5 ms·
Switzerland, most democratic country in the world, reminding people that it isn't just the authoritarians who know how to keep organised. It is very hard to un
by roenxi 7y ago
Switzerland, most democratic country in the world, reminding people that it isn't just the authoritarians who know how to keep organised.
It is very hard to understand how democracies work; it is important to keep an eye on how these things play out.
- philshem 7y agoIt's also a highly federal democracy, with Cantons being considered "sovereign"[0]. So it's not to be taken lightly that the federal government has taken such steps. Several questions in the press conference have been about the Cantons specifically[1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantons_of_Switzerland#Constitutions_and_powers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantons_of_Switzerland#Constit... [1] https://www.bag.admin.ch/bag/en/home/krankheiten/ausbrueche-epidemien-pandemien/aktuelle-ausbrueche-epidemien/novel-cov.html https://www.bag.admin.ch/bag/en/home/krankheiten/ausbrueche-...
- CaptainZapp 7y agoWell, as a Swiss I can only state for the record that the government is not the enemy. Essentially: The government is us.
- short_sells_poo 7y agoSwiss resident (but not Swiss citizen) here. I believe Switzerland is a very unique case in that the Swiss have a culture of local (ie. Canton and Commune) level decision making via direct democracy. You grow up wielding a certain power, and you know your decisions matter and will affect your everyday life. This ingrains a close relationship between the citizens and their representatives. What I'm trying to say is that I don't think it is possible to just take the Swiss model and transplant it elsewhere. It requires a multi-generational cultural conditioning to develop the civic mind that the Swiss have nurtured. It is also not clear how scalable it is ultimately. It requires a certain amount of enlightenment without which the system would not work.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoI agree and you do raise a very important point. One of the hall marks of the Swiss system is to push as much power as possible to as locally as possible. Communities have a lot of power in their decision making as long as such decisions do not violate cantonal (state) or federal laws. It demands, though, quite intense interaction with policies and referendums (there are usually about three referendums about various subjects on local, cantonal and federal level per year) and that said, I would wish that there would be more engagement and a higher ratio of voters actually going to the polls.
- RajuVarghese 7y agoIt also requires a certain willingness to compromise. In Switzerland one sees is all the way from the local government (gemeinde) up to the top (the federal level). Compromise is not a dirty word here; when politicians do it they are not (usually) looked at as 'giving in to the enemy'.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoThat's an extremely insightful comment and very true. Not that it's universally adhered to by all proponents, but generally that's very much the understanding how the system should work. As a for example: Switzerland has a "president". But that doesn't really matter since that changes annually and another member of the federal council gets to be president. Except representative the "president" is not more powerful than any other member of the council.
- PetitPrince 7y agoTo further clarify: The president have mostly a ceremonial and diplomatic role. What is considered the Head of the Executive Branch in other countries is collectively represented here by the Federal Council. The Council is made of 7 peoples elected proportionally from the various political party by the Federal Assembly (== parliement). The Council should also by picked so that all regions of Switzerland are represented.
- jariel 7y ago
- raxxorrax 7y agoThe level of support, organization and acceptance you get if it was "your decision" cannot be replicated by authoritarian governments at all.
- Angostura 7y agoI've always found Switzerland pretty authoritarian. Try hang out your washing on the wrong day of the week/in the wrong place.
- chinathrow 7y agoThat anecdote has nothing in common how the swiss gov/democracy works though.
- vstm 7y agoExactly, there are no laws against being a Bünzli.
- _trampeltier 7y agoYes, but a the same time that is the reason, why we have no Elon Musk in switzerland.
- auiya 7y agoIs that a bad thing?
- chinathrow 7y agoAgain, how are these two statements even remotely correlated? Asking for a Bünzli.
- underlines 7y agoThat's fine. They have hundrets of Elon Musks who innovate. https://www.globalinnovationindex.org/gii-2019-report https://www.globalinnovationindex.org/gii-2019-report
- halest 7y agoSo what would happen? You would get punished for causing inconvenience to a person who had a right to hang their washing on that day? Sounds very reasonable, how is that authoritarian?
- config_yml 7y agoThere's a law for that and it's democratically legitimized: https://www.admin.ch/opc/de/classified-compilation/20071012/index.html#a40 https://www.admin.ch/opc/de/classified-compilation/20071012/...
- deepaksurti 7y agoSwitzerland is a rare example of a country with instruments of direct democracy (at the levels of the municipalities, cantons, and federal state), excerpted from [1] which has more details of how Switzerland implements direct democracy in pure format and in combination with federal structures. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy#Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy#Switzerland
- teekert 7y agoPeople are elected to make decisions for us. We hold them responsible at the next election. That is the currently what democracy is.
- mikl 7y agoHow’s that working for ya? Democracies where the people only have a voice every few years are regularly seen doing things against the will of the people, because the politicians know they can get away with it, because it’ll be forgotten by the time the next election comes around.
- _xoo 7y agoIt's working great. In Switzerland we do not only have elections every few years but we can also (directly) vote on issues from all three legal jurisdictions (municipality, canton or federal level) multiple times a year. Thus, we not only have a democracy but a direct democracy.
- teekert 7y agoWhat would be the alternative?
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> Switzerland, most democratic country in the world, reminding people that it isn't just the authoritarians who know how to keep organised. So a democratic country is just as authoritarian as "authoritarians"? > It is very hard to understand how democracies work It really isn't. It's been around for many millenia ostensibly going all the way back to the slave owning ancient greeks. And historically, democracies have proven to veer toward totalitarianism. Something even Plato recognized thousands of years ago. It's funny how we conveniently forget that even nazi germany rose from a democracy. There is nothing inherently good about democracies. After all, democracies have exterminated continents full of people, democracies have practiced race-based slavery and the only form of government to have nuked civilians is a democracy. Hell democracies have attacked and destroyed more democracies around the world than authoritarians have. Instead of focusing on silly labels, why not focus on deeds/actions/results/etc.
- lm28469 7y ago> There is nothing inherently good about democracies. Besides the fact that we naturally evolved toward them since everything else we tried so far was worse ? And the fact that people are fleeing authoritarian regimes risking their lives to get into democratic ones daily yet the opposite never happened ? > After all, democracies have exterminated continents full of people, democracies have practiced race-based slavery and the only form of government to have nuked civilians is a democracy. Hell democracies have attacked and destroyed more democracies around the world than authoritarians have. When you put lions in cages they're still lions. > Instead of focusing on silly labels, why not focus on deeds/actions/results/etc. Right, open an history book and it'll be painfully obvious that the vast majority of authoritarian regimes are worse than being "not inherently good". > It's funny how we conveniently forget that even nazi germany rose from a democracy. It's neither funny nor forgotten. It's also pretty clear germany and their neighbours weren't better off after being under dictatorship. It's almost as if desperate times lead to desperate measures... more than democracy leading to authoritarianism. > the only form of government to have nuked civilians is a democracy. The US is as far away as you can get from democracy and still call it a democracy.
- 7y ago
- jotm 7y agoTo be fair, it's very democratic (is it the most?), not very free. Living there you have to put up with all sorts of restrictions that may seem overzealous for someone from, say, Eastern Europe. And they have the same ridiculous bureaucracy (unlike the UK, for example).