5 ms·
I can’t wait until this happens with last-mile internet access too, and, in a funny twist of circumstance, quality electric cars. What other long-moated indust
by sneak 7y ago
I can’t wait until this happens with last-mile internet access too, and, in a funny twist of circumstance, quality electric cars.
What other long-moated industries are going to crack open in the next half-dozen years?
- thedance 7y agoIf this is really your impression of the industry, you must be really young. It’s not “long-moated”. Intel was in a similar situation when the Opteron was current, and before they had to go head-to-head with Sun and IBM and before that nobody would even think of putting intel in a server at all. The period during which Intel’s products were the obviously superior choice lasted maybe 5-8 years at most. And it wasn’t some nefarious plot, either. Just good product.
- sneak 7y agoThe first computer I built myself was an 800MHz Athlon, so I am somewhat familiar with Intel’s history of competition. Moats don’t have to be malicious or nefarious. Sometimes there are just high barriers to entry to compete. See tractors with DRM, for instance. Apparently building tractors and a tractor repair/parts network is a very expensive undertaking.
- thedance 7y agoA moat implies barriers against new entrants, but none of the parties in the current market are new. They are all well within the moat.
- greglindahl 7y agoI'm pretty sure that the concept of a "moat" applies to more than new entrants. For example, this definition [1] refers to competitors, not new entrants. 1: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/economicmoat.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/economicmoat.asp
- gonzo41 7y agoResidential Power, Solar will hit a tipping point soon for home installs. And I'd expect the proliferation of microgrids around renewable sources mixed in with batteries.
- jchw 7y agoHonest question: do you think Teslas are, on the whole, overpriced? I am neither an owner nor an expert in electric cars, but I have been routinely impressed with the rate at which the price has come down. I don’t doubt that the $35k Model 3 configuration is probably non-sensical (at $35k minimum spec seems silly) but also it seems pretty competitive for an electric car that can replace a gas car. My personal hunch has always been that the price for relatively cheap Tesla configurations that make sense probably are limited by volume and initial cost of R&D and scaling up manufacturing. (Of course almost any company does some market segmentation for better or worse, so I’m sure the prices of options are non-sense.) Not to say the prices won’t go down. But I actually didn’t think the reason they were high was due to mature, moated companies. My personal belief is that Tesla would be foolish to rest on their success in such a way when other companies with a lot more resources are surely going to be competing more competently soon.
- sneak 7y agoNo, I don’t think they are super overpriced, I just think the quality isn’t there yet. Hopefully we can see higher quality all-electric options at similar or lower price points. Tesla’s service reputation is the main reason I still currently drive an ICE. (Before that, it was their laggy touchscreen - my gas guzzler has an iPad on a bracket on the dash, which does not lag.). Also I’m never going to drive something that spies on me; I had the GSM radio transceiver removed from my current vehicle. AIUI if you do that to a Tesla you never receive future updates, even to features you paid for in advance. More competition in the EV market is going to be awesome. Right now it’s just a bloodbath where Tesla can basically do whatever they want, because until very recently every other EV was simply hot garbage.
- leeoniya 7y ago> Also I’m never going to drive something that spies on me; I had the GSM radio transceiver removed from my current vehicle. i'd like to do the same to my VW Golf. i bought a VCDS tool to go in and fiddle with the settings to essentially put the gsm module into airplane mode (i think it's verizon telematics). dunno if this will be sufficient though. i read that just ripping it out causes a bunch of the infotainment system misbehave, etc.
- cptskippy 7y agoThose are very different situations. Intel has held a technological advantage and, up until recently, no one could compete with them so they could command their price. With ISPs there is a huge capital investment cost, and with EVs there are supply chain issues limiting capacity and commanding higher costs. With last-mile internet, the incumbents have made significant capital investments and competitors have so far been unwilling to engage in the sort of long term slow return investment necessary to build out infrastructure. Google Fiber has tried all means to lower the cost of entry and has thus far failed to deliver significant gains and they're unwilling to make the huge capital investments necessary to truly compete because ensuing price wars would make realizing a return near impossible. With BEVs the problem is manufacturing cost, primarily the cost of batteries needs to drop but the demand for EVs has not warranted dramatic ramp ups in battery manufacturing necessary for that to occur. The supply of suitable batteries is so limited that Jaguar and others have actually had to stop production.
- sneak 7y ago> With last-mile internet, the incumbents have made significant capital investments and competitors have so far been unwilling to engage in the sort of long term slow return investment necessary to build out infrastructure. I wish it were that simple. Unfortunately, the incumbents in a lot of places have done so much to make it appear like there is competition when there really isn’t, to prevent localities from allowing new entrants. It’s a huge problem, at least in the US.