7 ms·
FCC Proposes to Fine Wireless Carriers $200M for Selling Customer Location Data
- grawprog 7y ago>The FCC proposed fining T-Mobile $91 million; AT&T faces more than $57 million in fines; Verizon is looking at more than $48 million in penalties; and the FCC said Sprint should pay more than $12 million So that's actually $200 million split between four companies and what really amounts to not much more than cost od business for them.
- mikeyouse 7y agoLol - T-Mobile has $40B in annual revenue, does anyone think a fine of $0.09 billion covering years of wrongdoing is going to change their behavior? I'm sure 0.2% of their annual revenue will really sting.
- veeralpatel979 7y agoSomething I read in another HN thread was that while $200M may not be much compared to T-Mobile's annual revenue, it's probably a lot compared to how much ISPs earn from selling user data. This doesn't factor in the ongoing PR cost of headlines like "FCC weighing fining ISP X", "FCC fines ISP X", "ISP X appeals fine", "ISP X loses appeal", etc. Still, I agree the fine could have been harsher.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoWhat PR cost? We don’t have any options, we have to use one of these sleazy companies.
- veeralpatel979 7y agoFair point. Typically I'm on the side of the free market and less government regulation, but this system breaks down if consumers have no choice but to use a small set of companies, who all have an interest in doing the same thing, and creating a new competitor is difficult.
- dustinmr 7y agoAlso known as not a free market.
- rectang 7y agoThat's the No True Scotsman Fallacy. The only absolutely "free" market is a state of nature, without laws and where might is right. Once you impose laws, it's not completely free. The US telecom market could be more "free" than it is, but there are lots of options, none of which are perfectly "free".
- defnotashton2 7y agoIt's not a free market or anywhere near and implying such is dishonest. Coops would be everywhere if it wouldn't be for rediculous city, county, state and federal regulations. Not to mention the miles and miles of dark fiber all over the country held up in ownership litigation, not to mention the federal government created this problem in the first place by heavily subsidizing bell and continuing to do so. The telco industry has always been a regulated monopolistic market and that is primarily caused and was created by regulation..
- rectang 7y ago> It's not a free market or anywhere near Right, agreed. > implying such is dishonest. /me raises eyebrow. Making utilities into something that consensus opinion would label a "free market" is incredibly difficult. Without regulation, you get monopolies. With regulation, you get monopolies. Implying that a "free market" can solve the utility problem is (I won't say "dishonest" because I don't believe you're arguing in bad faith) facile.
- maccam94 7y agoOne nitpick: AFAIK the issues at the city/county level come from service contracts that guarantee exclusivity in return for things like providing service to sparsely populated (unprofitable) areas and discounted rates for the poor/disabled/etc. You can argue that those deals shouldn't have been made, but then the local government would have been allocating public resources (running wires under streets, conduits, etc) in a way that excluded their disadvantaged constituents. Anywho I am a proponent of Local Loop Unbundling. Limited conduit/pole space and complex webs of property easements make wired telecoms natural monopolies. Have the government own the conduits and fiber cables, and rent them to service providers instead.
- rubyfan 7y agoYou should be bouncing that up against net income rather than revenue. T-Mobile was $3.5B for 2019 so a $91MM fine is 2.6% which feels like a material deterrent.
- mikeyouse 7y agoNet Income is endlessly manipulated to avoid income tax, if you want to be generous, maybe compare against operating income which is $5.7B. But remember, they've been doing this for years so the most appropriate calculation would be against their operating income for the number of years that they've been abusing people's privacy. In any case, it results in a laughably small fine.
- rubyfan 7y agoSeems like a reasonable approach would be based on how much they made from the sale of the data rather than how deep their pockets are. I don’t think it’s reasonable for the FCC to be levying excessively punitive fines that put businesses at risk just to make a point. The fine seems like it should be based on the violation. And unfortunately each of the big careers was doing this sort of thing. If we don’t like it then we should look to support congress passing some form of data privacy rules for carriers.
- bogomipz 7y agoNot only that but T-Mobile has already vowed to fight these "cost of doing business" fines. [1] [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/t-mobile-vows-to-fight-fcc-fines-for-location-sharing-11582921450 https://www.wsj.com/articles/t-mobile-vows-to-fight-fcc-fine...
- DevKoala 7y agoNot only that, the penalty only takes place IF they didn't follow the "adequate precautions to secure the data".
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoI wonder if these companies collectively made more than $200M selling location data. It's the only way to evaluate how penalizing this is.
- nielsbot 7y agoI don't think the penalty should be based on the size of revenue earned, the fine should be a strong deterrent. So it should be significant compared to what they can afford.
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoDo you mean more profitable companies should be fined more than less profitable companies for the same scale of wrongful behavior? If one wrongdoer happens to have other lines of business that generate a lot of cash but aren’t implicated in the misbehavior, they should get a more severe punishment? I think the endgame from such a punishment regime is companies will reorganize their corporate structure to section everything off from such liabilities.
- rburhum 7y agothe goal is simply “fine them enough so that it hurts and works as a mea culpa, but doesn’t destroy them the first time”
- _jal 7y agoThe point is simply standard economic law analysis - the idea is to make (punishment * probability of being caught) > expected gain from the crime. The theory is that if you remove the incentive for the behavior you wish to discourage, people will cut out. There are many criticisms of the approach, but those are mostly about crimes committed by individuals, not corporations. When you're talking about HugeCo abusing customers, I think seriously punitive fines can work. But you need to make them painful enough that at least the board, and preferably the shareholders, want to ask questions about how exactly they know this won't happen again. > I think the endgame from such a punishment regime is companies will reorganize their corporate structure to section everything off from such liabilities. Of course they will. Any time a corporate entity can construct legal structures to capture more, shed externalities or shift risk, it will. Why wouldn't it? "We have a legal obligation to maximize profit..." But that's not the "endgame of such a regime", that's normal business.
- mc32 7y agoThey should make repeat offenses harsher. Kind of like with road infractions.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoFines should go up exponentially for repeat offenses. 10th infringement? Might as well shut down the company.
- Frost1x 7y agoI tend to agree with something to this effect. It should also be relative to specific company's financial factors. Something like Finland's progressive fines where speeding tickets are actually based as a percentage of one's income. Maybe based on revenue, profit, market cap, and/or something a lot more well thought out than what I throw together on my phone at a whim. Obviously when you specify certain factors like "income," they end up being gamed to minimize those factors and therefor minimize punishment so whatever factors you use need to be difficult to adjust around. Probably also need to account for recovery rates. Earning 1% back for one person may be trivial compared to the another which makes them more likely or at least financially capable to repeat the offense.
- erikig 7y agoI wish there was an app that allowed me to charge all these data companies for use of my data directly. The app would pop up when I was signing up for any service and let me know which of my data the service be using and give me a price per month. I would then gladly share it and collect my pennies per day or opt-out and get degraded service or no service at all.
- ravenstine 7y ago> I would then gladly share it and collect my pennies per day or opt-out and get degraded service or no service at all. The latter part sounds awful. Why would that be acceptable? Do you mean that your selling to them your data would be in place of paying a service charge?
- fooker 7y agoThis is how this might look like: Gmail - 200$ per year. Gmail-freemium - 0$ per year.
- RileyJames 7y agoIsn’t that basically what it’s like already? You can have free gmail, consumer edition. With ads, no privacy, etc. Or G Suite. Which includes gmail, docs, calendar, etc, for $6~ (I’m seeing $7.80 CAD) Per month. Making it about half the $200 you quoted, but none the less, possible.
- caconym_ 7y agoNot enough? What are you gonna do about it, little people?
- maerF0x0 7y agoHow much is the government going to charge itself for the mass surveillance and data collection?
- gscott 7y agoExact, this fine probably represents a fraction of the fee the carriers charge the NSA for a data feed of this information.
- joeblau 7y agoThat’s it?
- hermitdev 7y agoIt'd be nice if these fines were distributed amongst the affected customers, but of course it won't. Edit: grammar
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway713 7y agoCan someone explain how FCC fines work? I’ve always been confused by them. Are the companies breaking a law, or just some kind of regulation they agreed to? And if so, why does it take the FCC so long to do anything? It’s been well known for the years that mobile carriers have been selling location. It almost seems like the FCC lets it go on as long as they can in order to levy as big a fine as possible. Or am I just being cynical?
- sitkack 7y agoJAIL!
- SN76477 7y agoIt should be higher. It should be shaking in their boots high. Like a single mom getting a speeding ticket high. AT&T generated $47.99B in 2018 They do not care too much if they are fined 200M. How about we make it 2B? Now they are nervous, now they see where the line is drawn in the sand.
- jaclaz 7y ago> now they see where the line is drawn in the sand. line which should actually be carved in stone
- dntbnmpls 7y agoIt's meaningless unless we know how much wireless carriers stand to make by selling customer location data. If they make $20 billion and the fine is $200 million, then it's a small business expense and a tax write off.
- LatteLazy 7y agoThere you have it: the price of privacy is less than 1usd per citizen.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tuesday20 7y agoCan’t they fine the buyers?
- hedora 7y agoThis should be set as a function of how much they made, and damages incurred. 10x amount they charged + $200/victim/incident (so, $200 for each record sent) seems reasonable to me. The latter part of the fine should go to the victims, I think. If this bankrupts them, the executives, then board, then shareholders should be the ones to take a bath. (Not pensions, etc). After that, the fine should be reduced until it leads to a net zero valuation of the company, with the difference being given to the victims by issuing stock at the resulting stock price. I’d like the fines to be applicable to anyone selling location data (app developers, linking shady libraries, I’m looking at you), and enforceable via class action rights that can’t be waived, as well as small claims court. The rules should also apply to data returned by any non-mandatory compliance with government requests. For class actions, consumers should get at least $190 of the $200, regardless of any pre-trial settlements. I think these are minimally adequate steps to end this behavior.
- visarga 7y ago> 10x amount they charged + $200/victim/incident (so, $200 for each record sent) seems reasonable to me. Why be so nice, when companies ask for $150,000 per copyright infringement? Leaking personal data is much more serious.
- tapejek 7y agoI think it's going to be the right thing to do. There should be protection of personal data
- mygo 7y agoI’m in favor of companies being fined for their screw ups, but why does only the government get the money? When do we, the victims, get our compensation?