5 ms·
> Isn't there something like court transcripts I don't believe you can get these in real time. You can apply for them afterwards, or you can go and listen for
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> Isn't there something like court transcripts
I don't believe you can get these in real time. You can apply for them afterwards, or you can go and listen for yourself, as this person did.
In the UK we generally don't go in for blow-by-blow realtime reporting of court cases, like they do in the US.
> doesn't this effectively mean that a judge can do this anytime without consequences?
Judges in the UK are appointed professionals - they aren't elected as in many places in the US, so they aren't pursuing an agenda or appealing to an electorate. Judges going rogue isn't a problem in practice.
- mcherm 7y ago> Judges in the UK are appointed professionals - they aren't elected as in many places in the US, so they aren't pursuing an agenda or appealing to an electorate. Judges going rogue isn't a problem in practice. I think in this very case the judge clearly IS pursuing an agenda. It may be a government-approved agenda, but it is clearly an agenda separate from the even-handed pursuit of justice.
- mantap 7y agoJudges do sometimes have agendas. But that is exactly why higher courts exist. This particular case is shaping up to be appealed all the way to UK Supreme Court, these initial hearings are just practice sessions for both sides to hone their arguments.
- fareesh 7y agoThey can still have a personal agenda or be intimidated to pursue an agenda, or be incentivised to pursue an agenda. If the transcript exists it ought to be made available quickly to the public. If it's a matter of fees, there ought to be a way of paying in advance for the transcript for a particular day, unless I'm missing something that's unique to the transcription process that makes it less feasible than I'm imagining it to be.
- wil421 7y agoExplain to me how being appointed by someone makes you any less bias them being elected. Most states have non-partisan elections for Judges, only 18 allow then to run with a political party. Federal Judges are appointed and about 90% of state judges are elected. There have only been 2 Federal judges that have been impeached since 1989.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Explain to me how being appointed by someone makes you any less bias them being elected. Because you generally don't need to be re-appointed. You generally do need to be re-elected. In order to be re-elected you need to please the electorate, rather than do the 'right thing' (whatever that is.) This can create a conflict of interest, such as judges prioritising 'being tough on crime' over the facts of cases.
- wil421 7y agoThe Supreme Court justices are all appointed. It’s a huge deal politically because the current president will pick someone from their party. They generally vote in line with their party. I completely understand your point. One thing I will ad is with elections you can change your mind over time. With an appointee you are stuck with their views for an unknown amount of time usually until they retire or die.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> someone from their party That seems like basically an extension of election then, as you're electing someone who then appoints someone from their party. Judges in the UK (source of this article) are never part of a party - they're politically neutral. Judges in the Supreme Court aren't even allowed to vote in normal elections themeselves (they're lords.)
- tialaramex 7y agoAlthough a modern day Supreme Court judge is automatically referred to as Lord/ Lady, the peerage that would otherwise grant that title and forbids them from voting is not automatic. The Supreme Court are no longer Lords in fact as they were when they had the title "Lords of Appeal in Ordinary" and worked across the road in the House of Lords. All current Supreme Court justices have a peerage, but in principle a disapproving Government could just tell Liz not to give them a peerage and they wouldn't get one. Whereas all the elected Government can do about a choice of new Justice itself is say "No" and ask the committee to pick again, the committee isn't obliged to do anything except pick the same person again - which would be a very pointed rebuke. So far of course no government has done that but the UK Supreme Court is young and these are interesting times.