7 ms·
Google tries new angle on hiring
- maxbrown 16y agoOf course I love that they're seeking out entrepreneurial talent, but the article doesn't seem to make mention of how they're going to target that in interview questions. Definitely curious...
- Joakal 16y agoAcquisitions? Where else can you find people with entrepreneurial talents?
- WildUtah 16y agoThey've been sending recruiters to me regularly for about six months. I get regular pitches and emails about working for them about twice a month from various people. I'd like to be able to consider it but I'm not in their candidate pool (around forty, no regular job for a few years, non-tech schooling, travel, no high tech work for years before that). Must be hard to reach out to the kind of people Google does like to hire. My old friends from that group are always busy.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- alecco 16y agoFWIW, most jobs at Google or any other big corp are very boring and menial. And you have to deal with politics.
- Stormbringer 16y agoPolitics is what happens when three or more people get together to make a decision. It doesn't matter who you are, that is still true. The only way to avoid it is to work exclusively for yourself, and also somehow avoid all contact with customers. Good luck with that, and may the ramen noodles be with you, always.
- alecco 16y agoI'm just saying a random position at Google isn't that important. So IMHO, WildUtah shouldn't feel bad because he doesn't fit some stupid profile.
- Stormbringer 16y ago"no regular job for a few years," Given your situation, and the fact that going to a couple of interviews is enormously low-risk compared to the potential reward, maybe you should say yes to the Google recruiters? What is the worst case scenario here? Also, maybe they heard (through the grapevine) that you do good work. Stranger things have happened. :D
- Stormbringer 16y agoTries to say something encouraging and gets voted down. Nice. @grief-voter: WTF dude? Care to explain?
- dtby 16y agoI'd like to be able to consider it but I'm not in their candidate pool (around forty, no regular job for a few years, non-tech schooling, travel, no high tech work for years before that). I am not in their candidate pool, either by your standards. Quickly approaching forty, dropped out of 'society' for 5+ years, non-high tech work during that period, no Ivy League degree. And, yet, despite the fact that I have made -exceptionally- clear that I have no interest in working at their company, they will not stop recruiting me. I think you should go for it and put in that application. It's way more likely that they want you to work there than that you want to work for them.
- alecco 16y agoThis is terrible advice. Going through Google HR's meat grinder you have a small probability to get in. The process is quite random and it takes a lot of time and energies from you. Don't gamble on 1/10. Most likely, you'll feel like crap for nothing. And don't listen to the 1/10ers, they often rationalize and are fooled by selection bias.
- dtby 16y agothey often rationalize and are fooled by selection bias. Assuming you are talking about me, that's crazy. I have asked, literally, a handful of times that they never contact me again. It might be selection bias, but it's not rationalization and it's not fooling me. It's annoying the crap out me. I hope they go bother someone who is interested in working there.
- alecco 16y ago> Assuming you are talking about me Er, no. You implied you are not a googler. Perhaps I was talking to you.
- djb_hackernews 16y agoHmm I wonder what put you on their radar?
- mkramlich 16y agoKudos to Google for making this change. Sounds like they're reacting to feedback.
- klochner 16y agoGod bless the manhole cover problem. That's been making the rounds for over a decade.
- alecco 16y agoI don't like those problems. IMHO, they encourage rationalizing things that probably just evolved/happened over time. The real answer for me is because no better shape happened or showed to be significantly better. Also, since almost all follow the same shape, it's harder for other shapes to enter the market. Winner takes all.
- stcredzero 16y agoIt's not arbitrary. "Because it can't fall in the hole" is a compelling geometric and safety reason. The circular manhole cover is the simplest shape that has this property.
- notahacker 16y agoThe reasons for making the access tunnel beneath cylindrical in shape are actually far more compelling (remove less material and create a stronger hole). Nevertheless, rectangular manhole covers are pretty common.
- stcredzero 16y agoNevertheless, rectangular manhole covers are pretty common. I never claimed the market was perfect. I find that perfect omniscient markets a terrible assumption to base analysis on. The combination of superior cover safety and superior tunnel structure are pretty compelling, but not everyone chooses the optimal solution. That's just not how humans operate.
- EdiX 16y agoGod bless its resilience to all the non-round manholes around the world.
- 16y ago
- bkhl 16y agoI went through 8 interviews (over the course of 8 months) before I got an offer from Google. By the time Google gave me the offer, I already accepted an offer from the other company. I told the HR of Google that their process sucks (of course, I said it indirectly) and she agreed with me. I'm glad to hear that Google is finally making changes here.
- Stormbringer 16y agoAre they still limiting it to only PhDs and Masters? That to me always struck me as their biggest mistake. The common perception from people in the industry is that many of the best programmers are self taught. That doesn't preclude doing a degree of course, however even the really good programmers I've met that did degrees say that they really ramped up their learning efforts after leaving university (and that was my experience too).
- galactus 16y agoI don't think they ever limited to only PhDs/Masters (I have 3 friends working for google, none of them holds a phd or masters degree)
- Stormbringer 16y agoThey did in the early days. Good to know they've unbent a little on that as well. Of course it then begs the question "how then do you hire good programmers?". Solving that problem would be really interesting (my pay might go up :D )
- jakevoytko 16y agoI work at Google, and have a BS in CS from The College of New Jersey. So if they ever filtered on graduate degrees or prestigious schools, it's no longer the case. In fact, your description of a self-taught programmer fits me pretty well.
- dalore 16y agoNo they asked me to interview even though I dropped out of uni for my bachelors.
- arkitaip 16y ago"The new approach includes a new “rule of five” that limits the number of interviews a candidate can attend to no more than that number, said Laszlo Bock, head of human resources. In the past, would-be Googlers were often subjected to 12-14 interviews, he added." Wow, they actually consider 5 interviews to be a lean approach to interviewing; no wonder their process is convoluted. Methinks Google seriously needs to rethink their org structure.
- noamsml 16y agoWell, depends on how you count. Is 4 one-two hour interviews by different people on the same day considered one interview or four? (Assuming, of course, a preliminary phone interview would constitute the fifth)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- durin42 16y agoI don't think Google does interviews longer than 45 minutes for engineering.
- rozim 16y agoA normal onsite interview is 45 mins and yes, a normal start is the phone screen which counts as an interview too. I work at Google and have interviewed O(250) people there.
- olegrog 16y ago5 would generally mean you do one 45 minute phone screen and one in-person interview where you meet with 4 people for 45 minutes each. Given the cost of a bad hire, I personally don't think that's enough.
- EnderMB 16y agoIf I'm perfectly honest, the reason I haven't applied to companies like Google is because their process scares me. I studied at a modest university and achieved a good degree, but the kind of horror stories I hear make me firmly believe that I received a terrible education, because the level of employees they seem to attract (Jon Skeet, anyone?) are a class apart from myself. It didn't help that the university next door, a top ten institution, was regularly visited by the likes of Google.
- alecco 16y agoDon't let them make you feel like that. What matters is what you make and how you interact with people around you. I've met geniuses who don't make anything interesting out of their lives. They just play mind games and show off. Nobody really likes them or their "high standards." Usually they just criticize everybody and everything in some way or another, instead of helping out. And they are often lazy, covering themselves by stating things are not "challenging" or worthy of their highness. They remind me of those rich guys with sports cars. They wouldn't win any race. What matters is how you do with what you have. The house of cards of arrogants falls down if enough people just ignore them. Like the typical high school hotness scenario. My ideal hiring test: - What do you code for fun? - How do you help people around you? - Favorite non-fiction books? - Would you like to come over for a hackathon next saturday? Edit: I know one counter-example within Google, though. YMMV
- dtby 16y agoI attended a "modest" university. I am not Internet famous. I am old. Google will not leave me alone for all of the times I have told them "I am not interesting in working at your company." I think they assume I am kidding. It's my experience that if you really want to work there they probably want you.
- bane 16y agoI'm personally more concerned with the huge time-waste of the interview process, then getting a rejection after all that. (I'm also concerned about their discriminatory hiring practices -- selecting principally from specific schools rather than looking at individual candidates)
- sliverstorm 16y agoToo bad they won't ask about manhole covers anymore. I figured that one out on my own a long, long time ago. (free points!) P.S. If you know why they make them round, then do you know why they don't make them triangular? ;)
- eliben 16y agoI'm pretty sure a triangular one can fall down its hole if tilted properly.
- suraj 16y agoOldie http://hebig.org/blog/003029.php http://hebig.org/blog/003029.php
- StavrosK 16y agoI think so too, but how? It doesn't seem like there's a distance in an equilateral triangle longer than its edge.
- krschultz 16y agoThey can't. First off, there will be a small lip to keep it from falling in flat. This means that the hole is actually smaller than the manhole cover by an inch or more. Second, no matter how you orient an equilateral triangle with on point facing down the hole, there is an edge across the top that is too big to fall in. The way to visualize this, if you take one edge of an equilateral triangle and sweep it in a circle around one end, it will be outside of the triangle at all points except where the corners meet. So trying to drop it in any position other than with the edges lined up will make it impossible to fall through. And since there is a lip when the edges line up, it can't fall through. In contrast with a square or rectangle, if you sweep one of the edges it will be inside of the square or rectangle at some points (on a rectangle, you have to use the small sides). This means all you have to do is shove one edge of the cover down the hole and it will fall in.
- michaelcampbell 16y ago
- darren_ 16y agoI did > 8 interviews with Google and never encountered anything resembling manhole/ping-pong ball problems; this was more than two years ago and my friends who've interviewed since haven't mentioned them either. Still, limiting the number of interviews to 5 or so is at the very least a positive step towards reducing the chance of people meeting someone from what steve yegge calls their "interview anti-loop" (see: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2008/03/get-that-job-at-google.html http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2008/03/get-that-job-at-goog...; short version - sets of interviewers whose favourite subjects/questions happen to not overlap with your particular specialities, and will therefore have a much dimmer view of your talents than differently focused colleagues). Also, a problem with many many interviews is it's even harder for a candidate who has been given no significant post-rejection feedback to figure out what needed improvement or where you weren't a good fit; I'm reduced to speculating that maybe number 7 was a bit iffy? Or maybe 4 and 7?
- brown9-2 16y agoI have a feeling the spokesperson in the interview is describing interviews for positions other than software engineering. It's been well known that Google doesn't ask brainteaser-type questions for it's SE positions. Positions like Product Manager on the other hand are a different story.
- Nitramp 16y agoWhen I interviewed some months ago, I had one telephone interview and five on-site interviews. If I understood them correctly, some candidates also go through a second telephone interview. So a maximum of seven if you include phone interviews. The interviews were quite challenging (and of increasing difficulty), but there was nothing even resembling a trick question or a mind teaser. I researched a bit before the interviews, and credible results consistently said that Google always had a policy against such questions. I wonder how the head of HR can then talk about it as if they were asking such questions recently? All in all, the hiring process was challenging and exhausting, but never felt unfair or sloppy/undirected.
- groys 16y agoI had a similar experience, 2 telephonics and 4 on-site interviews. This is a blog post from an ex-googler and it explicitly mentions the manhole question was banned. http://www.technologywoman.com/2010/05/17/debunking-the-google-interview-myth/ http://www.technologywoman.com/2010/05/17/debunking-the-goog...
- mbarr 16y agoEngineering has been good at getting rid of trick questions, but some other groups still use them.
- Bossman 16y ago75,000 applications a week? Guess I shouldn't be surprised with how big of a company Google is, but still crazy to see that number.
- Stormbringer 16y agoBy my rough calculations they're hiring 1 person for every 650 applications. That's quite the winnowing process. If they have two pre-qualifying rounds of CV burning where at each stage they trash 80% of the CVs, then they'd be down to about 26 before even talking to anyone. Now four rounds of interviews where 50% of the people are eliminated and you still have 1.625 people left...
- larsberg 16y agoWe used to have ridiculous numbers like that at MSFT. If Google is reporting them the same way, they're not counting re-applications and people who are completely unqualified and either hoping for a lottery win or are just satisfying some unemployment requirement. Seriously, the recruiting folks told me that the vast majority of the "blind submit" resumes that came in via e-mail and website forms were unchanged duplicates of things already in the database.
- michaelcampbell 16y agoI may be misremembering, but I think that figure was the record high; it's not an ongoing rate.
- booduh 16y agoJust wait. Soon, they'll put shit (err-- a chip) in your brain, then follow you around for 6 months. "Its just a trial."
- spartanfan10 16y agoThey would probably be more successful in their university recruiting if they didn't wait until January to start making contact.
- flyt 16y agoThis headline should really be "Google lowers the bar"
- 16s 16y agoThey still ask silly questions. It's almost like Jeopardy for Nerds. * Convert decimal 11 to binary. * How many bits are in Unix permissions. * What does set UID mean. * How do you rm a file named -f * How are hard links different from soft links * What does const mean * More and more Jeopardy for Geeks questions It was like a Unix/C trivia game. No reasonable person would name a file -f (but that's beside the point)...it's just fun thinking of all the ways you could remove it if you ever had to.
- olegrog 16y agoThey may have been considering you for a "site reliability engineer" position, which requires knowing these types of things. I've been involved in ~100 Google interviews and I've never seen questions like this in a SWE interview.
- jmillikin 16y agoFunny, I got those sort of questions on my first phone screen, and I called them "pulse-checkers". As in, checking the candidate has a pulse and hasn't blatantly lied on their resume. I would expect anyone who's been through a CS101-level class to do small decimal<->binary conversions in their head, and anyone who's administered a UNIX system to know how to terminate an option list.