what you get when the OS vendor also makes apps. And it shows how privileged those apps are compared to others. Only the OS makers apps can have their functionality shipped with the OS itself.