4 ms·
Here in the UK we learned the hard way that health care is national defence. It’s a matter of vital national security. In WWI we were chronically short of healt
by simonh 7y ago
Here in the UK we learned the hard way that health care is national defence. It’s a matter of vital national security. In WWI we were chronically short of healthy young recruits, far too many potential soldiers were too sickly or under nourished to serve. What goes for the military goes for industry too, what use is a sickly, unfit work force, especially in a crisis? This is why universal health care is not controversial in the UK. It’s why lifelong conservative voters like me support universal health care, we were faced with a clear existential threat generations ago. How could we expect the population to fight for a country that didn’t look after them in return? Loyalty has to go both ways. I accept we’re a different case from the US because we’re a much smaller country, the US can manage due to sheer numbers, but that’s a pretty poor excuse. Having a fit, healthy population matters.
Now we’re faced with Covid-19. This is a matter of national and international security and defence. Health care spending is national defence spending. It’s just a different type of defence against different types of threats, some mundane, some exceptional.
- WalterBright 7y ago> How could we expect the population to fight for a country that didn’t look after them in return? One of the benefits of serving in the US military was free medical care for the soldier and his family.
- forkerenok 7y agoI think the argument extends to potential need to draft general population in times of need. You want to draft healthy people.
- chii 7y agothe argument doesn't work, because the assumption is that you have a large, but unhealthy population. But such a population is unable to sustain itself in the first place! If a country is doing fine (production wise), then there must be way more healthy, able-bodied people than sick people. The draft will just target those able-bodied people. And then there's the new style of war these days - drones, remote weapons and nukes. It either comes down to a small skirmish against brown people with little more than an AK47, or it's nuke time. i don't see war going any other direction.
- simonh 7y agoIt’s not purely a practical argument, though it has a strong practical component, to me it’s also a moral one. We expect loyalty and patriotism from our people. If we owe loyalty to our country and each other, I believe that carries obligations. I’m no socialist, I’m a true believer in the individual freedoms and liberties at the heart of capitalism. Free enterprise is the most powerful force in human society, and it is generally a force for good. I suppose where I part ways with American style conservatives is my attitude to government. To me, in a democracy we are the government. It’s not an external force, it’s something we all carry responsibility for, and can be a vehicle through which we meet our mutual responsibilities, and to me that’s tied to my sense of patriotic duty. I know America has a much stronger sense of individualism and personal autonomy. I don’t want to malign that or trivialise it, there are good historical reasons for it. It’s just that over here in the UK we learned different historical lessons for different reasons.
- jinushaun 7y agoPretty much my argument for universal healthcare. People from both sides focus too much on emotional aspects of universal heathcare, but from a practical standpoint, the healthier your population, the longer they will be alive paying taxes. Obesity was a problem in the US only when too many people were too fat to join the military.
- whatthesmack 7y agoI don’t think skepticism of governments is an emotional response. It is practical and evidenced by history & folks’ experience with it. Folks against one method of caring for the population (ie “universal healthcare”) are not necessarily against having healthcare for as many people as possible nor against helping others... they’ve just seen governments do things inefficiently and occasionally dangerously and thus have a reasonable level of skepticism for the “universal healthcare solution” to the problem. For example, in the US, the VA has a horrible track record that immediately turns folks, like myself, off of the idea that the government should have any more control over our decisions than it already has. In addition, the political party that is more likely to bring “universal healthcare” to fruition--the Democrat party--had trouble counting votes in Iowa recently. That level of competence does not currently lend itself to running an entire healthcare system where lives are at stake. All that to say... it’s much more complex than “people are emotional because they resist my solution to the problem”.
- DangitBobby 7y agoDoesn't the VA have a bad track record due to its disability rating classification system? If you have 100% disability but they deem you to have 50%, they won't pay enough for you to get what you really need. The problem with the VA is not that it's run by the government, it's that it is capable of fucking and bankrupting you, just like the rest of our healthcare system. > The democratic party had difficulty counting votes in Iowa recently. Seems like aggregating so much data from numerous sources by non-expert volunteers is very likely to have issues. More to your point, though, that setup is not how most government business is conducted, so it's not especially relevant.
- makomk 7y agoIt's less expensive than you'd think too. The key is that this only requires the vast majority of people to be able to work a large majority of the time. If it would cost more money to stop someone dying or going blind or suffering other major health problems than the typical worker is worth, the NHS just doesn't provide that treatment. There are plenty of other workers whose health care needs are much cheaper. Likewise, people wait months for the treatment of conditions that stop them going back to work, and that's fine - there are other workers. Highly-paid industries like IT which can't treat their employees like replacable cogs often offer private health insurance with lower waiting times as a perk that just happens to benefit them too. This is across the board. On the one end of the spectrum, the NHS only rolled out flu vaccination for infants this flu season and vaccinates a lot less aggressively than the US in general - if you have to vaccinate a large number of people to prevent a few serious illnesses that doesn't work out cost-wise. On the other, a lot of the expensive cancer treatments, as well as cutting-edge treatmeents for chronic conditions like cystic fibrosis, aren't available either. (Though some utterly ineffective cancer treatments have been funded for political reasons.) On the other hand, there was some bizarre business where the NHS decided not to offer a cost-effective cure for Hepatitis C to most people with it, even though it's a communicable disease with serious long-term health effects and curing them would probably save money in the long run, because the short-term cost was too high. I think they ended up making a deal with the drug companies very similar to the one a number of US states did, where they got reduced per-treatment costs as part of a program to aggressive find and treat everyone including homeless people and others who don't have access to healthcare. Sometimes the US and UK are less different than the press let on. I'm not sure how well the NHS would cope with a coronavirus pandemic either. In a good year it barely has enough resources to handle the seasonal flu, and this has been the worst flu season for it in a long time.
- simonh 7y agoAll health care systems everywhere have to make decisions based on cost. Everywhere. It doesn't matter how they are funded or run, they all operate within the constraints of the resources they have available.
- 7y ago
- bitlax 7y agoJust because you don't want healthcare controlled by the federal government doesn't mean you're opposed to healthcare itself, and some of the countries with universal healthcare have some of the highest infection and death rates so I'm not sure how your solution relates to COVID-19.
- makomk 7y agoYeah. Italy has a universal healthcare system funded from taxes, and not only are they now a major cluster of coronavirus infection and spread, their healthcare system ended up helping to spread the virus. Supposedly their healthcare is some of the best in the world overall too.
- rm_-rf_slash 7y agoThe difference is getting tested or treated in Italy won’t bankrupt you like it will in the US.
- jkingsbery 7y agoAlso: China has (near) universal health care. (https://www.internations.org/go/moving-to-china/healthcare#how-does-the-healthcare-system-work-in-china https://www.internations.org/go/moving-to-china/healthcare#h..., https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168851015001864 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016885101...) With universal health insurance, you're at the mercy of the government. If the government chooses not to cover your issue, or if the government tells you "you're not sick so stop telling people you are," that's too bad. The same thing happens in private insurance, to be sure (minus the "if you say bad things about us we'll put you in jail" part), since people get denied. With government run health care, you have fewer alternatives though. You can't try some other doctor to see if that one will work financially (since it's the same entity footing the bill ultimately). There's no alternate system or provider to go to (you can't do much to get better health coverage for next time).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- namelosw 7y agoI totally agree with your point, but it is very hard for the US to implement healthcare like in Europe. There are things like sugar tax in Europe, why? Because the governments spent so much money on health care. Corporations selling tasty but unhealthy food is profiting from part of the tax payer's money. In Japan, the system works because people are generally healthier. In Europe, the system works because the governments are willing to pay the bill in the first place, then tax the unhealthy food industries to make the system more efficient towards systems like Japan. In the US, it's pretty different because corporations have larger influences than in Europe. Also, there are a lot of people who won't give up unhealthy foods -- It basically boils down to personal preferences to be healthy or not in the US, while In Europe it's a little bit obligated to be healthy because it's costing tax payer's money.
- mytherin 7y agoWhile unhealthy individuals cost the health care system more early on in their life, healthy individuals tend to cost more in the long run because individuals live longer and thus require more treatment [1, 2]. In fact, one could argue unhealthy people are better for universal health care and universal retirement systems because they collect less retirement while still generally dying after age 65~70 (after having stopped working and having paid the maximum amount of money into these systems through taxes and retirement savings). [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/03/22/alcohol-obesity-and-smoking-do-not-cost-health-care-systems-money/#710d8dc164aa https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/03/22/alcohol-... [2] https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0050029 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jo...
- tomohawk 7y agoWhat works best in normal times rarely works best in extremis. And vice versa.
- mynameishere 7y agoThat sickliness was mainly from malnutrition, not health care.
- kenneth 7y agoDuring WWi it was mostly due to the Spanish flu killing 5% of the world's population, way more than the war the itself
- simonh 7y agoMalnutrition was a major factor yes, but not to an overwhelming degree. For example dental issues were also a major problem, and of course nutrition itself is a health issue in which a well functioning health care system plays an important role.