3 ms·
I worked sub-minimum wage for a decade or so; I don't think poverty is an impediment to creativity. It is an impediment to using that creativity (particularly t
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
I worked sub-minimum wage for a decade or so; I don't think poverty is an impediment to creativity. It is an impediment to using that creativity (particularly to generate value and/or income), however.
Not disagreeing, just trying to add some complexion.
- Hoasi 7y ago> I don't think poverty is an impediment to creativity. Poverty may even trigger creativity at times. But stress is the major impediment, and therefore living in long-term poverty does not favor sustained creativity.
- vidarh 7y agoSome creativity is "cheap entertainment" in the sense that much of it requires little material wealth to engage in, and that might sometimes spur creativity simply out of lack of alternatives. When I lived on next to nothing when I was younger, it was easy to focus on writing because I didn't have money to e.g. go out on the town. Reading back what I wrote, though, a lot of it seemed to be extremely introspective of my situation to the extent that I'd be embarrassed to let anyone read it even if it had been any good. I grew up in Norway; incidentally, one of the most famous Norwegian novels is the semi-autobiographical "Sult" (literally "Hunger") by Knut Hamsun, describing a young writers descent into madness as the hunger grips him as he wanders around in what is now Oslo. But I've also seen the flip side, where you spend so much time worrying about money or acquiring a semblance of security that everything else gets pushed aside.
- Hoasi 7y agoHunger, by Knut Hamsun, is an excellent read, it describes with dry humor what starvation does to the author's psyche and creativity. He goes from creative bursts of enthusiasm to the darkest moments of depression, from eviction to high hopes of getting published. Never at peace, but always hoping and trying. Recommended reading.
- pjmorris 7y agoHumans are creative, and they apply that creativity to their present circumstances. I'm reminded of John Adams here: "I must study politics and war, that our sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy. Our sons ought to study mathematics and philosophy, geography, natural history and naval architecture, navigation, commerce and agriculture in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, statuary, tapestry and porcelain.”
- palerdot 7y agoYou are right. JK Rowling of harry potter comes to my mind when I read your comment ... In one of her commencement speeches she will draw attention to this exact same point ...
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIsn't it important to look for trends rather than standouts? Just because JK Rowling, who is an extraordinary success story, made it doesn't mean others will, because otherwise JK Rowling wouldn't be extraordinary.
- palerdot 7y agoActually I was agreeing with the point that being poor does not impede creative thinking. I agree with your point too that JK Rowling has an extraordinary sucess story. But then again, we will never know about extremely creative yet poor people who are struggling to make ends meet and wasting their precious mental energy on things others take for granted. But that does not discredit the original point (to which I was agreeing), that being poor is not an impediment to creativity.
- zentiggr 7y agoI see a distinction between a basic creativity, i.e. how do i finagle the best existence out of this set of circumstances, cleverness, I suppose, and a fundamental creativity, the more artistic, unfettered by everyday concerns. Like Maslow's hierarchy of needs... generally people have to expend their creative thought on how to provide for themselves before they have the opportunity to use that thought in more expansive ways. Do a Dan Price and you jump start people's ability to settle the lower levels of needs and be able to make more choices.