6 ms·
Unfortunately a lot of these measures, it seems, are brought up because they’re “photogenic”, they lend themselves to inculcation of kids (like banning straws).
by mc32 7y ago
Unfortunately a lot of these measures, it seems, are brought up because they’re “photogenic”, they lend themselves to inculcation of kids (like banning straws).
But, in the end it has very minimal impact on the effects we’re trying to suppress but on the other hand is very good at getting people used to doing things without thinking through issues independently. It primes kids for ready-made ideology.
- rebuilder 7y ago"First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then they make token concessions and pretend you win."
- swiley 7y agoIsn’t that what they said about theranos?
- dkdk8283 7y agoI agree most of this is just a feel good campaign. Banning plastic straws infuriates me. Paper straws are trash. I carry my own plastic ones and use them as needed.
- liotier 7y agoWhat country do you live in ? Are straws necessities there ? I live in France and I can't remember the last time I used a straw - must have been a couple of years ago...
- swiley 7y agoI tried drinking coffee through a straw one summer because it’s supposed to protect your teeth. I’m pretty sure I’m at a greater risk of throat cancer now, and other than that I’m not too sure why you would want them.
- nkrisc 7y agoIf that's a concern, the more practical solutions are to 1) brush your teeth after drinking coffee or 2) don't drink coffee. I do choose to drink coffee and don't brush immediately after and accept the risk to my teeth. I was worried about the effect of soda on my teeth so I stopped drinking it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pnutjam 7y agohot drinks != use straw cold drinks = use straw
- KoftaBob 7y agoWhich is why it's not recommended to use a straw with hot beverages, only cold ones.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoStraws were originally introduced for public health reasons, so that your mouth need not touch a surface previously touched by someone else's mouth (and which was not well-cleaned). I'm not aware of any studies confirming or denying their advantage in the era of modern food safety standards.
- pnutjam 7y agoMy teeth hurt if I drink icy beverages without a straw. I think it can also contribute to tooth staining, and probably cavities if it's a sugary drink.
- danaris 7y agoThere are people with disabilities that make it difficult to impossible for them to drink without using a straw. Until plastic straws were banned, they were transparently accommodated by the existing systems. Now, they're shamed for or outright prevented from using the accessibility devices that allow them to actually, y'know, consume necessary and lifegiving liquid.
- poulsbohemian 7y agoSo in what way have you been harmed then, if you are using a reusable straw rather than one that would otherwise end up in a landfill or require recycling? We have metal and silicon ones we use - chances are our family will never need a disposable plastic or paper straw ever again, so I fail to see how we’ve been harmed in this ban.
- nkrisc 7y agoAt the same time, I don't miss them. Turns out that I never really needed them in the first place. Sure, some people might need them, but I imagine the vast majority of people don't really need to use a straw.
- ganstyles 7y agoSame. All cold brew coffee lately seems to come without straws and I don't miss them. I do carry around a reusable straw, one of the singular swag items from a conference that I've used. It's really a small trade-off from what, for me, must have been 1000 plastic straws used annually.
- prepend 7y agoYou drink 3 cold brew coffees a day? Your environmental impact would be so much better just skipping one coffee a week than all of your plastic straw usage. This is what bothers me is that it prohibits me from using straws for a nonissue.
- Tyr42 7y agoIt's a bit unfortunate for people with mobility issues who needed straws though. They benefited from it being a common thing and how they'll need to pack their own or something.
- JohnClark1337 7y agoMost restaurants in my area still use plastic straws. I think most people have forgotten about that and moved on to something else to be pissed about.
- downerending 7y agoIt's not just useless. At least one person has already been killed by a reusable straw. (Fell on metal one while using.)
- jgwil2 7y agoWhere exactly were plastic straws "banned?" As far as I know, the ban was on providing them without their being specifically requested.
- SllX 7y agoSan Francisco. Non-plastic straws only (so paper or even bamboo is fine), although there are a few businesses trying to work through their existing plastic stock on the down low.
- gamblor956 7y agoSanta Monica also has a complete ban on plastic straws, and LA City has a ban on providing them to dine-in customers unless specifically requested (https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-plastic-straws-20190301-story.html https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-plastic-straws-...). LA County has a similar rule but allows for the business to ask the customer if they want a plastic straw.
- standardUser 7y agoThat one-time use plastic straw - an object that no one strictly needs and has many alternatives - will persist in the environment indefinitely and will cause harm to ecosystems. You can think that's OK (I guess), but you can't pretend that preventing permanent harmful waste is only about feeling good. It's about preventing permanent harmful waste. Feeling good can be a little bonus I suppose.
- dkdk8283 7y agoI absolutely can think it’s ok. I purchase and properly dispose of single use plastic items. Nothing wrong with that.
- lopmotr 7y agoNo it won't if it's in a properly managed landfill. This is the misconception that anti-plastic fanatics have. Plastic doesn't kill fish when it's trapped underground forever. Straws in the ocean were dumped there by careless people. Since you care about the environment, there's no way you're using a paper straw so you can continue dropping it into the stormwater drain without the problems that you used to cause when you dropped plastic straws into the drain. The very people who choose paper straws are the ones that can't make any difference because they weren't the problem in the first place.
- poulsbohemian 7y agoWhy is causing people - kids or otherwise - to contemplate their footprint on the earth or their impact to other people a bad thing? I’ve never been a straw user, but frankly we bought some reusable metal straws (my partner uses them), some reusable portable utensils, and regularly carry our portable coffee cups when we go out in public. All things that can fit in a purse or bag. We don’t find it an inconvenience and we like that perhaps in a small way we are reducing the amount of generated waste.
- mc32 7y agoStraws are neither here nor there. More power to you on whatever choice you make. The point is these measures solidify indoctrination. Let us tell you what to do. “We’ll think it through for you. Here is what’s good.” And as kids grow up they grow up trusting these voices telling them what’s best for them. It undercuts their critical thinking skills. It’s one big “YEA”. Rarely are they asked to follow the rabbit hole or all the unintended consequences. But it makes people feel good about “having agency” and “doing good”.
- chimprich 7y agoIt seems to me that at least as big a problem in today's world is too much scepticism. Most of the time, the experts are correct. People question the science on climate change, the benefits of vaccination, whether the moon landings happened, whether the Earth is round, all based on the flimsiest of evidence.
- ganstyles 7y agoMy understanding is that a lot of people had this attitude when seatbelts were first introduced as being required for vehicles. And I see it now with respect to things like straws and mandatory bicycle helmet laws. It has always come across to me as very, "Old man yells at cloud" talk. Eventually you or your children won't even miss straws and the world will be better off for having banned them. We all play a part in making things better and it's very hard to argue that not being able to use straws is a bar thing.
- gamblor956 7y agoPeople like to pick on straw bans but the reason they're a thing is because plastic straws represent a substantial portion of the trash found on beaches and in waterways. And like plastic trash bags, plastic straws don't degrade, they just get ground up into smaller and smaller pieces. They can also choke fish and birds if they get caught in the throats, or poke holes in the stomachs/guts of fish and birds. Plastic straw bans may not make much sense in the Midwest, but they do matter in coastal areas.
- prepend 7y ago> substantial portion of the trash found on beaches and in waterways I don’t think do. What makes you think that. Unless you consider 1% substantial.
- coral-snake 7y agoLooking at the composition of the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, plastic straws don't qualify as a line-item in this[1] 2014 study (either by mass or count). 70.4% of the mass found in the gyre is from fishing-related items (with a whopping 58.3% of mass from fishing buoys alone). [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4262196/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4262196/
- gamblor956 7y agoI didn't say ocean. I said beaches. Straws and plastic bags are targeted because they are the low hanging fruit that is easy to change. Because people are highly resistant to change, even when it's just a mild inconvenience, and addressing a small part of the problem is better than doing nothing at all.