7 ms·
They are replacable. It’s cheap to replace them. They just don’t have a user accessible hatch. I wouldn’t want to have a battery hatch and perhaps worse water
by alkonaut 7y ago
They are replacable. It’s cheap to replace them. They just don’t have a user accessible hatch.
I wouldn’t want to have a battery hatch and perhaps worse water sealing, just so I could change a battery myself instead of paying $20 for it once in the lifetime of a phone that is maybe $500 to $1500 to buy!
Sure if it came at no cost in terms of size, weight, price, waterproofing etc then sure. But otherwise I’d rather just pay the cheap replacement once after 2-3 years.
If people throw away their phones because the battery has gone bad, I think it’s because they think it’ll be expensive or impossible to change it.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoIt’s more like 79 $ for the new generation of iPhones, at least if you want to have it changed by Apple with an official battery (https://support.apple.com/iphone/repair/service/battery-power https://support.apple.com/iphone/repair/service/battery-powe...). I did it for my SE and think it’s worth it, I still find it overpriced though.
- enneff 7y agoWhy get an official battery replacement for a phone that’s out of warranty?
- hinkley 7y agoDoes the replacement work nave a warranty?
- ThePhysicist 7y agoI don’t think so, I think the battery might have a one year warranty but it’s considered a “wear part” like a tire so I don’t think you can get a free replacement if it wears out in an expected way.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoBecause the phone itself is still fine and works really well, just the battery doesn’t hold a full charge and doesn’t deliver the full output current anymore. Now I can use the phone for another 1-2 years which is great. I love the form factor as well and right now Apple doesn’t have anything comparable, but I hope they’ll make a small phone again. Also, the unofficial replacement is not that much cheaper, you get a no-name Chinese battery (which is often worse than the original and more dangerous) and it might break things like FaceID/TouchID because the security chip will be reset and the non-official repair shops don’t have any means to reprogram it (as far as I know).
- dsabanin 7y agoBeacause then you know that the battery is actually good, not some refurbished old battery with patched firmware, or a cheap knock off that’s going to lose half of the capacity in a month, if not outright explode on you.
- Lammy 7y agoI don’t know if there are any user-visible side effects, but the phone does knows the difference between official and unofficial batteries. Here’s a photo I took of my iPhone 7 showing the internal battery stats immediately after an official replacement during the discount program a couple years ago: https://i.imgur.com/Wo5fSFj.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Wo5fSFj.jpg
- johnnycab 7y agoWhich app did you use to retrieve the detailed internal battery stats in the photo?
- Lammy 7y agoThe one pictured was a jailbreak tweak called DetailedPowerUsage: https://legitcomputerwhisperer.github.io/depic/InternalBatteryData/index.html https://legitcomputerwhisperer.github.io/depic/InternalBatte... DPU hasn't been updated for compatibility with iOS 12+, but another tweak "System Info" can show some of the same info: https://old.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/8ecxdm/update_system_info_v200_info_on_your_device_in/ https://old.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/8ecxdm/update_sy...
- johnnycab 7y agoThanks. I am not looking to jailbreak yet, so I will have to forgo acquiring these stats for now. I have Lirium Lite, which also does not show the internal stats past iOS 10, due to restricted API.
- alkonaut 7y agoDO you mean "why get an official battery" or "why do it at a certified store"? For me I'd do it at the store because it's the only way to make sure you get a good battery. Most cheap batteries are crap (or at least you won't know if it's crap until it's too late). If it was possible to get a battery that was 100% known to be original, and I could save a few $ by taking it to a corner shop to have the work done, I'd definitely do that for a phone out of warranty. But in my experience this just isn't possible (which is perhaps a better complaint to direct towards apple than the battery hatch complaint: I want to be able to buy original parts in any shop anywhere).
- thedance 7y ago99.5% of non-OEM batteries for phones and laptops are scams and you can’t tell the difference ahead of time.
- adrianmonk 7y agoLabor is expensive. The cost difference between OEM and aftermarket parts is small. If the aftermarket battery is fine, you only gain a little. If the aftermarket battery disappoints, you lose big. So it's cheap insurance.
- hinkley 7y agoThat’s parts and labor. I think GP is talking about labor. And I remember having a feature phone with a replaceable battery. Often became difficult to find a new battery after they stopped selling the phone. So if you think the lack of a battery is the only reason you’ll stop using your old phone? You’re probably only gonna get another year.
- alkonaut 7y agoIndeed $79 is a number you can't compare because it's a battery and a battery replacement job. For phones with user replaceable batteries you'd still need to buy batteries. And there job cost was only a small part of the $79.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoYeah I want to use it 1-2 years more, I’m not a power user and it’s still a perfectly fine phone, runs really fast and gets updates, so why throw it out? Also as I said below if you replace the battery yourself TouchID will stop working as the security chip thinks the phone has been tampered with, so if you wanna keep using that there’s only the official route I think. Not sure about FaceID but it might have the same problem.
- kasey_junk 7y agoI’ve replaced batteries on 3 different TouchId iPhones and never had that problem.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoInteresting. Maybe it’s just Apple propaganda then. Still I wouldn’t want to do it myself I think, though I’m sure it’s doable.
- jdeibele 7y agoMy 13-year-old did it on his iPhone SE with a little help from me. Hardest part was getting the old battery free of the adhesive gluing it to the case. He wouldn't use the hair dryer long enough to make the adhesive more pliant and ended up twisting and yanking the battery free. I put the old battery in a bucket on concrete overnight because he thought he might have punctured the envelope and I was worried about it catching on fire. No problem recycling it. It was about $20 for an Amazon battery kit that came complete with tools. Had 20% more charging capacity than the original (when it was new) and my son is very happy with the result. Earphones worked fine, screen worked fine, etc.
- hamaluik 7y agoI just replaced the battery in my iPhone a couple months ago. I ended up paying Apple over $300 because the glass on the bezel had a small crack on it and they wouldn’t touch it unless I replaced the entire screen too. It’s not “just $20” to replace an iPhone battery.
- traspler 7y agoI gave them my busted 6S with a huge crack in a corner and they replaced the battery without issue.
- zenexer 7y agoIt depends on the store and the device. Some stores—especially the smaller ones—don’t necessarily enforce every policy. Bigger stores, stores with stricter management, and stores that have encountered problems in the past are likely to give you a hard time.
- moooo99 7y agoEspecially considering that a battery replacement at Apple is around 75€. While thats a lot cheaper than buying a new phone as soon as the battery goes bad, its a lot more expensive than opening up the cover of your phone and simply swapping the battery. A few years ago I had a LG G3 with a removable back. It was a great phone, but had quite a few problems. One of them was a non-oled QHD panel that drew the battery like crazy. I just bought another battery for 15€ and swapped them when necessary. That was a lot more convienient than carrying around a bulky USB powerbank. Of course, that is a very specific problem to have. But having a user-removable battery is still one of the things I miss the most from older Android phones.
- alkonaut 7y agoApple might be stingy about conditions vs warranties (understandably). But you can always go to a third party. Your warranty isn't much good anyway if you have damaged it I'd assume. I meant the work portion of the cost, (at a third party if required e.g. because apple don't want to touch it) is probably around €20.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoIt's utterly trivial to engineer a waterproof phone with a user-removable battery. It's not remotely difficult. I have about a dozen watches that are seriously waterproof; I can change the battery in any of them in 5 minutes. There's only one reason Apple batteries are not user-replaceable: Apple makes more money this way because it encourages people to buy new phones.
- alkonaut 7y agoIf a phone would be 1mm thicker when having user replacable battery, that means the manufacturer has given up the opportunity to use that 1mm extra thickness for battery capacity. Which is the same as standby time, or performance. Watches usually don't have a problem with cpu performance/standby time so it's perhaps not a good comparison.
- eigenvector 7y agoIf 1mm worth of battery capacity is important, why do Apple and others keep making phones progressively thinner?
- alkonaut 7y agoThey make the phones thinner presumably because people want thinner phones. They want to be as thin as the competition. And as fast. And have as long battery time. And they are all related obviously.
- bitwize 7y agoThey kind of are, but the relationship is the wrong way around. Thinness is inversely correlated with battery life, a thicker phone has room for a bigger battery. Thinness also constrains your heat dissipation options, making it more difficult to drive the CPU/GPU at high clock speeds. My phone lives, alone, in my left front pocket. I'd much rather have the benefits of a thicc phone than maximize thinness.
- macintux 7y ago
- wackget 7y agoWhere can you get a battery changed for $20, including installation costs? Except maybe China.
- alkonaut 7y agoI'm talking about the installation cost only (because the battery would need to be purchased anyway).
- CameronNemo 7y agoI would be fine with this if third parties could replace it while the warranty or other support holds.
- alkonaut 7y agoIf the battery is bad while there is still warranty then Apple should replace it for free. If it deteriorates later than that (much more common) then you have no warranty anyway! Things that can be actual issues: - Apple not providing batteries and making the use of third party parts a worse experience - Third party repairs having side effects such as touch-ID not working. It’s fair to argue that Apple should make products that can will be serviced for free by them during the warranty period and then they should be serviceable by anyone and keep full functionality.
- ryanlol 7y agoGreat, this is how it already works in the EU.
- badrabbit 7y agoVehemently disagree. A $700 phone should not be thrown out or need a paid repair when a battery, hopefully cheaper than the vendor's battery can be used to replace. You don't need an ugly hatch, you just need a removable back.
- alkonaut 7y agoYou can use a third party battery in your iPhone. Thats what you get when you get a $30 replacement. My point is this: the cost of the repair is smaller than the cost of the battery regardless of whether you use Apple or a third party for both labor and parts. If you aren’t looking for a big waterproof hatch with a cartridge behind it then I too agree that if the number of steps would be smaller then that would be great. I have tried it but I still rather pay $10 or $20 for someone else to do it.
- badrabbit 7y agoYour prefernce is fine. This is about rights -- the right to not need the vendor to repair your own property. They intentionally made them very hard to repair so you need them, you need their stores. I was trying to say I would rather pay 5x more to do it myself. And if it was not for their intentional sabotage,there is no way having them repair it would be cheaper. There will always be cheaper lower quality batteries from china,not needing specialized tools also means $0 labor cost! This is one of the main reasons I hate(and I don't mean that casually) apple as a company. How dare they tell you what you can and cannot do with your own property? How dare they sabotage their products so that customizing it in any way or in this case even repairing it becomes difficult,it's your property now,not theirs! Imagine getting takeout food where adding salt would ruin or poison the food because the chef wants to control your ability to customize the food to your taste! Intentional sabotage should carry a severe legal penalty. Property rights matter, the right to sell a product to consumers however is not a right but a privilege companies like apple enjoy by the good will of the governments that represent the people.
- alkonaut 7y agoNot sure if we are discussing different things: I absolutely think people should have a right to repair their things. I don’t think that means manufacturers should be required to make it easy. I don’t buy that Apple has deliberately made it difficult to repair. It seems to be pretty similar designs across many smartphones from multiple manufacturers. I don’t think it’s a conspiracy, I think it’s the design you end up with if you weigh all parameters (cost, durability, performance, thickness, battery capacity, repairability ..) and simply rank ease of repair last. It’s what customers want, I guess. Apple should repair devices (including replacing batteries) for free within the warranty. When the warranty period has ended Apple should a) ensure people can get original parts if they want, so they can repair whereever they want and b) make sure that people can repair their devices in any way they want, forever, without it behaving worse than if Apple themselves repairs it. Those are really independent of whether or not these replacements involve 4 screws and 3 steps (great) or 20 screws and 44 steps (bad). I don’t want to pay a penalty of even 1% performance weight, durability or cost to get the simpler repair, so long as it’s a $20 job, that’s all I’m saying. 99% of users of course wouldn’t repair the phone regardless of whether the procedure uses 4 tiny standard screws or 40 screws requiring standard tools. The former would just let their unofficial repair guy do it for $5 instead of $20. This is why I think it’s not a very important question. There are a many other more important questions in the area, such as for example the stance on third party batteries, and whether it’s acceptable that some features are disabled when repairing (e.g touchID).